Pages

Showing posts with label brands. Show all posts
Showing posts with label brands. Show all posts

Friday, 5 June 2015

Visa - a strong brand business: so what price to buy?

Last week I observed (link here) that Visa was not only a top global brand...


...but also had a high brand value as per the BrandZ analysis versus its market cap level.

I have written about Visa before with my analysis last year starting off like this:

'Visa is well-known to most investors.  As consumers we see the logo on our credit or debit cards...


...but the reality is the company is the business makes its money as an integrated global payments technology company operating in almost all countries around the world (with the end product as the consumer using their debit/credit card)'

Since then the company has split its shares (4:1 on March 18th this year) but the stock on an adjusted basis has continued to perform well...


...including de facto market share growth 


Looking at the recent metrics the company continues to grow at either side of a double digit level which with operational leverage and related turns into a low teens ebit growth and proportional cash accumulation.

Of course there are plenty of structural reasons for this with the very high purchase transactions market share helping to form a high barrier to entry...


...and the structural shift towards credit/debit cards (still) and - of course - e-payments...


Underlying operational metrics in the last quarter reported were fairly solid as you would expect given the above...
...as was the guidance...more teens growth and a number for free cash flow generation.  
So what value (or valuation) this profile?  Of course one measure is a 5% free cash flow yield which would imply a US$120bn market cap or a share price of US$50 (fascinatingly equivalent to the US$200 'buy point' of the pre-split Visa report linked above).  

How about an earnings related measure? Structural growth and a strong balance sheet suggests to me a forward x16 EV/ebit level which would imply a 'buy' price of around US$60 or below a share.  

Finally technically I note the importance of the US$65 level. 

So...a flag at US$65 but with more value factors kicking in at US$60, then US$55 and finally US$50.  The latter three levels sounds like a trading strategy to me...

Monday, 1 June 2015

The top 100 brands in the world (part 3)

After looking through the top quarter of the amazing BrandZ top 100 brands in the world analysis over a couple of postings (link here and here) in this part of the analysis I will look at the brands ranked 26-55:


As in parts 1 and 2 I am going to compare brand value to EV (market cap plus net debt) and see what proportion of this EV can be attributed to the brand value per se and what proportion is more...operational.  The broad rule of thumb is that a high brand value of a company's EV may highlight value...especially if that brand value is going up. 

So what are the results? (brand value shown as a % of total company EV).  I am not going to show all the companies this time as unlike the top 25 there are starting to be a number of private entities (e.g. Subway) as well as brands which are just part of a broader business (e.g. Pampers, Gillette).  

So what are the five most striking companies on a brand value shown as a % of total company EV basis?

Hermes 48.7%
Starbucks 37.5%
FedEx 36.7%
BMW 36.4%
Nike 35.7%

Interestingly compared to parts 1 and 2 where I filtered at 40%+ only one name (Hermes) attained that level.  

Fascinatingly (although undoubtedly somewhat influenced by FX shifts) luxury good names have generally seen brand value reductions during the last year:


I wrote about Hermes last year and established a 'buy' price which is currently noticeably lower than the current share level (link here).  Time for another brand level review - to accompany the shares already identified for further analysis in parts 1 and 2. 

As for the other four stocks, well given I have already identified UPS in part 2 I will take FedEx no further.  

Elsewhere (outside Financial Orbit) I have reviewed BMW and noted that:

So one level is the 5% free cash flow yield mark which would suggest a c. Euro107.5 share price as being a noteworthy point.  I would apply though a further discount given the current material weakness of the euro and management guidance re China, hence I would stick with a ‘take profits’ view now, shift to ‘hold’ below Euro100/share and ‘buy’ below Euro90/share.  This would broadly be consistent with moving to ‘hold’ in the x7s EV/ebit FY15e and ‘buy’ in the x6s EV/ebit FY15e’ 

So the share flirting with falling below the Euro100 level is becoming more interesting essentially.  

Otherwise I took a look at Starbucks last year and wanted a lower share price. I will add it to the bottom of the 'high brand / EV' list but I am not compelled.  I will do the same with Nike which I have not formally looked at.  There are more compelling things to look at BUT they filter better on this metric than the norm.  So if there is time as the earnings season wanes...

Friday, 29 May 2015

The top 100 brands in the world (part 2)

After looking through the top tenth of the amazing BrandZ top 100 brands in the world analysis (link here) in this part of the analysis I will look at the brands ranked 11-25:


As in part 1 I am going to compare brand value to EV (market cap plus net debt) and see what proportion of this EV can be attributed to the brand value per se and what proportion is more...operational.  The broad rule of thumb is that a high brand value of a company's EV may highlight value...especially if that brand value is going up (interestingly true for all the above list except Amazon and ICBC).  

So what are the results? (brand value shown as a % of total company EV)

Tencent 40.7%
Facebook 33.7%
Alibaba 30.9%
Amazon 30.9%
China Mobile 29.0%
Wells Fargo 33.9%
General Electric 21.5%
UPS 53.6%
Disney 21.6%
Mastercard 39.6%
Baidu 61.3%
ICBC 13.1%
Vodafone 27.1%
SAP 40.2%
American Express 33.2%

Well that was interesting.  As before here are the top four.  Unlike the top 10 brands only two have over half their market cap covered by their BrandZ brand value:

Baidu 61.3%
UPS 53.6%
Tencent 40.7%
SAP 40.2%

So are these stocks cheap then?

The last time I mentioned Baidu on www.financialorbit.com was back in January when I observed:

'Good graphic on the market share of China's top search companies (I must re-review Baidu again when they have their next set of numbers)...'


Yes, I must review Baidu.  The brand analysis makes this very clear. 

Next up is UPS.  Way back over a year ago I mused that 'any material plunge below US$100' would be a buying opportunity for the important global logistics firm.  


And what have we seen since then?  Well over the last year a share which has been either side of US$100.  That sounds worthwhile reviewing too. 

Tencent I have reviewed recently (link here) and I await a lower share price here.  Interestingly a filter of 50%+ brand value of market cap would have captured a good buying opportunity earlier this year...

Finally, SAP.  It has been a while since I last wrote on the stock on this site but elsewhere I have undertaken some research and was positive after the Q4/FY numbers publication.  At prevailing I am more neutral but again a filter of 50%+ brand value of market cap would have captured a good buying opportunity earlier this year.  Worth noting down.  

From part 1 I observed the need for a review of Visa to be written (and this will be forthcoming later today).  From part 2 my observation is that Baidu and UPS should also be stocks to focus on.  Research thoughts on these two entities will therefore be published in the next few business days.  

Brands: a good filter inspiration for stock pickers.  

(Part 3 will focus on ranks 26-50).  

Wednesday, 27 May 2015

The top 100 brands in the world (part 1)

Brands are intrinsically fascinating and in a competitive and changing world a good source of business strength, protection and profile.  So once again - the same as last year (link here) - I find myself looking at the BrandZ information in today's Financial Times with great interest.


I take the view that brands and brand value can provide great insights for equity analysis and structural shifts.  Take this on regional shifts from the report writers themselves as an example: 

'Chinese brands, of which there are 14 in the Top 100 -- up from just one in 2006 -- are pushing out European brands. Those brands dropped 9.3% in the last year to 24 brands from 35 in 2006. The study said the value of U.S brands grew by 137% in the last 10 years'. 

So what were the results this year and what can we discern.  For a start there was far too much information for one write-up and I will sub-divide the list into a number of parts over the next few days.

Today then the top 10 brands...and what an interesting list they are.  For starters they are all American in heritage.  Second nine of them appeared in last year's top ten which says something about persistence (congratulations Verizon for breaking into the top ten...from eleventh!)



So what can we do with this data...well we can compare it to EV (market cap plus net debt) and see what proportion of this EV can be attributed to the brand value per se and what proportion is more...operational.  The broad rule of thumb is that a high brand value of a company's EV may highlight value...especially if that brand value is going up (interestingly only true of eight of the top ten). 

So what are the results? (brand value shown as a % of total company EV)

Apple 33.5%
Google 56.0%
Microsoft 36.1%
IBM 47.5%
Visa 56.0%
AT&T 33.1%
Verizon 27.6%
Coca-Cola 41.7%
McDonald's 76.2%
Marlboro (aka Altria) 72.2%.  If you also add the PMI market cap this reduces to c. 30%

Well that was interesting.  Here's the top four with usefully over half their market cap covered by their BrandZ brand value:

McDonald's 76.2%
Marlboro (aka Altria) 72.2%.  If you also add the PMI market cap this reduces to c. 30%
Google 56.0%
Visa 56.0%

So are these stocks cheap then?

Well funnily enough I have written about all four reasonably recently.  On McDonald's just a few weeks ago I opined that I would rather eat their burgers at the prevailing share price then buy the share (link here). That's the trouble with a brand value that is high but falling.  

Altria does not have that problem however and this stock has been a hugely successful share for me over the last year or so.  I last wrote about the stock here back in January when I sold half my position.  With the share down a little under 10% since then, this feels justified but the above analysis tells me - just as I concluded back in January - that a sub US$50 print is an opportunity to buy Altria.

As for Philip Morris International I do own the stock and have written positively about it here.  

My view would be for a brand to cover c. 30% of BOTH companies (and when both have other brands too) is quite remarkable.   

Now Google is a stock I own and think is good value at prevailing (see this commentary from April here). Any chance in that sub US$525 share price range is a buying opportunity in my view.  This brand analysis just reinforced that. 

And Visa.  It has been a while since I looked at the stock (around 11 months ago here) and my pre-split share price buy target of sub US$200 ultimately proved too conservative.  That's the way it goes sometimes...but it is time to reassess: the BrandZ analysis has highlighted that for me.  Look out for the updated note and view shortly.   

I have got a feeling many more insights from the BrandZ analysis will be upcoming as I delve further into the list.  

Tuesday, 9 September 2014

Watching McDonald's and thinking about brand value

Back in June I posted about the BrandZ survey I spotted in the Financial Times:



On the last time eleven months ago I did a specific piece of analysis on the company I noted that:

'McDonald's is an annuity-type business.  It is struggling to grow but - as shown in the SG&A fall of 4% in Q3 year-on-year - there are still levers that can be pulled to drive the EPS line.  With a 6%+ free cash flow yield, the next step is for the company to boost their share buyback'

I was reminded of this as today as the company reported some headline lacklustre numbers:

'McDonald's Corporation today announced that global comparable sales decreased 3.7% in August.  Performance by segment was as follows:
  • U.S. down 2.8%
  • Europe down  0.7%
  • Asia/Pacific, Middle East and Africa (APMEA) down 14.5%
"During August, McDonald's global business faced several headwinds that impacted sales performance," said McDonald's President and Chief Executive Officer Don Thompson'
They are striking numbers and mixed trading in the US and specific issues in Russia and (food hygiene influenced) China had the biggest impact.  And it may not be over:

As we continue to assess the impact of the supplier issue in China, we currently estimate that this issue will negatively impact third quarter results by about $0.15 - $0.20 per share in comparison to prior year results.  This is largely due to a combination of lost sales, expenses associated with our recovery efforts and the impact of these items on the third quarter tax rate, which is expected to be above the Company's outlook for the full-year tax rate of 31-33%.  An update on the Company's full-year 2014 financial outlook will be provided in conjunction with McDonald's third quarter earnings release in October.

Not great tone to the above and, unsurprisingly, the share has fallen to around 18 month lows although the share is approximately in the middle of the last three year range.  



What the brand analysis is telling me is that a level - on generalised weakness - to buy McDonald's shares is where the BrandZ brand value covers the entire market cap...which is at about US$87.50.  This would be highly unusual and clearly - when the 2015 report is issued - could be followed by another revision down in the McDonald's brand value.

Here's where the value investor in me is starting to get more interested.  A 3.4% dividend yield, net debt:ebitda of around x1 and good cash flow.  Now the question is whether the company's products are structurally out-of-favour or not and the lagging high brand value is a hoax.  That's where the greater data and comments disclosure in October comes in too.  One to watch.  After all the company is still the world's largest restaurant chain operator.

Monday, 30 June 2014

Asia today - views on China, Australian property market, Indian rainfall, Indonesian election and c-list US brands that are big in China

Asia today starts with a great chart showing who does and who does not like China:


No surprises re the thoughts of big trade beneficiaries such as Brazil, Australia and Russia...nor the views of Japan who hold the least favourable views in the world...

Talking about Australia and China, I thought this was interesting about the Chinese influence on the Australian housing market:

'Foreign investors are likely key drivers of the Sydney and Melbourne housing booms, according to new UBS data, potentially buying up to 40 per cent of all newly constructed homes, and accounting for up to one in eight Australian sales overall...Unprecedented levels of foreign buyer activity, combined with the ability of the $559 billion self-managed super fund sector to leverage its cash five times when making property purchases, could be two reasons why this Australian housing cycle is different to anything we’ve seen before'

But are we at a sentiment high.  This data from FastFT this morning on Australia's property market:

'New home sales down under fell 4.3 per cent in May from the previous month, the first monthly drop in five months, according to a trade body...In a sign that the nation's housing boom may have peaked, multi-unit sales dropped 16 per cent in May from April, signalling that the buy-to-let investors who traditionally buy smaller units are stepping back from the market.'

I remain cautious given previously shown strong historic price appreciation performance and stretched income multiples.

Elsewhere on the last day of the quarter, the Indian rainfall levels have been disappointing...


...time to get to know the potential (surprise) winner of Indonesia's upcoming Presidential election? 


Here's a great profile on Prabowo Subianto with the important observation that:

'To make it more confusing for the observer is that not only is Prabowo a cultural chameleon, but he is also a political chameleon – two very different skills that are not to be confused with each other. The former allows Prabowo to communicate effectively with different audiences, the latter allows him to change political tunes when it suits him'.

A few final facts/links...
                  
As per the People's Daily '2.4 million joined the China's Communist Party in 2013, a decline of 25.5 percent comparing to previous year, for the first time in 10 years'
 
Japanese bond holders should listen to Mr Abe's words (written in today's edition of The Financial Times) that 'without economic revival, there can be no fiscal consolidation'
 
And finally '5 brands that are fancy in China but c-list in the U.S.' (link here).  Good news potentially for Anheuser-Busch InBev and Yum Brands amongst others as I think we know which of the two is the bigger potential growth market...
 
 

Monday, 23 June 2014

Coca-Cola - brand value, takeover rumours and a level to buy with new money

Returning to my irregular series on brand value you may recall that Coca-Cola appeared in the top 10 global brands as per my original replication of the BrandZ data:



'So who stands out if you compare a company's market cap (slight difference with the methodology noted above) with their brand value? Well the top five from the above are:

McDonald's 85.6% (of market cap covered by the BrandZ value)
Altria 81.9%
IBM 56.8%
Visa 48.3%
Coca-Cola 44.7%'

Coca-Cola shares have been quite strong recently and are getting close again to the all-time highs of just over a year ago:


Having been a buyer at US$37 in February (link here) getting on for 15% higher today the valuation is getting harder to justify at a valuation that is pushing x18 EV/ebit. 

Nevertheless there is strong brand backing, good pricing power and truly international distribution/exposure.  There are also...rumours about bid interest. As this article on Seeking Alpha noted:

'Activist investor David Winters is at it again, this time asserting that none other than Warren Buffett may take Coca-Cola private in what would be a bold move, to say the least. You remember Winters from the compensation battle earlier this year, during which he said Coke (KO) executives were planning on diluting shareholders by as much as 15% simply to pay employees. He made waves in airing that concern but nothing came of it; is this time different?'

At a current market cap of US$183bn any deal to take Coca-Cola private would be simply huge and...unsurprisingly this was denied by Warren Buffett (link here). 

I do not place any real value on the takeover rumours on the grounds of the sheer difficulty of co-ordinating a US$200bn+ deal.  So then we go back to fundamentals - albeit with some backing by brand value'.  For new money the support at US$38 is as good a point as any...

Monday, 16 June 2014

IBM's brand value and relative share price attractiveness

I talked about the brand value work by BrandZ (which was published in The Financial Times) last week (link here).  Following on from that work (and appraisal of McDonald's and Altria) I am going to take a look at IBM and then, later today in a separate post, Coca-Cola.  Both of these companies were in the top five names when filtering from the perspective of brand value as a proportion of current market cap.  To recall some statistics from last week:

'McDonald's 85.6% (of market cap covered by the BrandZ value)
Altria 81.9%
IBM 56.8%
Visa 48.3%
Coca-Cola 44.7%'

Turning to IBM first, back in January I noted that:

'A single digit EV/ebit level is back to the mid US$160s share level - or the lowest point since mid-2011 for the shares.  Unless Lenovo overpay or the company gets even more aggressive on returning capital, I struggle to get excited...even if Warren Buffett is on the shareholder list'

Since I wrote these words, Lenovo have progressed with the purchase of the small server business (at an ok price - although the money raised is equivalent to around 1% of their NAV, see here), Warren Buffett remains a shareholders and as for the shares...well they have moved in a c. US$175-200 range and are currently much nearer to the bottom than the top of that range:


What newsflow have we had from IBM over the intervening five months since I last looked at them?  Here are the three key events from my perspective:

Another sale? Press reports that Globalfoundries are "the lead candidate" to buy IBM's chip manufacturing/foundry ops. A source states the unit has been losing as much as $1.5bn/year...
Q1 numbers: As Seeking Alpha put it: 'Though IBM reiterated its 2014 EPS guidance, it was "really reset lower" given the company lowered its full-year tax rate forecast to 20% from 23%...The big issue is IBM's legacy businesses are getting hit by multiple points." '


Analyst day: CFO Martin Schroeter reiterated IBM's EPS target for 2015 of “at least $20”
In combination this does not sound the greatest...

Nevertheless you can make a more optimistic case based on the growth of big data...

...and then the underlying growth of the gross profit margin line (aligned with the US$14bn of free cash flow generated over the last 12 months and US$23bn returned to investors via a combination of buybacks and share repurchases - see above)

 
Progress which is driven by productivity, software and services (in that order) - themes which should continue to accrue especially given some of the M&A activity undertaken by IBM.  

 
 Ultimately I want to see a print in the US$160s for close to that single digit EV/ebit ratio BUT having another look at the story the combination of the growth thematic, gross margin progress, buyback/shareholder return (augmented still be a small net cash position on the balance sheet).  The high brand value is great news for a buy on a bad day story. 
 

Monday, 9 June 2014

The world's largest brands..and thoughts on McDonalds's and Altria

I have been meaning to write up the 'BrandZ top 100 brand rankings' (which appeared in The Financial Times on 21 May) for a couple of weeks now.  I have looked before at brand value related to market capitalisation (see this link for example).  Brands are currently hugely favoured by investors so it is worth looking into the top brand list and comparing it to market cap/EV. 

So how has it done?  In a certainly statistically insignificant study from the top 30 global brands from the Interbrand analysis I identified three groups:

(1) Where brand value exceeded 40% of EV (Coca-Cola, HP, Kellogg's)
(2) Where brand value exceeded 35% of EV but not 40% (Google, McDonald's)
(3) Where brand value exceeded 25% of EV but not 35% (Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, Cisco)

How have they done since the end of September posting...well in a rough and ready piece of analysis:

Group (1) is up around 27.1%
Group (2) is up around 17.9%
Group (3) is up around 16.1%

And the S&P500?  14.8%...

So brands...work?  Well clearly this far too simplistic and narrow a study but there is a bit of theory attached to it. 

So what about the BrandZ survey?  First who were in the top 10?



Some quite interesting trends here including a 20% fall in brand value for Apple (and more modest brand value falls for IBM, McDonald's and Altria (aka Marlboro).  By contrast there were big brand value uplifts at Google, Microsoft, Visa and Amazon. 

So who stands out if you compare a company's market cap (slight difference with the methodology noted above) with their brand value? Well the top five from the above are:

McDonald's 85.6% (of market cap covered by the BrandZ value)
Altria 81.9%
IBM 56.8%
Visa 48.3%
Coca-Cola 44.7%

These are much higher numbers, on average, than the Interbrand equivalents.  Clearly there is a methodological difference in the brand accounting processes but running with the concept that a higher number per se is better than a lower one what should we make of the top five?

Well the better news is that I have a positive view on three of the names currently including both the top two.  McDonald's was actually over the wires today with a sales update which Fast FT described as:

'America is still striking a sour note for McDonald's. The fast food chain reported a 1 per cent decline in same-store sales in the US last month, underlining the struggle chief executive Don Thompson is having in the company's biggest market. Analysts had expected that US sales would rise 0.1 per cent'

On the last time I did a specific piece of analysis on the company I noted that:

'McDonald's is an annuity-type business.  It is struggling to grow but - as shown in the SG&A fall of 4% in Q3 year-on-year - there are still levers that can be pulled to drive the EPS line.  With a 6%+ free cash flow yield, the next step is for the company to boost their share buyback.  The business model is not broken, it is just in a lacklustre economy they will inevitably struggle'

This remains the case...the only difference is that back then the share was trading at the bottom of its US$94-102 range...and now it is trading near the top. 


What the brand analysis is telling me is that the second level - on generalised weakness - to buy McDonald's shares after US$94 is where the BrandZ brand value covers the entire market cap...which is at about US$87.50. 

What about Altria?  Back in April I concluded on the US-based tobacco giant that:

'to expect a US$40+ Altria share price still seems a reasonable expectation.  Add in that 5% dividend yield and that's a solid combination for investors'

Since then the share has performed strongly and has pierced that US$40 level (and moved to new all-time highs):


I got aggressive with the Altria share in the US$34s a couple of times in the last year...and interestingly this is where the BrandZ value analysis suggests the brand approximately covers the company's market cap...interesting. 

As with McDonald's I think there are interim levels to get involved before this (US$36 is x10 EV/ebit, US$38/40 look technically interesting).  Don't be afraid to buy any generalised weakness...but that is not going to help you necessarily make a lot of money buying the share today (although my target for Altria is a x12 EV/ebit valuation or c. US$43.5 with a potential 'kicker' if SABMiller - in which they have a large stake - picks up a bid). 

In the next part I will look at the other top five names. 

Friday, 6 June 2014

Having another look at Joy Global and Brown-Forman

One of the best aspects of writing this website is having a handy depository (for better or for worse in terms of the accuracy of the calls!) of investment articles and thoughts.  Two companies in the US that reported during the week were Brown-Forman and Joy Global.  As I noted back in August (link here) they are 'beauty and the beast'. 

Of course the value investor in me liked 'the beast' and Joy Global was a friend to me from a sub US$50 in price. 


Unfortunately I don't hold it today but it made me some nice returns in the second half of last year.  Reading this week's statement clearly conditions are tough but management are focused on providing returns to shareholders including that monster buyback they announced back in August. 

Unlike back in August I find Joy's share price harder to fundamentally justify today but rather the key insights came in some of the comments they made including rather sanguine comments on three slightly controversial commodities (with my emphasis added) especially as the spot price for the first two is currently trading below the levels cited:

On iron ore: 'the slope of the seaborne iron ore cost curve provides support at the $100 to $110 level and should support prices for the remainder of the year given the expectation for global steel demand to increase above 3 percent in 2014'

On copper:
'global copper inventories remain 27 percent below the March 2013 peak and expectations are that copper prices should average $3.10 per pound during 2014. Copper prices have held steady over the last several months as supply and demand conditions have remained relatively balanced'.

'Copper continues to have the strongest fundamentals of the major commodities we serve, with nearly 95 percent of global producers recognizing positive cash generation'
 
On oil sands: 'The economics of oil sands remain strong as oil prices have averaged over $90 per barrel since 2010. Sustained prices at these levels continue to stimulate investment in the oil sands region given the average cost of production in the $50 to $80 range'

(on the latter good news for Aggreko who I wrote about here earlier this week)


As for Brown-Forman well 'the beauty' has continued to blossom since August...and is trading around a x20 EV/ebit multiple.


It is an interesting indication what has continued to do really well in the current market: branded businesses that are growing (in Brown-Forman's case at around 10% a year) or as the company put it in the release earlier in the week:

'I believe that our leadership position in premium American whiskey, led by the one and only Jack Daniel’s trademark, and a very balanced geographic contribution, underpin the company’s differentiated performance. We remain optimistic about the organic growth prospects for Brown-Forman'

I am all for growth businesses but with extra oomph being given by the Jim Beam takeout the share does not excite me at the moment...especially when I can buy broad peers like Remy Cointreau or Pernod Ricard at a discount (to neutral cycle earnings) and also with good brands.

Time to do some more brand work...and try to find those relative bargains.  But that's for next week.  Have a good weekend.

Wednesday, 2 October 2013

Brands #3 - ranks 61-100

It really has been fascinating looking through the Interbrand survey.  So far, my analysis (which can be found here and here) has particularly reinforced my confidence in Google and Sony as investment cases. 

As before, given that the Interbrand analysis kindly gives a brand value, I thought it would be quite interesting to compare this value with a company's EV (i.e. a company's market cap + any net debt). 

Here are the companies ranked 61-100 of the Interbrand  research whose brand value is a high proportion of their EV:

> 40% Tiffany, Burberry, Avon

> 35% Dell

Selected others - Xerox 33.7%

Now Dell is kind of irrelevant going forward as it is being taken private, but the other three names are most interesting. 

I took a look at Tiffany at the last set of numbers (link here) and concluded that at c. US$82/share it was fairly fully valued and that its luxury peer Coach (at c. US$52/share) was more interesting (for full disclosure, I am still long Coach).  Since then, Coach is up about US$2/share whilst Tiffany is down c. US$6/share so that was a correct call, but it has got me wondering about the latter now, especially given the brand value as a % of EV was 52.4%. 

As per below, the share price chart does look as if it is rolling over.  Interestingly the next historic support on the chart is around US$70 where the valuation also is back at c. x12 EV/ebit which is more a level I could get excited about.   Something to think about, especially with such a worthy 'brand'. 


As for Burberry and Avon, I have not looked at them under the Financial Orbit banner although I am familiar with both. 

Burberry has rode the fashion-luxury bull run well over recent years, with only the blip around a perceived Asian sales miss a year ago blotting the copybook (but which created a wonderful buying opportunity):


The company is classically ever more focused on Asia - just like the aforementioned Coach interestingly. 


I note though even the prospective value is around x14 EV/ebit - just like Tiffany a lot is priced in.  Below 1425p is a share price support level and a more sensible valuation everything adjusted.  A useful level again given the brand value given by Interbrand. 

Finally, Avon has any a number of corporate struggles (particularly in its key Latam market) including an almost complete change of leadership.  These issues have been reflected in the share price non-progression:


I like the direct selling model and, as disclosed before, I am long Avon's Swedish-listed peer Oriflame. 

Looking through the numbers, Avon is deep in turnaround mode under the new CEO.  In Latam and Europe/Middle East, revenue growth has been traded off for higher margins.  The smaller North America/Asia businesses though have continued to struggle.  Throw in inevitable FX volatility and some concerns about consumer behaviour around the world (the recent Unilever comments etc) and high x13s EV/ebit feels too optimistic against the x9 rating for Oriflame with its own issues/turnaround hopes in its key Eastern Europe market. 

Nevertheless, Avon is back on my radar watch list (next numbers 1st November) due to the perceived power/worth of its brand.  US$18s look an interesting level.  This is the power of 'the brand'. 

Tuesday, 1 October 2013

Brands numbers 31-60: any opportunities?

I posted on the Interbrand report a couple of times yesterday (see for the example the link here).  Following on from my analysis of the top 30 brands, here are some summary thoughts on the global brands ranked 31-60. 

Given that this analysis kindly gives a brand value, I thought it would be quite interesting to compare this value with a company's EV (i.e. a company's market cap + any net debt). 

Here are the companies ranked 31-60 of the Interbrand  research whose brand value is a high proportion of their EV:

> 40% Sony

> 35% Canon, Nokia

Selected others - Philips 30.2%

I have written up analyses on all the three names which ranked 35%+ of their current EV as their brand value.  Here are the summary conclusions and links from my perspective.

Sony:
When I wrote up the Q2 numbers a couple of months ago, I concluded that Dan Loeb's activism was onto something and targeted a share price of over Y2400 (currently Y2085).  Link here. 

Canon:
I was not impressed by the Canon numbers when I looked at them in late July (the Q2 numbers) due to structural declines in their core imaging division (cameras and related).  The share remains over 10% above my target share price.  Link here. 

Nokia:
A difficult one to look at given they have just monetised the mobile handsets part of their business to Microsoft.  Next year it will be interesting to see what the continuing networking business will be worth as a brand.  My latest Nokia related report can be found here. 

Just as yesterday's conclusion was an unusual one (Google is a far more interesting brand at the margin today than various well-known consumer goods companies), today's observation is also a little unconventional.

We are brought up to believe in the strength of brands, but here we have three brands - in the form of Sony, Canon and Nokia - which have been humbled in recent years due to competition in their respective industries. 

However there is hope.  Sony have attracted activist interest and Nokia has sold off part of its business to create value.  I struggle fundamentally with Canon but observe that another quarter or two of profit pain and the pressure will rise for a potential outcome like Sony or Nokia.  Canon results on 24th October are going to be worth watching out for. 

Monday, 30 September 2013

Brand value - the top 30

I have talked about the Interbrand research piece already today (see this link). 

Given that this analysis kindly gives a brand value, I thought it would be quite interesting to compare this value with a company's EV (i.e. a company's market cap + any net debt). 

Here are the companies in the top 30 of the Interbrand  research whose brand value is a high proportion of their EV:

> 40% Coca-Cola, Hewlett-Packard, Kellogg's

> 35% Google, McDonald's

Selected others - Apple 23.8%, Microsoft 27.4%, Samsung 29.2%, Cisco 32%

I have written up analyses on all the five names which ranked 35%+ of their current EV as their brand value.  Here are the summary conclusions and links from my perspective.

Coca-Cola:
'The US$36s should again provide a support point for the shares even in volatile markets.  Something to note down.'  Link here. 

Hewlett-Packard:
'For the time being there is no need to do anything.  All eyes for me are on 9th October.'  Link here.

Kellogg's:
'It is a great brand, some of the innovation looks good but at x14 EV/ebit FY13e earnings it is all priced in and a bit more.'  (that number equivalent today is around US$57 a share). Link here. 

Google:
'Roll the numbers forward another year, should Google be at US$1000+ a share? Yes they should. '
Link here. 

McDonald's:
'Not an easy environment but the franchise continues to move forward.  They are a survivor.  I want to buy sub x12 EV/ebit which equates to US$93.5.'  Link here. 

So, in conclusion, if you want to buy a mega cap branded name, have a look at Google (and not the consumer goods/staples companies). 

More on the branded side later in the week (numbers 31 and lower).   

Brands, brands, brands

Anyone in the investment world can get a lot of insights from the excellent Interbrand annual report on brands, which can be found here:

Some key charts below to start the thinking process, but much more to come on this. 

So Coca-Cola is off the top spot...as Apple and Google show 28% and 34% 'top riser' brand increases.  Only Intel show a fall in brand value.  Note whilst there are two Asian brands in the top 10 (Samsung, Toyota) but NO European companies...

 
The rise and rise of Apple and Google also shown here


America the most represented across the entire top 100 and Europe also well ahead of Asia.  I think we know though how this will evolve in the next decade...even if brands - by definition - have barriers to entry. 


Much more to come on this later in the week.