I posted on the Interbrand report a couple of times yesterday (see for the example the link here). Following on from my analysis of the top 30 brands, here are some summary thoughts on the global brands ranked 31-60.
Given that this analysis kindly gives a brand value, I thought it would be quite interesting to compare this value with a company's EV (i.e. a company's market cap + any net debt).
Here are the companies ranked 31-60 of the Interbrand research whose brand value is a high proportion of their EV:
> 40% Sony
> 35% Canon, Nokia
Selected others - Philips 30.2%
I have written up analyses on all the three names which ranked 35%+ of their current EV as their brand value. Here are the summary conclusions and links from my perspective.
Sony:
When I wrote up the Q2 numbers a couple of months ago, I concluded that Dan Loeb's activism was onto something and targeted a share price of over Y2400 (currently Y2085). Link here.
Canon:
I was not impressed by the Canon numbers when I looked at them in late July (the Q2 numbers) due to structural declines in their core imaging division (cameras and related). The share remains over 10% above my target share price. Link here.
Nokia:
A difficult one to look at given they have just monetised the mobile handsets part of their business to Microsoft. Next year it will be interesting to see what the continuing networking business will be worth as a brand. My latest Nokia related report can be found here.
Just as yesterday's conclusion was an unusual one (Google is a far more interesting brand at the margin today than various well-known consumer goods companies), today's observation is also a little unconventional.
We are brought up to believe in the strength of brands, but here we have three brands - in the form of Sony, Canon and Nokia - which have been humbled in recent years due to competition in their respective industries.
However there is hope. Sony have attracted activist interest and Nokia has sold off part of its business to create value. I struggle fundamentally with Canon but observe that another quarter or two of profit pain and the pressure will rise for a potential outcome like Sony or Nokia. Canon results on 24th October are going to be worth watching out for.
No comments:
Post a Comment