Pages

Friday, 2 August 2013

Some detail from Asia

We talked briefly about Sony yesterday, following its results announcement just after the Tokyo close.  The share edged up in Friday trading in Japan and still, essentially, have doubled in Yen terms year-to-date. 

Yesterday we noted that the influences for their key electronics businesses the year-on-year influences went beyond FX, namely -

FX +Y19bn impact
Price/demand -Y25bn impact
Cost cutting +Y37bn impact

The company gave a couple of interesting insight into this division -

we were able to record a profit for the 5 electronics segments in total for the first time since the first quarter of fiscal 2011, and this was due to significant improvement in our result of smartphone business and the strength of new products, and the change of profit of the TV business for the first time since first quarter fiscal 2010

I looked at the progression of profitability in their electronic businesses in Q1 '13 yoy and building on the above the stand-out performer was surprisingly...mobile.  Home entertainment and games were assisted by the FX changes whilst the difficult areas were imaging and devices. 

Clearly you have a Yen-influence here and a variety of different end markets.  If I extrapolate Q1 profit here and place the division on a (low) x8 EV/ebit valuation you get a value of Y430bn. 

This feels suitably conservative given the company have talked about Y100bn operating profit for this division before, but have rowed away from that now. 


Music and pictures were solid performers and it was interesting that on the international conference call that Dan Loeb, the activist investor who is trying to shake up Sony, asked about music publishing specifically.  I got a value here of Y580bn (am still thinking that the turned-down Softbank bid for Universal Music owned by Vivendi was a great indicator of value in this space). 


Finally onto the financial services division.  The company would not break out fully the influence of the markets on this division but did say that

Revenue and operating income for the segment increased largely due to a significant improvement in investment performance as Sony Life reflecting a significant rise in the Japanese stock market during the quarter

There is clearly some risk here but I got a value of Y1472bn for this division (x8 ebit). 

Adding all this together gives Y2482bn or a share price of Y2436, a bump up from the current Y2100+ share price.  I think Dan Loeb is still onto something. 


Turning to Cheung Kong the headline numbers raised some obvious questions outside the performance of Hutchison Whampoa -



Digging deeper into the numbers, the timings around property completions were blamed for the profits fall.  Contributions from other areas, as shown below, namely rents, hotels and infrastructure investments exhibited a better performance. 



So what is happening at the 50% owned Hutchison Whampoa?  Well results here have been good


Note in particular the improvement in 3 Group Europe.  We will touch on this later. 

So what exactly does Hutchison Whampoa own? This (slightly confusing) chart from their presentation helps to spell it out -


Infrastructure (big expansion in waste management via an acquisition in the Netherlands), property/hotels, energy (Canadian), retail (Watsons)...it is quite an international mixture.  Note the exposure is c. 50% Asia, 50% RoW...and according to press reports, the company is looking to further expand international (ex Asia) exposure to take advantage of low trade prices.  This also may include selling some Asian assets (some of the Hong Kong retail assets ParknShop are allegedly up-for-sale). 

On 3 Europe they finally can see some profit daylight...mobile is a tough business nowadays.  Note the big licence payment for example -


Hutchison Whampoa is an interesting business.  x1 price:book, a 25% gearing ratio, a supportive large shareholder (Li Ka Shing controls both Cheung Kong and Hutchison) and a x13 P/e which is a big discount to the big European/US infrastructure conglomerates.  They are also trying to add value by buying assets under pressure in areas such as Europe. 

The share did kick up 4% today but this is still a powerful mixture. 

As for Cheung Kong, have a think about this.  Of CK's HK$261bn market cap, HK$193bn of this is down to the Hutchison holding.  Now they could not sell this at that price but the CK stub at 'just' HK$68bn strikes me as low.  That is left than x5 ebit for the group on its core assets.  Yes, HK property is expensive but half the company's 'stub' profits are from hotels, rentals and the like.  Cheung Kong also looks lightly valued...and is no-way near recent highs.

No comments:

Post a Comment