I have been meaning to write up the 'BrandZ top 100 brand rankings' (which appeared in The Financial Times on 21 May) for a couple of weeks now. I have looked before at brand value related to market capitalisation (see this link for example). Brands are currently hugely favoured by investors so it is worth looking into the top brand list and comparing it to market cap/EV.
So how has it done? In a certainly statistically insignificant study from the top 30 global brands from the Interbrand analysis I identified three groups:
(1) Where brand value exceeded 40% of EV (Coca-Cola, HP, Kellogg's)
(2) Where brand value exceeded 35% of EV but not 40% (Google, McDonald's)
(3) Where brand value exceeded 25% of EV but not 35% (Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, Cisco)
How have they done since the end of September posting...well in a rough and ready piece of analysis:
Group (1) is up around 27.1%
Group (2) is up around 17.9%
Group (3) is up around 16.1%
And the S&P500? 14.8%...
So brands...work? Well clearly this far too simplistic and narrow a study but there is a bit of theory attached to it.
So what about the BrandZ survey? First who were in the top 10?
Some quite interesting trends here including a 20% fall in brand value for Apple (and more modest brand value falls for IBM, McDonald's and Altria (aka Marlboro). By contrast there were big brand value uplifts at Google, Microsoft, Visa and Amazon.
So who stands out if you compare a company's market cap (slight difference with the methodology noted above) with their brand value? Well the top five from the above are:
McDonald's 85.6% (of market cap covered by the BrandZ value)
Altria 81.9%
IBM 56.8%
Visa 48.3%
Coca-Cola 44.7%
These are much higher numbers, on average, than the Interbrand equivalents. Clearly there is a methodological difference in the brand accounting processes but running with the concept that a higher number per se is better than a lower one what should we make of the top five?
Well the better news is that I have a positive view on three of the names currently including both the top two. McDonald's was actually over the wires today with a sales update which Fast FT described as:
'America is still striking a sour note for McDonald's. The fast food chain reported a 1 per cent decline in same-store sales in the US last month, underlining the struggle chief executive Don Thompson is having in the company's biggest market. Analysts had expected that US sales would rise 0.1 per cent'
On the last time I did a specific piece of analysis on the company I noted that:
'McDonald's is an annuity-type business. It is struggling to grow but - as shown in the SG&A fall of 4% in Q3 year-on-year - there are still levers that can be pulled to drive the EPS line. With a 6%+ free cash flow yield, the next step is for the company to boost their share buyback. The business model is not broken, it is just in a lacklustre economy they will inevitably struggle'
This remains the case...the only difference is that back then the share was trading at the bottom of its US$94-102 range...and now it is trading near the top.
What the brand analysis is telling me is that the second level - on generalised weakness - to buy McDonald's shares after US$94 is where the BrandZ brand value covers the entire market cap...which is at about US$87.50.
What about Altria? Back in April I concluded on the US-based tobacco giant that:
'to expect a US$40+ Altria share price still seems a reasonable expectation. Add in that 5% dividend yield and that's a solid combination for investors'
Since then the share has performed strongly and has pierced that US$40 level (and moved to new all-time highs):
I got aggressive with the Altria share in the US$34s a couple of times in the last year...and interestingly this is where the BrandZ value analysis suggests the brand approximately covers the company's market cap...interesting.
As with McDonald's I think there are interim levels to get involved before this (US$36 is x10 EV/ebit, US$38/40 look technically interesting). Don't be afraid to buy any generalised weakness...but that is not going to help you necessarily make a lot of money buying the share today (although my target for Altria is a x12 EV/ebit valuation or c. US$43.5 with a potential 'kicker' if SABMiller - in which they have a large stake - picks up a bid).
In the next part I will look at the other top five names.




Caffeinated bottled water? It's all in the brand. "Go! Water"? h/t AT&T.
ReplyDelete