Pages

Friday, 6 June 2014

Having another look at Joy Global and Brown-Forman

One of the best aspects of writing this website is having a handy depository (for better or for worse in terms of the accuracy of the calls!) of investment articles and thoughts.  Two companies in the US that reported during the week were Brown-Forman and Joy Global.  As I noted back in August (link here) they are 'beauty and the beast'. 

Of course the value investor in me liked 'the beast' and Joy Global was a friend to me from a sub US$50 in price. 


Unfortunately I don't hold it today but it made me some nice returns in the second half of last year.  Reading this week's statement clearly conditions are tough but management are focused on providing returns to shareholders including that monster buyback they announced back in August. 

Unlike back in August I find Joy's share price harder to fundamentally justify today but rather the key insights came in some of the comments they made including rather sanguine comments on three slightly controversial commodities (with my emphasis added) especially as the spot price for the first two is currently trading below the levels cited:

On iron ore: 'the slope of the seaborne iron ore cost curve provides support at the $100 to $110 level and should support prices for the remainder of the year given the expectation for global steel demand to increase above 3 percent in 2014'

On copper:
'global copper inventories remain 27 percent below the March 2013 peak and expectations are that copper prices should average $3.10 per pound during 2014. Copper prices have held steady over the last several months as supply and demand conditions have remained relatively balanced'.

'Copper continues to have the strongest fundamentals of the major commodities we serve, with nearly 95 percent of global producers recognizing positive cash generation'
 
On oil sands: 'The economics of oil sands remain strong as oil prices have averaged over $90 per barrel since 2010. Sustained prices at these levels continue to stimulate investment in the oil sands region given the average cost of production in the $50 to $80 range'

(on the latter good news for Aggreko who I wrote about here earlier this week)


As for Brown-Forman well 'the beauty' has continued to blossom since August...and is trading around a x20 EV/ebit multiple.


It is an interesting indication what has continued to do really well in the current market: branded businesses that are growing (in Brown-Forman's case at around 10% a year) or as the company put it in the release earlier in the week:

'I believe that our leadership position in premium American whiskey, led by the one and only Jack Daniel’s trademark, and a very balanced geographic contribution, underpin the company’s differentiated performance. We remain optimistic about the organic growth prospects for Brown-Forman'

I am all for growth businesses but with extra oomph being given by the Jim Beam takeout the share does not excite me at the moment...especially when I can buy broad peers like Remy Cointreau or Pernod Ricard at a discount (to neutral cycle earnings) and also with good brands.

Time to do some more brand work...and try to find those relative bargains.  But that's for next week.  Have a good weekend.

No comments:

Post a Comment