Pages

Friday, 1 August 2014

Guest post: "Lower tier regions – the key indicator of China’s future"

As Financial Orbit moves into its second year I promised some further content innovations.  One of these is the introduction of guest authors. 

Jing Liang grew up in Shanxi Province (Taiyuan City, northern China) but left China fifteen years ago to come to the UK to study and work in the financial sector, most recently at an international investment bank. This is the second posting (you can find the first posting here titled 'Provincial diversification: a missing piece of the China investment jigsaw') in a proposed multi-part series from someone with real and direct insights into the building power, influence and potential challenges of the Chinese economy.

Part 2:  Lower tier regions – the key indicator of China’s future by Jing Liang

The dragon has nine sons, all of them are different – Chinese proverb

During the last 15 years in the UK, I learnt that the main way to socialise with friends is to visit pubs and that each region has its own local beer. The key way to socialise in Mainland China is to go to restaurants. Every time I visit different provinces in China, the first thing I notice is how different the local cuisines are comparing to one another. The opening remark of the popular documentary A Bite of China says that China has billions of people, has one of the world’s most abundant and diversified natural landscape, plateaus, forests, coasts and the mixture of China’s geography and climate has helped different natural products in different regions to grow and prosper. This leads to a diversification of cultures in cuisines in the Mainland. This diversification is also exemplified in other areas.

Mainland China has 31 provinces (including 22 provinces, 4 municipalities, 5 autonomous regions) which are the highest level Chinese administrative division. Municipalities (Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin and Chongqing) are cities but have higher-level status than some of the common provinces, e.g. Beijing, as the capital, is also the centre of culture and politics of China, whilst Shanghai is the economic centre. 

In part 1, I discussed how provincial differences need to be addressed and individual provinces should be closely examined in order to get a closer picture of Mainland. One of key reasons is that the provinces are becoming increasingly significant, in terms of size, as individual economic entities.

I did a quick comparison between the 31 Mainland China provinces and 28 countries within the EU, putting them into one group and ranking them in terms of GDP, GDP per capita and population. The table shows the top 30 from the group (the Chinese provinces are shaded in yellow):


                    Source: figures are collected from wikipedia.org.

Clearly, not many provinces made it to the league table when GDP per capita was used but given the relative speed of Chinese development this will progressively change over the next decade. The table also shows that there are big gaps between different provinces in terms of economic performances. The differences are partly due to government policies e.g. early special economic zones or coastal provinces that benefited from favorable policies.

Source: figures are collected from Wikipedia.org.

The above charts show GDP and GDP per capita in 2013 for the provinces and their respective growth rates. The differences between the advanced regions and lower tier regions are often huge, both in terms of size and growth rates. In general, lower tier regions show stronger growth in both measures. However, not all lower tier regions have the same growth power, e.g. Shanxi, which is highlighted in red, has been growing rather slowly comparing to others, such as Guizhou, highlighted in green. Guizhou recently has received a lot of government favorable policies – it is one of the key focus for the government anti-poverty project. Guizhou also received support to establish the second Zhongguancun Science and Technology Park, which is the equivalent of Silicon Valley in Beijing. However, another reason is the difference in economic drivers. The charts below give a quick comparison between four provinces – Guangdong and Zhejiang are top tier regions, Shanxi and Guizhou are lower tiers.  


Guangdong and Zhejiang are top tier regions which have a more balanced sector structure. Comparing Shanxi and Guizhou, one obvious observation is that Shanxi is more relying on the secondary (manufacturing) component. In the middle of economic transition, this might be one of the key reasons why Shanxi is experiencing slow growth, as economic focus shifts more to the consumer sector (typically more tertiary focused). However, when I was visiting Shanxi in May this year, I observed the economic transition is well underway. During my visit this time (I come from Taiyuan, Shanxi) I visited Taiyuan (the provincial capital), Xinzhou (prefecture level city), Wutai County and Jingle County (see table below for some statistics on each place). I was impressed with the urbanization progress in Taiyuan (will be discussed in later parts) however what I was most impressed with was the plans and focus Jingle County placed on promoting the sustainable growth route.  


Jingle (the name means “peace and happy”) is a small county town (160,000 people, 130,000 of which are farmers) which is administered by Xinzhou City and is one of the anti-poverty projects in China (meaning that they receive government grants to support local economic development). I learnt that the local government and the local farmers have already started to focus on using their non-exploited natural farmland, water and air to attract investments, which are much more tailored to their provincial advantages and hence potentially sustainable in the long term. Their investment projects include roses for commercial use, quinoa production (targeting international market and increased awareness of healthy living in top tier regions of China), grapes, traditional agriculture products and tourism, e.g. they advertise their clean air and beautiful green mountains to attract tourism from nearby polluted cities. All of which are leveraging people’s concerns on food safety and air quality. Obviously, there are still needs for more organized commercially focused operations and further investment in its development.

However, I do think Jingle’s existing projects and strategies are more sustainable, healthy and balanced. There are lots of places in China, like Jingle, which are still very under-developed based on GDP/capita figures often because they are located in inland regions. The results from their sustainable development policies might not be immediate: Shanxi province still ranked quite low in terms of growth in the first half this year (see chart below).  In terms however of sustainability and medium-term focus it represents a high quality growth level.
                       Source: figures are collected from iFeng, Xinhua News, Sina news.

Central and western region (in green), which mostly are lower tier regions (apart from Tianjin), are showing the strongest growth. As we all know, the future of China depends on how well China transit itself from an economy that is heavily rely on infrastructure investments to an economy that is supported by more sustainable and healthier consumption. Therefore, as the lower tiers are slowly becoming the major drivers of the China growth, to understand their development dynamics will be one of the key factors to judge how successful the transition will be.

According to Want China Times, consumption now contributes more to GDP growth than investments and exports. Consumption accounts for 54.4% of China's recent economic expansion, while investments account for 48.5% and exports account for -2.9%, according to data from China's National Bureau of Statistics. Consumption grew 11% during the first half of this year in China, higher than the economic growth rate for the same period, according to bureau data.

Even though this transition is causing a slowing down in some regions, the key lesson from even a slow growth zone like Shanxi is that efforts to improve the quality of growth across the country is high on the policy agenda.  This is important to remember when you read stories about whether China will grow at 6%, 7% or 8% this year.  The debate in China concerns how to keep such growth levels for the decade to ensure the development of the inland areas and lower tier cities. 

The transition might look painful in some area in the short term, but in return of the growing pain, China is more likely to enjoy more sustainable growth in the long run and understand the lower tier region will be the key to un-cover the growth pattern. 

Developing this in part 3 I will discuss why I think changes in perceptions to food safety and air pollution have created opportunities for the economy in transition and lower tier regions in particular.   


2 comments:

  1. China's many challenges create infinite opportunities for entrpreneurs. The planet has become one place and China will be a leader in unifying nations into a global body. I support the wisdom of Asia in tempering the myopic rapacity of the West.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, I agree...and as per the wrap yesterday (31/07/14) China and a select few other countries are the creditor nations too. Another way to temper the 'myopic rapacity of the West' as you nicely put it! http://financialorbit.blogspot.com/2014/07/financial-orbit-wrap-31-07-14.html

    ReplyDelete