Pages

Monday, 11 August 2014

Guest post - "Food safety and air pollution in China is an opportunity and not a threat"

This is the third part of a guest author series on China.  You can find links to parts 1 and 2 here. 

 
Part 3 - Food safety and air pollution in China is an opportunity and not a threat by Jing Liang

Afflictions are sometimes blessings in disguise
塞翁失马,焉知非福
                                                                              - Chinese proverb

Food safety and air pollution are the two most popular topics I heard when I was in China between April and June, ranking just after property and the anti-corruption campaign.

However, an English saying – every cloud has a silver lining – comes to mind.  After my visit to Shanxi this time, I observed two developments.  First, the central government is taking serious actions in tackling the food safety and air pollution issues. Second, these policy actions have trickled down to the local government levels as exemplified by visible actions e.g. the availability of higher quality farming products including organic food and tourism in remote mountain areas for the clean air. Both private businesses and local governments have started to explore business opportunities that centre around these two issues, especially in the lower tier regions, which often have more unexploited resources in terms of land and clean air.  

Shanxi (my home province), a lower tier province, is one of the most polluted provinces in China. However, when I was visiting this time, I noticed some positive actions they took to clean up the air pollution. Not only was I impressed with the fresh air and blue sky in Lingshi County (see below), I also noticed in Taiyuan, the capital city, that it has made considerable effort to reduce cars relate pollutions by pushing a bike-sharing program (equivalent to Boris bike in London). The chart below shows the size of the bike-sharing program worldwide:
 
 

Out of 21 cities ranked by the chart, 16 from China. Apart from Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen are Tier 1 cities, the others are either tier 2 or tier 3 cities or lower. I was very impressed that Taiyuan made it to top 5.

The locals also started to explore tourism to leverage their existing clean environment in remote mountainous area (Shanxi literally means Mountain West in Chinese).

I took a picture (below) when I was visiting the Red Canyon in Lingshi County, a lower tier town outside Taiyuan, in May and the picture second below is an image I found on google by typing “Beijing smog Tianenmen”, which is becoming a dominant image whenever China and pollution are mentioned:
 
 
 
The Red Canyon was developed by a private company. The key selling point is the clean air away from larger cities and it shows to me that the lower tier regions are using their natural resource to tap into the booming tourism industry. Saying this, whilst I was there, I found the infrastructure, e.g. hotels and restaurants, were still very under-developed. It indicates there is room for a lot of further growth.

In addition to tourism, lower tier regions are also leveraging their land to explore organic and high quality farming products, given consumers have increased food safety concerns. According to Credit Suisse estimates, because of increased urbanization and the increased level of disposable income, the estimated retail value of agriculture products will reach 405 trillion RMB in 2015 (from 15.4 trillion in 2010). China agriculture contributed 10.2% to its total GDP as of 2012 so such an increase can make a useful contribution. The chart below shows a rough picture the regional differences on agriculture produce:
 
 
I visited an organic farm located in a village at the bottom of the Wu Tai mountain, in Wu Tai County (another lower tier county town). The farm produces high quality livestock. I also visited Jingle County, which specializes in producing high quality millet and other coarse food grain (e.g. maize, sorghum) because of its suitable climate. The main way of generating revenue for these farms and others in smaller counties is to sell directly to restaurants and supermarket chains. However, the common issue they share is lack of scale.  One of the key barriers to overcome is that they lack a controllable production and transportation chain. It is the opposite issue faced by some restaurant/fast food chain, which are desperately seeking reliable suppliers within a more integrated supply chain.

In late July, Yum! Brands and McDonald’s announced its decision to cut an existing supplier, who supplied low quality expired meat. Yum!, who generated 37% of their operating profit as per their last quarterly results disclosure from China, is facing head winds because of this negative news. This follows similar scandals a year or so ago. 

However, with all these scandals, I did not see people boycotting Pizza Hut or KFC. When I asked people if they were worried, the general response was that they were. However, people prefer to pay more to go to bigger restaurants or branded chains, such as Pizza Hut or KFC. The consumers seem to believe if there is any issue, these companies will make compensation. The businesses that do suffer, I noticed, are the street food stalls or smaller scale businesses.

Therefore, I think the issues faced by Yum! Brands and similar companies are not permanent. There are quality suppliers out there in the mainland and they just have to find a way to reach them. Building up an integrated supply chain is only matter of time and is definitely not impossible. Hence, the scandalous headlines should not signify longer-term issues for these companies, and short-term fluctuation in their share prices may well be creating a buying opportunity for longer-term investors.

To conclude from my observations during my visit in the spring, I think the existence of food safety and air pollution issues have given an extra push for the effort the government needed to move to a more sustainable growth route, e.g. the development of more integrated supply chain that the food industry desperately needs, as well as the investment into clean energy (e.g. gas) infrastructure, especially in some lower tier regions, which are becoming the driving force of the whole economy.

The encouraging news is that the evidence of action is everywhere.  

No comments:

Post a Comment