Pages

Showing posts with label china; guest; Jing Liang. Show all posts
Showing posts with label china; guest; Jing Liang. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 September 2014

Guest post - 'Who is Alibaba?'

Continuing this marvellous guest author series on China and related investment matters, Jing Liang looks at the history and prospects of the company everyone is talking about at the moment: Alibaba

Who is Alibaba? by Jing Liang

Suppleness triumphs over hardness, softness over strength – Lao Tzu
弱之胜强, 柔之胜刚

When growing up in the mainland, children were often told the story of Ali Baba and 40 thieves. I was always amazed by the intelligence of Ali Baba and his friends who not only successfully outwitted the thieves using their own tricks but were able to reserve all the treasure and share them with the villagers. This month, as Alibaba – China’s eCommerce/Internet conglomerate – is going to be floated on the US stock market, its success in one of the fastest growing but most competitive markets is captivating. But who is Alibaba exactly? How did it achieve the success? How do they make money and what’s their potential? And, of course, what are the risks?

In its 2014 IPO SEC filing, Alibaba stated it is planning to issue around 320 million shares and hopes to price its shares between $60 and $66 each. If the Alibaba IPO achieved the higher end of this range, Alibaba would raise just over $21 billion and become the largest IPO in history as indicated by the chart below.


The table below shows Alibaba’s earnings information between 2010 and 2014 based on its IPO filing.
 

Bloomberg polled 12 analysts and Alibaba was valued at $168 billion on average, it reflects 33x EV/EBITDA based on earning for the year ending March 2014, which is similar to its peers such as Tencent and it obviously indicates the exuberance of the market for the impending IPO. I have used the valuation calculator provided by the FT, which includes forward-looking earnings estimates for the next 7 years. The following is my result.

 

The valuation tool includes forecast of the five factors listed above. On the right hand side is the forecast I made. The model itself is really sensitive to the change – by decimal places – of each component. Rather than speculating its accuracy (as it is really like a winning a lottery), it is more useful to use it as a tool for direction of valuation.
 

The simple assumptions made (as shown above) for each component is based on relatively strong growth in eCommerce in China, Alibaba’s dominance in the market, its past performance (as stated in earnings’ table) and possible slowdown in terms of profitability towards the end of forecasting period (possible reasons include domestic competition, market saturation, etc). The valuation I came up with is $237 billion (US$98 per share) valuation implying an EV/EBITDA multiple just over 20x for 2016 forward earnings. That makes the proposed IPO pricing at $60 to $66 in the prospectus a “buying” opportunity…the trouble is there is anticipated to be a significant leap on day 1 of trading as well. 

Who is Alibaba?
Alibaba is an Internet conglomerate in Mainland China that was founded in 1999. Its origins are in a company called 1688.com which was set up to level the playing field for small-medium enterprise (SMEs) enabling them to leverage innovation and technology to compete in both domestic and global markets. Fast forward to 2014, it is now offering a mixture of Internet based services ranging from B2B (business-to-business), B2C (business-to-consumer) to a range of digital related services. The following table gives a quick overview of what Alibaba does and who the global equivalents are:

 

In 2014 (based on its 2014 IPO SEC filing), it generated US$296 billion of gross merchandise value (GMV), 14.5 billion annual orders and it has 279 million annual active buyers. According to KPMG, Alibaba had already surpassed both eBay and Amazon combined in terms of GMV in 2012.

 

The above chart shows the quarterly Alibaba GMV since 2012 and the percentage of which were generated through mobile device, which is a fast growing eCommerce platform in China. In second quarter 2014, Alibaba’s Tmall represented 57% of total transactions volumes in China B2C market.  

How did it achieve its success so far?

Jack Ma, the charismatic founder of Alibaba once said: “The difference between China e-commerce and US e-commerce is that e-commerce in the USA is what I call the dessert – it’s supplementary to their main business, because the USA’s infrastructure of doing business is so good. So it is very difficult for e-commerce in the USA to grow, to develop, to surpass the traditional business. But in China, because the infrastructure of commerce is too bad, then e-commerce becomes the main course.”

The comment not only addressed the key difference between the eCommerce operating environment in the US and China, it also explains one of the key reasons for Alibaba’s fast growth.

 

The chart on the left shows retail space per capita in five countries including China.  As it points out, in terms of commerce infrastructure, China still has a lot of catching up to do especially given its large population base and geographical diversity. However, the purchasing power for Chinese consumers is increasing at a faster pace. The chart on the right hand side shows the pace of eCommerce growth in both the US and China. As pointed out by the chart, China’s eCommerce growth has already surpassed the US in 2012. The relatively slow commerce infrastructure and purchasing power growth have created opportunities for the fast growth of eCommerce. As pointed out by Jack Ma, not only eCommerce is a supplement for the traditional mainstream businesses, it is mainstream itself in China.

Apart from the macro environment in China that provided the necessary pre-requisite condition for the fast growth of Alibaba, in order to establish its dominance and combat the fierce competition from both the domestic and foreign competitors, two insights on Chinese market provided Aliaba an edge:

1.      The average Chinese consumer is tight fisted. On Alibaba’s B2B platform, Alibaba removed all basic services fees. Fees are only charged for services such as advertising and web-design. The strategy helped Alibaba to gain size. The size in turn created and increased the value for its other business, e.g. advertising business. Because of the sheer size of Alibaba’s eCommerce platform, it is able to block the search engine such as Baidu and lead consumers directly to its site to find goods. This made advertising on Alibaba platform more valuable. Also, the strategy of removing basic service fees made Alibaba a formidable competitor. The chart below shows the battle between Alibaba’s unit Taobao and eBay, who entered the market in 2002 via acquisition of EachNet.

 
2.   In general, the Chinese are reluctant to trust strangers especially when it comes to doing business. Therefore, Alibaba provided a safety net by offering vetting services. In addition, the payment system Alipay provided the certainty of payments. Unlike Paypal, which only collect payment on the point of purchase, Alipay holds funds under an escrow account and therefore the payment is secured before purchase. Because of eCommerce, Alipay obtained vast amount of credit data on its user base, which enables Alibaba to provide micro loan (average size around $8000) to its users.

It seems to me, the success of Alibaba are not just because of its early bird advantage, that it is also riding the wave of a strong China Internet commerce development. It is branching out into other areas to build a coherent ecosystem that is based on its foundation business and leveraging a strong self-reinforcing network effects. 

 

As shown on its home page, Alibaba promises a 102-year sustainable growth, so how will they achieve this? What is the potential?

What is the main revenue driver and what are the potential?

Alibaba generates revenue through online marketing services, commission on transactions and fees for online services. In addition, they also generate revenues through fees from memberships, value-added services and cloud computing services. The following chart shows a breakdown of their top line by business type for the year ending 31st December 2013

 

The chart indicates the majority of Alibaba’s top line comes from China and eCommerce. The three marketplaces – Tmall, Taobao and Juhuasuan – contributed 82.7% of revenue generated in 2013. Therefore, one can say Alibaba’s near future still depends on China and further growth of eCommerce.

China on average is slowing based on GDP growth alone. However, the lower tier regions still are showing signs of strong growth momentum (see chart below on the left). Furthermore, the Internet penetration growth is speeding up in the lower tier regions in China as indicated on the chart below on the right.
 


One of the key reasons for the fast growth of eCommerce in China is because of its unique mainstream nature, which is especially reflected in the lower tier regions, where commerce infrastructure is less developed comparing to the coastal areas. Therefore, eCommerce is a crucial market strategy for merchants to reach out the consumers there. In order to enhance its reach to the lower tier regions, Alibaba has a joint agreement with China Post, which has the world largest postal network and most importantly, it has deeper reach into China’s lower tier regions.

In addition, consumption, as portion of GDP is increasing (currently around 34% of GDP, still lower than the average worldwide) and China has already become the second biggest consumer in the world overtaking Japan in 2013 (as per the Economist, 18th Feb 2014 edition).  However, eCommerce as portion of retail sales is still small, roughly around 10%. The below chart shows the percentage of GDP that is come from Internet related expenditures.

  
China has overtaken the US already in 2013. However, there is sample room for further growth. As pointed out by the research done by McKinsey, China’s eCommerce is largely consumer driven. So the potential lies with continued lower tier Internet penetration, continued consumption growth and eCommerce that is driven by retail consumers. So what are the risks?

The risks
China slow down, possibilities of slower consumption growth and an un-realization of lower tier regions’ potential are all possible risk factors and there are many others mentioned in Alibaba filing with the SEC. However, I think one of the biggest challenges is its competition with its domestic rivals and its tendency to get into the pricing war, like other corporations in China often do. The latest battle with its rival, Tencent, was in the Taxi app market.


There are currently 130 million registered accounts in the taxi app market in the mainland. As shown on the chart above, Alibaba and Tencent are the two biggest players with Tencent leading just slightly. Even though the two sides reached the truce, roughly 2 billion RMB (around 325 million USD, Analysys International estimates) was spent on the “fight” between January and June this year. It was an expensive battle with no clear winners according to Analysys. However, it signifies the emergence of two clear dominant rivals in the upcoming Mobile Internet era in China.

To compete with Tencent, one of Alibaba’s key challenges is to break into Social Network segment of Mobile Internet. One of Tencent’s key strength is its ability to leverage its social network (SNW) to create user stickiness which is exemplified in its gaming, its WeChat and its latest Red-pocket app (Hongbao, Chinese tradition to give money as a gift to family and friends in Chinese New Year), which outshone Alibaba’s similar app because its “fun” element created for users. The following chart shows the league table of the most popular apps in China in May 2014.

 

As indicated by the Chart, Alibaba in the mobile app area still has long way to catch up with its rivals, especially Tencent. To counter this, Alibaba has made a few strategic purchases, e.g. it took an 18% of stake in WeiBo, and it has just launched its very own SNW app, Laiwang. However, with Tencent’s dominant position in the SNW area, Alibaba needs more than just acquisitions and launching a similar app, which are typical tactics used by established giant corporations that need to catch up.

This is one area that Alibaba needs new ideas.

Conclusion

With all factors considered, the long awaited IPO of Alibaba is an exciting event on its own. After 30 years of opening up its market, China has started to deliver corporations that truly stand for Chinese entrepreneur values and the true potential lies in how Alibaba re-shaped the ways, especially for SMEs, of growth for other businesses in the mainland. If Alibaba fulfills its promise it made on its corporate statement, that it is truly going to “live” for at least 102 years, the IPO is just a beginning of its history. No wonder it appears that this is an IPO everyone appears to be excited to be part of. 

Thursday, 28 August 2014

Guest post - "Tencent - waiting for a better entry point"

This is the fifth in a guest post series on China.  You can find a link to all the previous parts here. Today Jing Liang looks at one of the most interesting companies in China (and the great competitor of Alibaba) Tencent.  

Tencent – waiting for a better entry point by Jing Liang

One is not often given two bites at the cherry – Chinese proverb
机不可失,时不再来

The value investing founding father Benjamin Graham said, “If you are shopping for common stocks, choose them the way you would buy groceries, not the way you would buy perfume.” One of my favorite investment authors, Peter Lynch says one should only buy what one knows. Combining the two, I conclude Tencent is definitely a company to strategically own but also patiently wait for a better entry point.

The company reported strong second quarter and first half results earlier this month. The headline numbers continue to show its strength of growth and dominance in the Chinese Internet markets especially the online mobile gaming segment. The charts below show the share price growth comparison (2009 to 2014) and its annual earnings generation (2007 to 2013).


 It is worth noting on the earnings chart that Tencent shows an un-interrupted upward trend covering the period of credit crisis. However, the company does come with a high price tag: 40 times PE (as of 25th August) and 23 times EV/EBITDA for 2014 (estimates by Infinancials). Compared to its peers globally (shown below), Tencent’s valuation does stand out from an earnings perspective (earnings data is shown in charts below).

 

Even though the entry point valuation for Tencent right now is less desirable, the company does deserve attention and a place on the watch list. Not only has it been producing consistent results, its size is catching up with its other famous global peers (see charts below).

 

My own Tencent experience went through three phases.  First the instant message software QQ in the late 90s, when suddenly people in China started using QQ instead of MSN for PC messaging.  Then it was QQ virtual farm game in the early 2000s, when friends and relatives in China, especially women, are all on the QQ virtual farm “stealing and harvesting vegetables”.  What was intriguing for me, looking back, is that the game created a never ending dynamics between its users, social interaction and fun at the same time. The most recent significant experience was my registration with the social networking site WeChat in 2012.  The chart below shows WeChat and Facebook users growth.

 

On average, Facebook user base grew 10% each quarter (since 2009) compared to 84% for WeChat. If we just compare the first 3 years of growth of each social network platform (2004 for Facebook and 2010 for WeChat), Facebook user base grew 328% on average and WeChat grew over 900%.  WeChat might be a copycat of Facebook, but its growth is so much faster. This is helped by the government censorship of other global social media in mainland. However, competitions between domestic players have always been fierce (as exemplified in other sectors as well as Internet market).

Tencent CEO Huateng Ma (also known as Pony Ma) once said “Ideas are not important in China – execution is” because “in the America, when you bring an idea to market you usually have several months before competition pops up, allowing you to capture significant market share. In China, you can have hundreds of competitors within the first hours of going live”.

This not only identified the key characteristics of competitive Chinese market, it laid foundation for Tencent strategies: execution focused on users experience, tailored to its users’ needs and interests, creating social network dynamics which create user stickiness in almost all their products and capabilities to monetize its content. The strategies were tested and proved by its success in the online gaming market.

In 2014, gaming segment contributed 56% of Tencent’s top line and it remains the dominant player in Chinese market, whose value, according to Newzoo, is estimated to overtake the US by 2016. The charts below show the annual revenue from China mobile gaming market with estimates provided by CLSA and gaming market share (2012).

 

From the charts above, we can see that Tencent is in a dominant position in the fast growing market with great-anticipated potential. Tencent was ranked No. 1 publisher in China’s iOS App Store by free downloads and revenue for each of the first seven months of 2014 (Tencent first half 2014 results announcement). According to Plain Vanilla Games, which developed QuizUp and in which Tencent invested $22 million, Tencent group’s priority when considering the purchase was not valuation but users experience.

Their willingness to tailor to the local preferences and ability to leverage social network power were also exemplified in their third party internet-payment system – Tenpay. The chart below demonstrates the size of this market in mainland and market share by different providers.

 

The third party online payment market has been growing rapidly as indicated in above chart. The top 3 providers, Alipay, Tenpay and Unionpay’s market share have been quite stable in the last few years. Tencent’s Tenpay at the moment has a stable 19% of the market. During Chinese New Year 2014, Tenpay launched “New Year Red Envelope (hongbao)” app on WeChat.  The app not only allowed people to give red envelopes (a tradition in China to use red envelopes to give money to friends and families), but compared to Alibaba’s Hongbao app, Tencent made it more fun. For example, within a group of 10 friends, a “hongbao” giver could set it up so that only the first five people to “grab” an envelope would get any money (each person can only receive maximum of 200 RMB, around $28, for each red envelope). This has created more fun for people involved. On top of this, users need to register their account details with WeChat in order to make and receive the red envelope, therefore the app has brought more users onto WeChat and broke the first barrier for users to purchase anything online.

However, no one is perfect, not even Tencent. The company has many successes, but also failures. Their eCommerce venture belongs to one of those and their liaison with JD.com is yet to be tested. In addition, its tendency to get into a pricing war is also to be questioned. The latest battle with its rival, Alibaba, was in the Taxi app market.


There are currently 130 million registered accounts in the taxi app market in the mainland. As shown on the chart above, Alibaba and Tencent are the two biggest players with Tencent leading just slightly. Even though the two sides reached the truce, roughly 2 billion RMB (around 325 million USD, Analysys International estimates) was spent on the “fight” between January and June this year. It was an expensive battle with no clear winners according to Analysys. However, it signifies the emergence of two clear dominant rivals in the upcoming Mobile Internet era in China.

Apart from the price war and unsuccessful ventures, another question for Tencent is their overseas expansion. Apart from WeChat, which Tencent has made an effort to expand to Southeast Asia (with 100 million users in 2012 and 2nd most downloaded app in India in 2013) and some small acquisitions in some US gaming start-ups, which is aimed primarily to improve domestic consumer experience, there is no major moves from Tencent. If Tencent really would like to stand among the global giants, oversea expansion is inevitable.

Judging the pros and cons, Tencent is a good company. From its inception in 1998 to becoming an Internet giant within its domestic market, its progress has been very strong and it certainly produced impressive returns, especially if you were lucky to have bought it in 2009 for example (as shown near the start of this piece). However, the share price tag at the current level largely reflects the strong market expectations for future growth. As much as I admire Tencent as a company and its products, I still believe investors need a more desirable entry point. However, should the opportunity come again, let’s say a high-teen EV/EBITDA or at around 100 HKD level, one should certainly seize the day, as one of the Chinese proverbs said, one is not often given two bites of the cherry.


Monday, 18 August 2014

Guest post - "The digital revolution with China characteristics"

This is the fourth in a guest post series on China.  You can find a link to all the previous parts here.  Today Jing Liang looks at some fast evolving parts of the Chinese economy...and comes to some surprising conclusions.  The upcoming Alibaba IPO really does look a must review...additionally there is plenty for Apple and Samsung shareholders - amongst others - to think about.  


Part 4 – "The digital revolution with China characteristics" by Jing Liang 

The students outshine the teachers  -  Chinese idiom
后来居上

The scale, the penetration and the speed of formation (which include how fast people adopt technologies) of China’s digital era is impressive. Similar to every other sectors, they copy first (as many of us know), then they develop their own characteristics in order to adapt to the preferences of locals and then they catch up and compete with their teachers, the foreign competitors in their domestic market.   

When I was in China earlier this year, visiting family and friends, I was really impressed with the digital lifestyle and the digital awareness people have (even in lower tier region such as Shanxi province) – from online video streaming using smart TV, purchasing cinema tickets on smartphone and online shopping to social networks, such as WeChat. When I went to a restaurant in Taiyuan, the waitress told me if I just scanned the bar code on the table, which automatically sent the link of the restaurant to WeChat, I got 10% off instantly, which struck me as a good marketing tactic.

Residents of the West might not find this extraordinary. However, in China, the speed of digital development is phenomenal. Does this mean future growth might take slightly faster trajectory than what analysts would otherwise forecast? Especially with the speed of urbanization, more people will move into cities and this inevitably entails adjusting to the digital age. The chart below illustrates Internet users in 3 countries (US, China, India) as of the first half of 2014 and their penetration rate in terms of percentage of local population.

 China has just reached over 640 million users (with 46% penetration rate comparing to 87% in the US) in the first half of 2014, a number which is more than both US and India combined. The availabilities and expansion of the Internet provided possibilities and the necessary playing field for other digital culture development, e.g. the development of social networking platforms. Tencent’s WeChat, the answer to Facebook or Twitter in China (to me, it is the blend of both) was created late 2010. The chart below shows the number of users each quarter since 2011.
 
On average, Facebook user base grew 10% each quarter (since 2009) comparing to 84% for WeChat. If we just compare the first 3 years of growth of each social network platform (2004 for Facebook and 2010 for WeChat), Facebook user base grew 328% on average and WeChat grew over 900%.  WeChat might be a copycat of Facebook, but its growth is so much faster.

Chinese government censorship of foreign competitors is possibly one of the main reasons for this faster growth. Another reason could be that Facebook, as one of the pioneers for social network, has already established the market acceptance of the concept and WeChat, as a late comer, simply just arrived at the right time and tabbed into a market that is ready for it.

Growth aside, WeChat also has developed certain characteristics of its own, such as voice messaging and gaming (tied to WeChat), which became one of its highest revenue contributors based on its second quarter result. In addition, unless your contacts are mutual acquainted between them, they will not be able to see the comment made by the others on your post. This is very different from Facebook or Twitter. It reflects, I think, Chinese characteristics.

Apart from the expansion of the Internet, the booming of social network is also a result of and further push for the fast growth of portable devices, i.e. smartphone and tablets. Over 80% of Internet users, around 500 million of them, are using portable devices browsing Internet at some point. China has already overtaken the US as the biggest smartphone market in 2012.

Out of top 5 smartphone brands in the mainland (as shown above), 4 of which are domestic producers as of the second quarter 2014. Xiaomi overtook Samsung this time and became the largest smartphone seller. The company is only 4-year-old. It has delivered products that are tailored for the locals. It has focused on its locally relevant operating system features and services, combined with effectively executed marketing strategy and pushed volumes at aggressive price points. The strategies have been adopted by many other domestic players, such as Lenovo, which is now the fourth largest smartphone makers as of the first half in 2014. These strategies are the key reasons for the dramatic change of smartphone market landscape in the mainland in the last 5 years.

In 2009, there were hardly any domestic players in the smartphone/featured mobile market in the mainland (chart above on the left), Nokia was still the dominant player and even Samsung only captured 3% of the market. However, in 2014 (second quarter, chart on the right), apart from Samsung, hardly any foreign players were able to sustain significant market share. Aggressive pricing at the expense of margins is always the strategy used by the local players in order to gain market share at the initial stage, especially in the mid to lower tier market segment, which shows strongest growth. However, the qualities of their products are also improving.

I noticed, especially in the lower tier regions, people focus more on both pricing and practicality, e.g. easy access to the stores or post sale services, and not so much on branding image, which was one of the key reasons for purchasing foreign higher end products. Therefore, for foreign brands, such as Samsung and Apple, simply focus on higher end, higher quality and market image building might not be enough to maintain their market position in the mainland, as clearly indicated by the charts above.  With increased commoditization of portable device segment, strategy of targeting practicality, local taste with the focus slightly shift to mid (or mid to lower) end market might be required for foreign brands to compete in the mainland.

The development of smartphone/tablets market, the increased Internet availabilities, a more established online payment system and fast growing online social network provided extra push for the further development of eCommerce. In 2000, China only had 2.1 million total Internet users and all other important ingredient for the eCommerce, such as logistics and online payment system, are lacking. Fast forward to 2014, the chart below shows, in terms of eCommerce transaction value, China has already overtaken the US:
 

The chart was based on 2013 data in which compounded growth of eCommerce transaction was 70% in the mainland (KPMG estimates).

From what I observed, people are increasingly adopting online shopping, either from their PCs or their mobiles, the established payment system and delivery system made it more convenient. Crucially, online shopping solves two most important issues in the mainland. First, it satisfied consumers’ need for comparing items, both in terms of quality (checking reviews provided by other consumers) and pricing. Secondly, it solved the geographical issues caused by the size of the mainland and low penetration of some brands in some lower tier regions.

Even with this fast growth, the eCommerce only captures around 10% of total retail sales market in the second quarter of 2014 (earlier than 2015 which some of analysts have estimated). The below chart shows market share by different online shopping platforms (B2C) as of 2nd quarter this year:

 
As shown on the chart, the B2C market is largely dominated by domestic players. Alibaba’s Tmall represents 56% of the B2C segment. According to 2013 Alibaba’s filing to SEC in preparation of its IPO, both Tmall and Taobao handled $248 billion purchase. This means Alibaba accounts for nearly 84% of volumes in the mainland. Its value of merchandise sold in 2012 has already surpassed Ebay and Amazon combined (KPMG estimates). With its dominant position in a fast growing segment with great potential, its IPO does deserve attention.

To conclude, from what I observed this time in the mainland, combined with figures and data presented above, I was impressed with the progress. Even though one might argue China is still lacking originality and innovation. As a country just opened up its market in the 80s, I think the progress of the last 35 years have been extraordinary. As the technology matures, we already see signs of innovation, which is exemplified by how they tailor to local markets’ preferences, using targeted marketing strategies which leverage characteristics of digital age (e.g. Xiaomi’s online fire sale) to gain market share.  

In addition, another reason why China’s digital revolution can progress so fast is a relatively simultaneous establishment of various ingredients: readily available expertise from foreign brands, established market acceptance of the digital concept pioneered by foreign companies and established infrastructure. Everything is at the right place at the right time.

As China progresses and matures, the real sustainable growth will have to come from significant innovation. The students outshine the teachers for now in their domestic market.  However, will they be able to become the master and eventually the real leaders, not just in domestic market but overseas? We will just have to wait and see.

Monday, 11 August 2014

Guest post - "Food safety and air pollution in China is an opportunity and not a threat"

This is the third part of a guest author series on China.  You can find links to parts 1 and 2 here. 

 
Part 3 - Food safety and air pollution in China is an opportunity and not a threat by Jing Liang

Afflictions are sometimes blessings in disguise
塞翁失马,焉知非福
                                                                              - Chinese proverb

Food safety and air pollution are the two most popular topics I heard when I was in China between April and June, ranking just after property and the anti-corruption campaign.

However, an English saying – every cloud has a silver lining – comes to mind.  After my visit to Shanxi this time, I observed two developments.  First, the central government is taking serious actions in tackling the food safety and air pollution issues. Second, these policy actions have trickled down to the local government levels as exemplified by visible actions e.g. the availability of higher quality farming products including organic food and tourism in remote mountain areas for the clean air. Both private businesses and local governments have started to explore business opportunities that centre around these two issues, especially in the lower tier regions, which often have more unexploited resources in terms of land and clean air.  

Shanxi (my home province), a lower tier province, is one of the most polluted provinces in China. However, when I was visiting this time, I noticed some positive actions they took to clean up the air pollution. Not only was I impressed with the fresh air and blue sky in Lingshi County (see below), I also noticed in Taiyuan, the capital city, that it has made considerable effort to reduce cars relate pollutions by pushing a bike-sharing program (equivalent to Boris bike in London). The chart below shows the size of the bike-sharing program worldwide:
 
 

Out of 21 cities ranked by the chart, 16 from China. Apart from Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen are Tier 1 cities, the others are either tier 2 or tier 3 cities or lower. I was very impressed that Taiyuan made it to top 5.

The locals also started to explore tourism to leverage their existing clean environment in remote mountainous area (Shanxi literally means Mountain West in Chinese).

I took a picture (below) when I was visiting the Red Canyon in Lingshi County, a lower tier town outside Taiyuan, in May and the picture second below is an image I found on google by typing “Beijing smog Tianenmen”, which is becoming a dominant image whenever China and pollution are mentioned:
 
 
 
The Red Canyon was developed by a private company. The key selling point is the clean air away from larger cities and it shows to me that the lower tier regions are using their natural resource to tap into the booming tourism industry. Saying this, whilst I was there, I found the infrastructure, e.g. hotels and restaurants, were still very under-developed. It indicates there is room for a lot of further growth.

In addition to tourism, lower tier regions are also leveraging their land to explore organic and high quality farming products, given consumers have increased food safety concerns. According to Credit Suisse estimates, because of increased urbanization and the increased level of disposable income, the estimated retail value of agriculture products will reach 405 trillion RMB in 2015 (from 15.4 trillion in 2010). China agriculture contributed 10.2% to its total GDP as of 2012 so such an increase can make a useful contribution. The chart below shows a rough picture the regional differences on agriculture produce:
 
 
I visited an organic farm located in a village at the bottom of the Wu Tai mountain, in Wu Tai County (another lower tier county town). The farm produces high quality livestock. I also visited Jingle County, which specializes in producing high quality millet and other coarse food grain (e.g. maize, sorghum) because of its suitable climate. The main way of generating revenue for these farms and others in smaller counties is to sell directly to restaurants and supermarket chains. However, the common issue they share is lack of scale.  One of the key barriers to overcome is that they lack a controllable production and transportation chain. It is the opposite issue faced by some restaurant/fast food chain, which are desperately seeking reliable suppliers within a more integrated supply chain.

In late July, Yum! Brands and McDonald’s announced its decision to cut an existing supplier, who supplied low quality expired meat. Yum!, who generated 37% of their operating profit as per their last quarterly results disclosure from China, is facing head winds because of this negative news. This follows similar scandals a year or so ago. 

However, with all these scandals, I did not see people boycotting Pizza Hut or KFC. When I asked people if they were worried, the general response was that they were. However, people prefer to pay more to go to bigger restaurants or branded chains, such as Pizza Hut or KFC. The consumers seem to believe if there is any issue, these companies will make compensation. The businesses that do suffer, I noticed, are the street food stalls or smaller scale businesses.

Therefore, I think the issues faced by Yum! Brands and similar companies are not permanent. There are quality suppliers out there in the mainland and they just have to find a way to reach them. Building up an integrated supply chain is only matter of time and is definitely not impossible. Hence, the scandalous headlines should not signify longer-term issues for these companies, and short-term fluctuation in their share prices may well be creating a buying opportunity for longer-term investors.

To conclude from my observations during my visit in the spring, I think the existence of food safety and air pollution issues have given an extra push for the effort the government needed to move to a more sustainable growth route, e.g. the development of more integrated supply chain that the food industry desperately needs, as well as the investment into clean energy (e.g. gas) infrastructure, especially in some lower tier regions, which are becoming the driving force of the whole economy.

The encouraging news is that the evidence of action is everywhere.  

Friday, 1 August 2014

Guest post: "Lower tier regions – the key indicator of China’s future"

As Financial Orbit moves into its second year I promised some further content innovations.  One of these is the introduction of guest authors. 

Jing Liang grew up in Shanxi Province (Taiyuan City, northern China) but left China fifteen years ago to come to the UK to study and work in the financial sector, most recently at an international investment bank. This is the second posting (you can find the first posting here titled 'Provincial diversification: a missing piece of the China investment jigsaw') in a proposed multi-part series from someone with real and direct insights into the building power, influence and potential challenges of the Chinese economy.

Part 2:  Lower tier regions – the key indicator of China’s future by Jing Liang

The dragon has nine sons, all of them are different – Chinese proverb

During the last 15 years in the UK, I learnt that the main way to socialise with friends is to visit pubs and that each region has its own local beer. The key way to socialise in Mainland China is to go to restaurants. Every time I visit different provinces in China, the first thing I notice is how different the local cuisines are comparing to one another. The opening remark of the popular documentary A Bite of China says that China has billions of people, has one of the world’s most abundant and diversified natural landscape, plateaus, forests, coasts and the mixture of China’s geography and climate has helped different natural products in different regions to grow and prosper. This leads to a diversification of cultures in cuisines in the Mainland. This diversification is also exemplified in other areas.

Mainland China has 31 provinces (including 22 provinces, 4 municipalities, 5 autonomous regions) which are the highest level Chinese administrative division. Municipalities (Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin and Chongqing) are cities but have higher-level status than some of the common provinces, e.g. Beijing, as the capital, is also the centre of culture and politics of China, whilst Shanghai is the economic centre. 

In part 1, I discussed how provincial differences need to be addressed and individual provinces should be closely examined in order to get a closer picture of Mainland. One of key reasons is that the provinces are becoming increasingly significant, in terms of size, as individual economic entities.

I did a quick comparison between the 31 Mainland China provinces and 28 countries within the EU, putting them into one group and ranking them in terms of GDP, GDP per capita and population. The table shows the top 30 from the group (the Chinese provinces are shaded in yellow):


                    Source: figures are collected from wikipedia.org.

Clearly, not many provinces made it to the league table when GDP per capita was used but given the relative speed of Chinese development this will progressively change over the next decade. The table also shows that there are big gaps between different provinces in terms of economic performances. The differences are partly due to government policies e.g. early special economic zones or coastal provinces that benefited from favorable policies.

Source: figures are collected from Wikipedia.org.

The above charts show GDP and GDP per capita in 2013 for the provinces and their respective growth rates. The differences between the advanced regions and lower tier regions are often huge, both in terms of size and growth rates. In general, lower tier regions show stronger growth in both measures. However, not all lower tier regions have the same growth power, e.g. Shanxi, which is highlighted in red, has been growing rather slowly comparing to others, such as Guizhou, highlighted in green. Guizhou recently has received a lot of government favorable policies – it is one of the key focus for the government anti-poverty project. Guizhou also received support to establish the second Zhongguancun Science and Technology Park, which is the equivalent of Silicon Valley in Beijing. However, another reason is the difference in economic drivers. The charts below give a quick comparison between four provinces – Guangdong and Zhejiang are top tier regions, Shanxi and Guizhou are lower tiers.  


Guangdong and Zhejiang are top tier regions which have a more balanced sector structure. Comparing Shanxi and Guizhou, one obvious observation is that Shanxi is more relying on the secondary (manufacturing) component. In the middle of economic transition, this might be one of the key reasons why Shanxi is experiencing slow growth, as economic focus shifts more to the consumer sector (typically more tertiary focused). However, when I was visiting Shanxi in May this year, I observed the economic transition is well underway. During my visit this time (I come from Taiyuan, Shanxi) I visited Taiyuan (the provincial capital), Xinzhou (prefecture level city), Wutai County and Jingle County (see table below for some statistics on each place). I was impressed with the urbanization progress in Taiyuan (will be discussed in later parts) however what I was most impressed with was the plans and focus Jingle County placed on promoting the sustainable growth route.  


Jingle (the name means “peace and happy”) is a small county town (160,000 people, 130,000 of which are farmers) which is administered by Xinzhou City and is one of the anti-poverty projects in China (meaning that they receive government grants to support local economic development). I learnt that the local government and the local farmers have already started to focus on using their non-exploited natural farmland, water and air to attract investments, which are much more tailored to their provincial advantages and hence potentially sustainable in the long term. Their investment projects include roses for commercial use, quinoa production (targeting international market and increased awareness of healthy living in top tier regions of China), grapes, traditional agriculture products and tourism, e.g. they advertise their clean air and beautiful green mountains to attract tourism from nearby polluted cities. All of which are leveraging people’s concerns on food safety and air quality. Obviously, there are still needs for more organized commercially focused operations and further investment in its development.

However, I do think Jingle’s existing projects and strategies are more sustainable, healthy and balanced. There are lots of places in China, like Jingle, which are still very under-developed based on GDP/capita figures often because they are located in inland regions. The results from their sustainable development policies might not be immediate: Shanxi province still ranked quite low in terms of growth in the first half this year (see chart below).  In terms however of sustainability and medium-term focus it represents a high quality growth level.
                       Source: figures are collected from iFeng, Xinhua News, Sina news.

Central and western region (in green), which mostly are lower tier regions (apart from Tianjin), are showing the strongest growth. As we all know, the future of China depends on how well China transit itself from an economy that is heavily rely on infrastructure investments to an economy that is supported by more sustainable and healthier consumption. Therefore, as the lower tiers are slowly becoming the major drivers of the China growth, to understand their development dynamics will be one of the key factors to judge how successful the transition will be.

According to Want China Times, consumption now contributes more to GDP growth than investments and exports. Consumption accounts for 54.4% of China's recent economic expansion, while investments account for 48.5% and exports account for -2.9%, according to data from China's National Bureau of Statistics. Consumption grew 11% during the first half of this year in China, higher than the economic growth rate for the same period, according to bureau data.

Even though this transition is causing a slowing down in some regions, the key lesson from even a slow growth zone like Shanxi is that efforts to improve the quality of growth across the country is high on the policy agenda.  This is important to remember when you read stories about whether China will grow at 6%, 7% or 8% this year.  The debate in China concerns how to keep such growth levels for the decade to ensure the development of the inland areas and lower tier cities. 

The transition might look painful in some area in the short term, but in return of the growing pain, China is more likely to enjoy more sustainable growth in the long run and understand the lower tier region will be the key to un-cover the growth pattern. 

Developing this in part 3 I will discuss why I think changes in perceptions to food safety and air pollution have created opportunities for the economy in transition and lower tier regions in particular.