Pages

Monday, 18 August 2014

Guest post - "The digital revolution with China characteristics"

This is the fourth in a guest post series on China.  You can find a link to all the previous parts here.  Today Jing Liang looks at some fast evolving parts of the Chinese economy...and comes to some surprising conclusions.  The upcoming Alibaba IPO really does look a must review...additionally there is plenty for Apple and Samsung shareholders - amongst others - to think about.  


Part 4 – "The digital revolution with China characteristics" by Jing Liang 

The students outshine the teachers  -  Chinese idiom
后来居上

The scale, the penetration and the speed of formation (which include how fast people adopt technologies) of China’s digital era is impressive. Similar to every other sectors, they copy first (as many of us know), then they develop their own characteristics in order to adapt to the preferences of locals and then they catch up and compete with their teachers, the foreign competitors in their domestic market.   

When I was in China earlier this year, visiting family and friends, I was really impressed with the digital lifestyle and the digital awareness people have (even in lower tier region such as Shanxi province) – from online video streaming using smart TV, purchasing cinema tickets on smartphone and online shopping to social networks, such as WeChat. When I went to a restaurant in Taiyuan, the waitress told me if I just scanned the bar code on the table, which automatically sent the link of the restaurant to WeChat, I got 10% off instantly, which struck me as a good marketing tactic.

Residents of the West might not find this extraordinary. However, in China, the speed of digital development is phenomenal. Does this mean future growth might take slightly faster trajectory than what analysts would otherwise forecast? Especially with the speed of urbanization, more people will move into cities and this inevitably entails adjusting to the digital age. The chart below illustrates Internet users in 3 countries (US, China, India) as of the first half of 2014 and their penetration rate in terms of percentage of local population.

 China has just reached over 640 million users (with 46% penetration rate comparing to 87% in the US) in the first half of 2014, a number which is more than both US and India combined. The availabilities and expansion of the Internet provided possibilities and the necessary playing field for other digital culture development, e.g. the development of social networking platforms. Tencent’s WeChat, the answer to Facebook or Twitter in China (to me, it is the blend of both) was created late 2010. The chart below shows the number of users each quarter since 2011.
 
On average, Facebook user base grew 10% each quarter (since 2009) comparing to 84% for WeChat. If we just compare the first 3 years of growth of each social network platform (2004 for Facebook and 2010 for WeChat), Facebook user base grew 328% on average and WeChat grew over 900%.  WeChat might be a copycat of Facebook, but its growth is so much faster.

Chinese government censorship of foreign competitors is possibly one of the main reasons for this faster growth. Another reason could be that Facebook, as one of the pioneers for social network, has already established the market acceptance of the concept and WeChat, as a late comer, simply just arrived at the right time and tabbed into a market that is ready for it.

Growth aside, WeChat also has developed certain characteristics of its own, such as voice messaging and gaming (tied to WeChat), which became one of its highest revenue contributors based on its second quarter result. In addition, unless your contacts are mutual acquainted between them, they will not be able to see the comment made by the others on your post. This is very different from Facebook or Twitter. It reflects, I think, Chinese characteristics.

Apart from the expansion of the Internet, the booming of social network is also a result of and further push for the fast growth of portable devices, i.e. smartphone and tablets. Over 80% of Internet users, around 500 million of them, are using portable devices browsing Internet at some point. China has already overtaken the US as the biggest smartphone market in 2012.

Out of top 5 smartphone brands in the mainland (as shown above), 4 of which are domestic producers as of the second quarter 2014. Xiaomi overtook Samsung this time and became the largest smartphone seller. The company is only 4-year-old. It has delivered products that are tailored for the locals. It has focused on its locally relevant operating system features and services, combined with effectively executed marketing strategy and pushed volumes at aggressive price points. The strategies have been adopted by many other domestic players, such as Lenovo, which is now the fourth largest smartphone makers as of the first half in 2014. These strategies are the key reasons for the dramatic change of smartphone market landscape in the mainland in the last 5 years.

In 2009, there were hardly any domestic players in the smartphone/featured mobile market in the mainland (chart above on the left), Nokia was still the dominant player and even Samsung only captured 3% of the market. However, in 2014 (second quarter, chart on the right), apart from Samsung, hardly any foreign players were able to sustain significant market share. Aggressive pricing at the expense of margins is always the strategy used by the local players in order to gain market share at the initial stage, especially in the mid to lower tier market segment, which shows strongest growth. However, the qualities of their products are also improving.

I noticed, especially in the lower tier regions, people focus more on both pricing and practicality, e.g. easy access to the stores or post sale services, and not so much on branding image, which was one of the key reasons for purchasing foreign higher end products. Therefore, for foreign brands, such as Samsung and Apple, simply focus on higher end, higher quality and market image building might not be enough to maintain their market position in the mainland, as clearly indicated by the charts above.  With increased commoditization of portable device segment, strategy of targeting practicality, local taste with the focus slightly shift to mid (or mid to lower) end market might be required for foreign brands to compete in the mainland.

The development of smartphone/tablets market, the increased Internet availabilities, a more established online payment system and fast growing online social network provided extra push for the further development of eCommerce. In 2000, China only had 2.1 million total Internet users and all other important ingredient for the eCommerce, such as logistics and online payment system, are lacking. Fast forward to 2014, the chart below shows, in terms of eCommerce transaction value, China has already overtaken the US:
 

The chart was based on 2013 data in which compounded growth of eCommerce transaction was 70% in the mainland (KPMG estimates).

From what I observed, people are increasingly adopting online shopping, either from their PCs or their mobiles, the established payment system and delivery system made it more convenient. Crucially, online shopping solves two most important issues in the mainland. First, it satisfied consumers’ need for comparing items, both in terms of quality (checking reviews provided by other consumers) and pricing. Secondly, it solved the geographical issues caused by the size of the mainland and low penetration of some brands in some lower tier regions.

Even with this fast growth, the eCommerce only captures around 10% of total retail sales market in the second quarter of 2014 (earlier than 2015 which some of analysts have estimated). The below chart shows market share by different online shopping platforms (B2C) as of 2nd quarter this year:

 
As shown on the chart, the B2C market is largely dominated by domestic players. Alibaba’s Tmall represents 56% of the B2C segment. According to 2013 Alibaba’s filing to SEC in preparation of its IPO, both Tmall and Taobao handled $248 billion purchase. This means Alibaba accounts for nearly 84% of volumes in the mainland. Its value of merchandise sold in 2012 has already surpassed Ebay and Amazon combined (KPMG estimates). With its dominant position in a fast growing segment with great potential, its IPO does deserve attention.

To conclude, from what I observed this time in the mainland, combined with figures and data presented above, I was impressed with the progress. Even though one might argue China is still lacking originality and innovation. As a country just opened up its market in the 80s, I think the progress of the last 35 years have been extraordinary. As the technology matures, we already see signs of innovation, which is exemplified by how they tailor to local markets’ preferences, using targeted marketing strategies which leverage characteristics of digital age (e.g. Xiaomi’s online fire sale) to gain market share.  

In addition, another reason why China’s digital revolution can progress so fast is a relatively simultaneous establishment of various ingredients: readily available expertise from foreign brands, established market acceptance of the digital concept pioneered by foreign companies and established infrastructure. Everything is at the right place at the right time.

As China progresses and matures, the real sustainable growth will have to come from significant innovation. The students outshine the teachers for now in their domestic market.  However, will they be able to become the master and eventually the real leaders, not just in domestic market but overseas? We will just have to wait and see.

No comments:

Post a Comment