In the write-up, I used this chart to help illustrate that Nokia still had an important role to play in the Networks area (especially after they bought out Siemens to wholly own the previous joint venture):
Over the last 24 hours various rumours have emerged about a potential deal between Nokia and Alcatel which, if true, would create a clear global number two to challenge Ericsson.
So does a deal make sense?
Well, a consolidated market can be used as a margin enhancing mechanism, that is fairly obvious. But this starts with the business that you buy...and the price that you pay for it.
If I take a look at Alcatel today, three key charts come to the fore:
First, the business is split between 'core networking' and 'access' as shown below. I assume Nokia is only interested in the 'access' part as this provides the overlap with its own business. Interestingly though, 'core networking' has been more successful - especially in IP routing/platforms - at building revenue in recent quarters...
...which has played out in the operating income lines. 'Access' is loss-making by contrast.
Cash flow is also poor at Alcatel. The company is cost cutting but the combination of tough markets, ongoing impairment charges and a Euro26bn pension pot (admittedly fairly fully funded) overhangs.
Now Alcatel shares have been on a very strong run, up over 200% in the last year. This has pushed the market cap to Euro6.3bn or an EV of just over Euro7bn. This might be an EV:revenues ratio of 'just' x0.5 but the trouble is earnings are negligible and expectations for FY13 are still for a loss.
By contrast, in my earlier valuation piece on Nokia I noted their Network business was estimated to generate Euro1bn of profits at a margin of around 10%. If you put the Alcatel business on similar margins and a similar multiple to what I valued the Nokia Networks business on, you get a valuation of Euro2.8bn.
Given the business is not generating a positive margin and hence should not be valued this way, I think if Nokia pay more than half this price then it certainly would be a bad deal, especially given the amount of restructuring that would be required. Clearly from Nokia's perspective the lower the price, the better.
Interestingly, I noticed this comment in a Reuters report:
According to Reuters, analysts estimate Alcatel-Lucent's wireless business is worth between €1.1bn to €1.5bn.
Nokia have the money following the Euro5.4bn payment by Microsoft for the handsets/related business. I think the best use is a combination of returning a large proportion of this to investors via a special dividend and considering the Alcatel deal - but just for the 'Access' business.
As an aside, for what it is worth, the 'core networking' business valuation is very dependent on whether it can sustain the 8%+ margin they generated in Q2. If they do...then Alcatel's share price run could be justified. That's for another report...
Net net Nokia shareholders should not be worried about an Alcatel 'Access' business deal (within the metrics above) but a play for the whole business, using up the Microsoft sale proceeds and more...well, that's another story.
If I take a look at Alcatel today, three key charts come to the fore:
First, the business is split between 'core networking' and 'access' as shown below. I assume Nokia is only interested in the 'access' part as this provides the overlap with its own business. Interestingly though, 'core networking' has been more successful - especially in IP routing/platforms - at building revenue in recent quarters...
...which has played out in the operating income lines. 'Access' is loss-making by contrast.
Cash flow is also poor at Alcatel. The company is cost cutting but the combination of tough markets, ongoing impairment charges and a Euro26bn pension pot (admittedly fairly fully funded) overhangs.
Now Alcatel shares have been on a very strong run, up over 200% in the last year. This has pushed the market cap to Euro6.3bn or an EV of just over Euro7bn. This might be an EV:revenues ratio of 'just' x0.5 but the trouble is earnings are negligible and expectations for FY13 are still for a loss.
By contrast, in my earlier valuation piece on Nokia I noted their Network business was estimated to generate Euro1bn of profits at a margin of around 10%. If you put the Alcatel business on similar margins and a similar multiple to what I valued the Nokia Networks business on, you get a valuation of Euro2.8bn.
Given the business is not generating a positive margin and hence should not be valued this way, I think if Nokia pay more than half this price then it certainly would be a bad deal, especially given the amount of restructuring that would be required. Clearly from Nokia's perspective the lower the price, the better.
Interestingly, I noticed this comment in a Reuters report:
According to Reuters, analysts estimate Alcatel-Lucent's wireless business is worth between €1.1bn to €1.5bn.
Nokia have the money following the Euro5.4bn payment by Microsoft for the handsets/related business. I think the best use is a combination of returning a large proportion of this to investors via a special dividend and considering the Alcatel deal - but just for the 'Access' business.
As an aside, for what it is worth, the 'core networking' business valuation is very dependent on whether it can sustain the 8%+ margin they generated in Q2. If they do...then Alcatel's share price run could be justified. That's for another report...
Net net Nokia shareholders should not be worried about an Alcatel 'Access' business deal (within the metrics above) but a play for the whole business, using up the Microsoft sale proceeds and more...well, that's another story.




No comments:
Post a Comment