It really has been fascinating looking through the Interbrand survey. So far, my analysis (which can be found here and here) has particularly reinforced my confidence in Google and Sony as investment cases.
As before, given that the Interbrand analysis kindly gives a brand value, I thought it would be quite interesting to compare this value with a company's EV (i.e. a company's market cap + any net debt).
Here are the companies ranked 61-100 of the Interbrand research whose brand value is a high proportion of their EV:
> 40% Tiffany, Burberry, Avon
> 35% Dell
Selected others - Xerox 33.7%
Now Dell is kind of irrelevant going forward as it is being taken private, but the other three names are most interesting.
I took a look at Tiffany at the last set of numbers (link here) and concluded that at c. US$82/share it was fairly fully valued and that its luxury peer Coach (at c. US$52/share) was more interesting (for full disclosure, I am still long Coach). Since then, Coach is up about US$2/share whilst Tiffany is down c. US$6/share so that was a correct call, but it has got me wondering about the latter now, especially given the brand value as a % of EV was 52.4%.
As per below, the share price chart does look as if it is rolling over. Interestingly the next historic support on the chart is around US$70 where the valuation also is back at c. x12 EV/ebit which is more a level I could get excited about. Something to think about, especially with such a worthy 'brand'.
As for Burberry and Avon, I have not looked at them under the Financial Orbit banner although I am familiar with both.
Burberry has rode the fashion-luxury bull run well over recent years, with only the blip around a perceived Asian sales miss a year ago blotting the copybook (but which created a wonderful buying opportunity):
The company is classically ever more focused on Asia - just like the aforementioned Coach interestingly.
I note though even the prospective value is around x14 EV/ebit - just like Tiffany a lot is priced in. Below 1425p is a share price support level and a more sensible valuation everything adjusted. A useful level again given the brand value given by Interbrand.
Finally, Avon has any a number of corporate struggles (particularly in its key Latam market) including an almost complete change of leadership. These issues have been reflected in the share price non-progression:
I like the direct selling model and, as disclosed before, I am long Avon's Swedish-listed peer Oriflame.
Looking through the numbers, Avon is deep in turnaround mode under the new CEO. In Latam and Europe/Middle East, revenue growth has been traded off for higher margins. The smaller North America/Asia businesses though have continued to struggle. Throw in inevitable FX volatility and some concerns about consumer behaviour around the world (the recent Unilever comments etc) and high x13s EV/ebit feels too optimistic against the x9 rating for Oriflame with its own issues/turnaround hopes in its key Eastern Europe market.
Nevertheless, Avon is back on my radar watch list (next numbers 1st November) due to the perceived power/worth of its brand. US$18s look an interesting level. This is the power of 'the brand'.




No comments:
Post a Comment