Pages

Thursday, 13 November 2014

Wal-Mart: good numbers have international implications

Food retail has been an atrocious performing sector during 2014 caught between structural change towards online and convenience, price competition from discounters and a general lack of food price inflation.  I have documented the trials and tribulations of a number of UK names (link here for example) as well as Wal-Mart in the US.  However in the last few weeks there has been a slight performance improvement across the board as shown in the chart for Tesco and Wal-Mart below.


Note the big bump in Wal-Mart's shares today - quite surprising given the downbeat nature of the capital markets day a few weeks ago (which I wrote up and published my top ten charts from here) which included a negative guidance update:


Well the guidance per se did not particularly get better...

'The company now sees FY14 EPS of $4.92-$5.02 vs. $4.98 consensus'.

...but the tone of comments did.  Take the hugely critical and influential US sales note how the Q3 numbers were clearly better than the YTD ones assisted by a couple of the positive themes mentioned at the capital markets day: e-commerce and convenience.  


Even internationally there is a mixed but improving picture.  Whilst only two geographies had rising net sales, three had an improving gross profit rate including the UK division Asda (a statistic which the US business still has not quite achieved).

I noted previously that a single digit EV/ebit ratio for Wal-Mart would be consistent with a US$70 share price but the share blazing through the US$80 level indicates much more optimism/valuation inflation.  On an international basis good news for the pressurised UK listed supermarket sector.  That's where the relative value lays.  I remain long Tesco and Morrison's.  

1 comment:

  1. Yes, a fair point! Still for the masses struggling with a lack of real wage growth I feel the food retailers are getting their heads around what to do and how to service them. Very low sentiment to the space (especially here in the UK) but it is a necessity area when push comes to shove...and hence there is a value. Anyhow am talking my own book on a couple of the UK names (was too conservative it appears re adding Wal-Mart). Make sure you bring at least two credit cards when you visit Whole Foods next time!

    ReplyDelete