Pages

Tuesday, 9 September 2014

Watching McDonald's and thinking about brand value

Back in June I posted about the BrandZ survey I spotted in the Financial Times:



On the last time eleven months ago I did a specific piece of analysis on the company I noted that:

'McDonald's is an annuity-type business.  It is struggling to grow but - as shown in the SG&A fall of 4% in Q3 year-on-year - there are still levers that can be pulled to drive the EPS line.  With a 6%+ free cash flow yield, the next step is for the company to boost their share buyback'

I was reminded of this as today as the company reported some headline lacklustre numbers:

'McDonald's Corporation today announced that global comparable sales decreased 3.7% in August.  Performance by segment was as follows:
  • U.S. down 2.8%
  • Europe down  0.7%
  • Asia/Pacific, Middle East and Africa (APMEA) down 14.5%
"During August, McDonald's global business faced several headwinds that impacted sales performance," said McDonald's President and Chief Executive Officer Don Thompson'
They are striking numbers and mixed trading in the US and specific issues in Russia and (food hygiene influenced) China had the biggest impact.  And it may not be over:

As we continue to assess the impact of the supplier issue in China, we currently estimate that this issue will negatively impact third quarter results by about $0.15 - $0.20 per share in comparison to prior year results.  This is largely due to a combination of lost sales, expenses associated with our recovery efforts and the impact of these items on the third quarter tax rate, which is expected to be above the Company's outlook for the full-year tax rate of 31-33%.  An update on the Company's full-year 2014 financial outlook will be provided in conjunction with McDonald's third quarter earnings release in October.

Not great tone to the above and, unsurprisingly, the share has fallen to around 18 month lows although the share is approximately in the middle of the last three year range.  



What the brand analysis is telling me is that a level - on generalised weakness - to buy McDonald's shares is where the BrandZ brand value covers the entire market cap...which is at about US$87.50.  This would be highly unusual and clearly - when the 2015 report is issued - could be followed by another revision down in the McDonald's brand value.

Here's where the value investor in me is starting to get more interested.  A 3.4% dividend yield, net debt:ebitda of around x1 and good cash flow.  Now the question is whether the company's products are structurally out-of-favour or not and the lagging high brand value is a hoax.  That's where the greater data and comments disclosure in October comes in too.  One to watch.  After all the company is still the world's largest restaurant chain operator.

No comments:

Post a Comment