Financials are amongst the biggest names reporting in Europe today. After the fireworks from the Lloyds results yesterday, today it was the turn of RBS.
We criticised the Lloyds financial release yesterday for not offering the return on equity disclosures we like in a clear and easy manner to see. This was not the case for RBS though. I like the way they were up-front with the disclosures -
I think this chart tells you almost everything you need to know about RBS today. Note first the difference between the core business and group operating profitability...the difference is the bad bank (non-core) drag. It is still a drag. All the losses there were due to more impairments.
Second, note how the core business has its own drag...Ulster Bank of Ireland. That part of the business lost £330m in H1 and is still messy. Above and beyond that, £5bn worth of other Irish loans are in the non-core part still.
Clearly the aim is to run down the non-core bank further. That now stands at £46bn in assets and they hope to reduce it to £20bn by 2016 through natural run-off. We should expect to see more impairments.
So, where do they want to go? Here are a few targets they outlined:
I don't think you can regard RBS as a 10% RoE business today, to achieve that you have to eliminate the non-core and Ulster Bank influences. However today it is valued just below fair value for the 7.4% actual core business RoE. This tells you that the company is a straight play on core book franchise worth maintenance versus new impairment losses at the non-core bank. RBS is not high quality but the debate has changed. If you trust that the outgoing CEO Mr Hester has done a good job in taking writedowns where needed then value will emerge here over time.
Axa and Allianz are never the two easiest companies to look at. Both shares are up this morning on results which pleased the markets.
I have always found Axa a bit easier to look at. Results were good with a 16% rise in operating earnings across all divisions except 'international' signifying a good H1 effort. I did note that the H1 RoE actually exceeded their hoped-for target over the next couple of years -
The chart I thought most insightful from their presentation was the sensitivity one. Insurance, by definition, is about managing a lot of risks so it was useful to hear their views -
So, what does the above tell us? AXA is more 'scared' of falling interest rates than rising interest rates than, from a solvency perspective, rising/falling stock markets. It was ever thus with such a fixed income centric investment book but again reiterates that a backing-up bond market does support these companies.
It is possible AXA will raise its Ambition 2015 target given the unusual situation they find themselves in as noted in the first chart from the company we used. Or maybe they feel that the H1 RoE level is unsustainable. Clarification in the conference call later would be useful. Either way, the AXA machine keeps on rolling forward.




No comments:
Post a Comment