I wrote part 1 of this analysis on McDonald's three months ago (you can find the link here). Back then I concluded that:
'Not an easy environment but the franchise continues to move forward. They are a survivor. I want to buy sub x12 EV/ebit which equates to US$93.5. At that level I think you have a good opportunity to trade the stock back to US$100 and probably pick up a dividend to augment the return. This consumer staple remains a bit expensive…'
What has happened in the interim period? Well, McDonald's shares have continued to struggle to move through US$100 and, in fact, have been kicking around my previously cited preferred US$93.5 level earlier this month and is called to open just below this level today. So, should I be buying McDonalds shares here?
Looking at the numbers the company released, 0.9% Q3 comparable sales growth and a 6% rise in EPS does not seem that bad at all. The quarterly dividend also rose 5% making the annualised yield for the stock just under 3.5% which sounds ok.
Regionally, Europe was again the standout with comparable sales up only 0.2% but operating income up 11% in constant currency (8% reported). Menu innovation continued to benefit results.
The core US market remained a little dull although 0.7% comparable sales and 5% rise in operating income is not a disaster at all. However I note the company listed a number of continued innovations they are launching to try to induce more customers to come to their restaurants.
By contrast, the smaller Asia/Africa division continued to struggle (with Japan, China and Australia name-checked) with sales -1.4% and operating income down 12% headline (-4% constant currency). The company continues to use menu and opening hours innovations to try to turn this around.
So nothing too terrible or different than before. This is also replicated in the outlook statement (with my emphasis added):
'Looking ahead, the Company expects the dynamics of the current environment to persist. For the fourth quarter, the Company expects global comparable sales performance to be in-line with recent quarterly trends while restaurant margin percentages are expected to decline at a level relatively similar to first quarter results. Global comparable sales for the month of October are expected to be relatively flat'.
Where did that margin decline come from? Clearly trading on the ground is struggling to move forward. This excellent chart from Hedgeye
So how do you value that?
Well, McDonald's is an annuity-type business. It is struggling to grow but - as shown in the SG&A fall of 4% in Q3 year-on-year - there are still levers that can be pulled to drive the EPS line. With a 6%+ free cash flow yield, the next step is for the company to boost their share buyback. The business model is not broken, it is just in a lacklustre economy they will inevitably struggle. But, unlike many other consumer branded staples, the valuation is starting to reflect this. The brand continues to be strong.
My thoughts would be to start a position sub US$93.5 makes sense, especially for dividend-favouring investors. Numbers will be edged back due to the margin comments above but time is rolling on too. A US$93.5 or below share price equates to less than x12 EV/ebit FY14e even with these new adjustments. Time to be getting the McD's in? From a zero position, I think yes.


No comments:
Post a Comment