Pages

Monday, 16 June 2014

IBM's brand value and relative share price attractiveness

I talked about the brand value work by BrandZ (which was published in The Financial Times) last week (link here).  Following on from that work (and appraisal of McDonald's and Altria) I am going to take a look at IBM and then, later today in a separate post, Coca-Cola.  Both of these companies were in the top five names when filtering from the perspective of brand value as a proportion of current market cap.  To recall some statistics from last week:

'McDonald's 85.6% (of market cap covered by the BrandZ value)
Altria 81.9%
IBM 56.8%
Visa 48.3%
Coca-Cola 44.7%'

Turning to IBM first, back in January I noted that:

'A single digit EV/ebit level is back to the mid US$160s share level - or the lowest point since mid-2011 for the shares.  Unless Lenovo overpay or the company gets even more aggressive on returning capital, I struggle to get excited...even if Warren Buffett is on the shareholder list'

Since I wrote these words, Lenovo have progressed with the purchase of the small server business (at an ok price - although the money raised is equivalent to around 1% of their NAV, see here), Warren Buffett remains a shareholders and as for the shares...well they have moved in a c. US$175-200 range and are currently much nearer to the bottom than the top of that range:


What newsflow have we had from IBM over the intervening five months since I last looked at them?  Here are the three key events from my perspective:

Another sale? Press reports that Globalfoundries are "the lead candidate" to buy IBM's chip manufacturing/foundry ops. A source states the unit has been losing as much as $1.5bn/year...
Q1 numbers: As Seeking Alpha put it: 'Though IBM reiterated its 2014 EPS guidance, it was "really reset lower" given the company lowered its full-year tax rate forecast to 20% from 23%...The big issue is IBM's legacy businesses are getting hit by multiple points." '


Analyst day: CFO Martin Schroeter reiterated IBM's EPS target for 2015 of “at least $20”
In combination this does not sound the greatest...

Nevertheless you can make a more optimistic case based on the growth of big data...

...and then the underlying growth of the gross profit margin line (aligned with the US$14bn of free cash flow generated over the last 12 months and US$23bn returned to investors via a combination of buybacks and share repurchases - see above)

 
Progress which is driven by productivity, software and services (in that order) - themes which should continue to accrue especially given some of the M&A activity undertaken by IBM.  

 
 Ultimately I want to see a print in the US$160s for close to that single digit EV/ebit ratio BUT having another look at the story the combination of the growth thematic, gross margin progress, buyback/shareholder return (augmented still be a small net cash position on the balance sheet).  The high brand value is great news for a buy on a bad day story. 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment