Pages

Tuesday, 3 September 2013

Microsoft and Nokia - some brief maths

Another day, another deal in the telecoms/technology space as Microsoft announces that it is to acquire Nokia’s devices & services business. So two drunks propping each other up?  Here is an interesting fact to start off with: since December 31, 1999 Microsoft is down -42% while Nokia is down -91%.

Before we appraise the strategic rationale for the deal, let's look at the facts. Note that the deal covers both the devices business and patent licences too with the Euro5.44bn transaction value split between the two areas being approximately 70%/30%. 


What sort of multiple does Euro5.44bn represent?  Well, as per the Q2 2013 Nokia report, the devices side - at an operating profit level - was loss-making:


This seems a heroic price.  To put this fully into context, let's look at the Nokia market cap at the close of business yesterday (Monday). 

Market cap Euro11.4bn
Net cash Euro4.1bn
Payment for Siemens 50% stake in NSN Euro1.7bn
EV = Euro11.4 -4.1 + 1.7 = Euro9bn

With c. Euro5.4bn being paid for the devices business (and associated patents) the 'stub' value of the remaining Nokia businesses is around Euro3.6bn.  What value should we attribute to these businesses?

Nokia states that:

Following the transaction, Nokia plans to focus on its three established businesses, each of which is a leader in enabling mobility in its respective market segment: NSN, a leader in network infrastructure and services; HERE, a leader in mapping and location services; and Advanced Technologies, a leader in technology development and licensing.

NSN is the most valuable business in my opinion.  Here is the divisional slide from the Q2 2013 presentation:
 


We can see from the transaction name-checked above, that earlier this year, Nokia bought out Siemens for the equivalent of a Euro3.4bn valuation for the NSN division (Euro1.7bn * 2).

Well, we know that thematically this is a good area.  The chart below was taken from the Ericsson report on the future of the mobile industry.  Rising data needs = rising infrastructure needs. 


In terms of players, Ericsson are market leaders (as per below) and trade on a x11 EV/ebit multiple.  We know that the Chinese (Huawei and ZTE) are both aggressive competitors and have been winning contracts/part contracts around the world. 


Given Nokia's second tier positioning here, I would rate the division inherently at x8 EV/ebit.  They are on-track for Euro1bn in operating profits here...so we could call it a Euro8bn worth division.  However, there is a big divergence between IFRS and non-IFRS profitability (lots of writedowns etc) so I am going to reduce the rating to x6 EV/ebit.  So a Euro6bn division. That was still a good deal they got from Siemens. 

I know less about Here, but 'here' is the presentation chart from the Q2 2013 Nokia report:

 

I am not going to attribute much value to this division.   Given Nokia will retain central costs as well (and we have noted material ongoing restructuring still at the NSN division), let's put this division in at zero. 
 
So with the other divisions worth a cumulative Euro6bn, that's a 66% uplift versus the 'stub' value.  Euro5 a share, anyone?
 
 
Now there are lots of assumptions here. 
 
The deal looks highly likely to go through (Q1 2014 closing) but there's always a risk it falls apart
You still have to worry that NSN will have further writedowns etc. as well (recall that Nokia's debt is junk rated) 
Nokia could also spend its windfall in a manner that doesn't please the market
 
Turning to Microsoft, the deal is around 4% of EV.  Accretion should occur in a year or so helped by ultra low interest rates on cash.  Does it feel a great deal?  No.  But in the wider scheme of things Microsoft might have wasted 4-5% of their shareholder's money...or maybe they have bought the last ticket going.  If Microsoft changes by more than a couple of percent today I would be surprised. 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment