Continuing this marvellous guest author series on China and related investment matters, Jing Liang looks at the history and prospects of the company everyone is talking about at the moment: Alibaba
Who
is Alibaba? by Jing Liang
Suppleness
triumphs over hardness, softness over strength – Lao Tzu
弱之胜强, 柔之胜刚
When growing up in the
mainland, children were often told the story of Ali Baba and 40 thieves. I was
always amazed by the intelligence of Ali Baba and his friends who not only successfully
outwitted the thieves using their own tricks but were able to reserve all the
treasure and share them with the villagers. This month, as Alibaba – China’s eCommerce/Internet
conglomerate – is going to be floated on the US stock market, its success in
one of the fastest growing but most competitive markets is captivating. But who
is Alibaba exactly? How did it achieve the success? How do they make money and
what’s their potential? And, of course, what are the risks?
In its 2014 IPO SEC
filing, Alibaba stated it is planning to issue around 320 million shares and
hopes to price its shares between $60 and $66 each. If the Alibaba IPO achieved
the higher end of this range, Alibaba would raise just over $21 billion and
become the largest IPO in history as indicated by the chart below.
The table below shows Alibaba’s earnings information between 2010 and 2014 based on its IPO filing.
Bloomberg polled 12
analysts and Alibaba was valued at $168 billion on average, it reflects 33x
EV/EBITDA based on earning for the year ending March 2014, which is similar to
its peers such as Tencent and it obviously indicates the exuberance of the
market for the impending IPO. I have used the valuation calculator provided by
the FT, which includes forward-looking earnings estimates for the next 7 years.
The following is my result.
The valuation tool
includes forecast of the five factors listed above. On the right hand side is
the forecast I made. The model itself is really sensitive to the change – by
decimal places – of each component. Rather than speculating its accuracy (as it
is really like a winning a lottery), it is more useful to use it as a tool for
direction of valuation.
The simple assumptions
made (as shown above) for each component is based on relatively strong growth
in eCommerce in China, Alibaba’s dominance in the market, its past performance
(as stated in earnings’ table) and possible slowdown in terms of profitability
towards the end of forecasting period (possible reasons include domestic
competition, market saturation, etc). The valuation I came up with is $237
billion (US$98 per share) valuation implying an EV/EBITDA multiple just over
20x for 2016 forward earnings. That makes the proposed IPO pricing at $60 to $66
in the prospectus a “buying” opportunity…the trouble is there is anticipated to
be a significant leap on day 1 of trading as well.
Who
is Alibaba?
Alibaba is an Internet
conglomerate in Mainland China that was founded in 1999. Its origins are in a
company called 1688.com which was set up to level the playing field for
small-medium enterprise (SMEs) enabling them to leverage innovation and
technology to compete in both domestic and global markets. Fast forward to
2014, it is now offering a mixture of Internet based services ranging from B2B
(business-to-business), B2C (business-to-consumer) to a range of digital
related services. The following table gives a quick overview of what Alibaba
does and who the global equivalents are:
In 2014 (based on its
2014 IPO SEC filing), it generated US$296 billion of gross merchandise value
(GMV), 14.5 billion annual orders and it has 279 million annual active buyers. According
to KPMG, Alibaba had already surpassed both eBay and Amazon combined in terms
of GMV in 2012.
The above chart shows
the quarterly Alibaba GMV since 2012 and the percentage of which were generated
through mobile device, which is a fast growing eCommerce platform in China. In
second quarter 2014, Alibaba’s Tmall represented 57% of total transactions
volumes in China B2C market.
How
did it achieve its success so far?
Jack Ma, the
charismatic founder of Alibaba once said: “The
difference between China e-commerce and US e-commerce is that e-commerce in the
USA is what I call the dessert – it’s supplementary to their main business,
because the USA’s infrastructure of doing business is so good. So it is very
difficult for e-commerce in the USA to grow, to develop, to surpass the
traditional business. But in China, because the infrastructure of commerce is
too bad, then e-commerce becomes the main course.”
The comment not only
addressed the key difference between the eCommerce operating environment in the
US and China, it also explains one of the key reasons for Alibaba’s fast growth.
The
chart on the left shows retail space per capita in five countries including
China. As it points out, in terms of
commerce infrastructure, China still has a lot of catching up to do especially
given its large population base and geographical diversity. However, the purchasing
power for Chinese consumers is increasing at a faster pace. The chart on the
right hand side shows the pace of eCommerce growth in both the US and China. As
pointed out by the chart, China’s eCommerce growth has already surpassed the US
in 2012. The relatively slow commerce infrastructure and purchasing power
growth have created opportunities for the fast growth of eCommerce. As pointed
out by Jack Ma, not only eCommerce is a supplement for the traditional mainstream
businesses, it is mainstream itself in China.
Apart from the macro
environment in China that provided the necessary pre-requisite condition for
the fast growth of Alibaba, in order to establish its dominance and combat the
fierce competition from both the domestic and foreign competitors, two insights
on Chinese market provided Aliaba an edge:
1.
The
average Chinese consumer is tight fisted. On Alibaba’s B2B platform, Alibaba removed
all basic services fees. Fees are only charged for services such as advertising
and web-design. The strategy helped Alibaba to gain size. The size in turn created
and increased the value for its other business, e.g. advertising business. Because
of the sheer size of Alibaba’s eCommerce platform, it is able to block the search
engine such as Baidu and lead consumers directly to its site to find goods.
This made advertising on Alibaba platform more valuable. Also, the strategy of
removing basic service fees made Alibaba a formidable competitor. The chart
below shows the battle between Alibaba’s unit Taobao and eBay, who entered the
market in 2002 via acquisition of EachNet.
2. In
general, the Chinese are reluctant to trust strangers especially when it comes
to doing business. Therefore, Alibaba provided a safety net by offering vetting
services. In addition, the payment system Alipay provided the certainty of payments.
Unlike Paypal, which only collect payment on the point of purchase, Alipay
holds funds under an escrow account and therefore the payment is secured before
purchase. Because of eCommerce, Alipay obtained vast amount of credit data on
its user base, which enables Alibaba to provide micro loan (average size around
$8000) to its users.
It seems to me, the success
of Alibaba are not just because of its early bird advantage, that it is also riding
the wave of a strong China Internet commerce development. It is branching out
into other areas to build a coherent ecosystem that is based on its foundation
business and leveraging a strong self-reinforcing network effects.
As shown on its home
page, Alibaba promises a 102-year sustainable growth, so how will they achieve
this? What is the potential?
What
is the main revenue driver and what are the potential?
Alibaba generates
revenue through online marketing services, commission on transactions and fees
for online services. In addition, they also generate revenues through fees from
memberships, value-added services and cloud computing services. The following
chart shows a breakdown of their top line by business type for the year ending
31st December 2013
The
chart indicates the majority of Alibaba’s top line comes from China and
eCommerce. The three marketplaces – Tmall, Taobao and Juhuasuan – contributed 82.7%
of revenue generated in 2013. Therefore, one can say Alibaba’s near future
still depends on China and further growth of eCommerce.
China
on average is slowing based on GDP growth alone. However, the lower tier
regions still are showing signs of strong growth momentum (see chart below on
the left). Furthermore, the Internet penetration growth is speeding up in the
lower tier regions in China as indicated on the chart below on the right.
One of the key reasons
for the fast growth of eCommerce in China is because of its unique mainstream
nature, which is especially reflected in the lower tier regions, where commerce
infrastructure is less developed comparing to the coastal areas. Therefore,
eCommerce is a crucial market strategy for merchants to reach out the consumers
there. In order to enhance its reach to the lower tier regions, Alibaba has a
joint agreement with China Post, which has the world largest postal network and
most importantly, it has deeper reach into China’s lower tier regions.
In addition, consumption,
as portion of GDP is increasing (currently around 34% of GDP, still lower than
the average worldwide) and China has already become the second biggest consumer
in the world overtaking Japan in 2013 (as per the Economist, 18th Feb 2014 edition). However, eCommerce as portion of retail sales
is still small, roughly around 10%. The below chart shows the percentage of GDP
that is come from Internet related expenditures.
China has overtaken
the US already in 2013. However, there is sample room for further growth. As
pointed out by the research done by McKinsey, China’s eCommerce is largely
consumer driven. So the potential lies with continued lower tier Internet
penetration, continued consumption growth and eCommerce that is driven by
retail consumers. So what are the risks?
The
risks
China slow down,
possibilities of slower consumption growth and an un-realization of lower tier
regions’ potential are all possible risk factors and there are many others
mentioned in Alibaba filing with the SEC. However, I think one of the biggest
challenges is its competition with its domestic rivals and its tendency to get
into the pricing war, like other corporations in China often do. The latest
battle with its rival, Tencent, was in the Taxi app market.
There are currently
130 million registered accounts in the taxi app market in the mainland. As
shown on the chart above, Alibaba and Tencent are the two biggest players with
Tencent leading just slightly. Even though the two sides reached the truce,
roughly 2 billion RMB (around 325 million USD, Analysys International
estimates) was spent on the “fight” between January and June this year. It was
an expensive battle with no clear winners according to Analysys. However, it
signifies the emergence of two clear dominant rivals in the upcoming Mobile
Internet era in China.
To compete with
Tencent, one of Alibaba’s key challenges is to break into Social Network
segment of Mobile Internet. One of Tencent’s key strength is its ability to
leverage its social network (SNW) to create user stickiness which is
exemplified in its gaming, its WeChat and its latest Red-pocket app (Hongbao, Chinese
tradition to give money as a gift to family and friends in Chinese New Year),
which outshone Alibaba’s similar app because its “fun” element created for
users. The following chart shows the league table of the most popular apps in
China in May 2014.
As indicated by the
Chart, Alibaba in the mobile app area still has long way to catch up with its
rivals, especially Tencent. To counter this, Alibaba has made a few strategic
purchases, e.g. it took an 18% of stake in WeiBo, and it has just launched its
very own SNW app, Laiwang. However, with Tencent’s dominant position in the SNW
area, Alibaba needs more than just acquisitions and launching a similar app,
which are typical tactics used by established giant corporations that need to
catch up.
This is one area that
Alibaba needs new ideas.
Conclusion
With all factors
considered, the long awaited IPO of Alibaba is an exciting event on its own.
After 30 years of opening up its market, China has started to deliver
corporations that truly stand for Chinese entrepreneur values and the true
potential lies in how Alibaba re-shaped the ways, especially for SMEs, of
growth for other businesses in the mainland. If Alibaba fulfills its promise it
made on its corporate statement, that it is truly going to “live” for at least
102 years, the IPO is just a beginning of its history. No wonder it appears
that this is an IPO everyone appears to be excited to be part of.




































