Pages

Tuesday, 19 May 2015

Walmart - still sadly indicative of malaise

Has it really been six months since I last wrote on Walmart?  Apparently (link here) it is.  Back at the link above I gave the view that at/around the US$70 level I could see some value in Walmart shares.  Well since then we have not even got close...despite the retailer's shares having fallen over US$10/share since the early January high:


So what to make of today's Q1 numbers?  Well whilst constant currency revenues rose (headline sales hurt by currency translations), operating income and EPS did not.  


Looking at US sales by divisional line grocery was flattish but all other categories moved ahead.  As shown below comparable traffic was positive (and even strong in the more convenience centred 'Neighborhood Market' stores)...but via lower margins operating income was down mid single digit.  

And the less retail centred Sam's Club faired even worse even at the basic category sales level:


A ray of hope at the international divisions (even if they generate less than a quarter of US profits)?  Well sales were good except in the ultra-competitive UK (where at least gross profit rose - in fact the gross profit rate rose in four out of the five International operations).
But even ignoring the translation into the (strong) US dollar operating profit was up just a pathetic 0.1%.  Not inspiring at all.  


So here's the trouble: at a still US$290bn+ EV you are trading on a static x12 EV/ebit with a 3-4% free cash flow yield.  That just does not get me excited.  I don't mind buying a recovery story at that multiple but I fail to see it in the absence of much stronger general growth levels.  

For me I am still waiting for around US$70/share.  

So if Walmart cannot get any momentum what is that saying about the average American and spending capability?  As the company noted on the conference call:

Based on recent surveys, we know that many of our U.S. customers are using their tax refunds and the extra money from lower gas prices to pay down debt or put it into savings.

Hmm.  

No comments:

Post a Comment