Pages

Wednesday, 20 May 2015

Catching up with Staples

Six months or so ago I wrote a posting about Staples which noted I had taken a profit on my holding but also acknowledged a frustration that I had missed out on a subsequent bump in the shares.  Since then the shares have...gone nowhere first:


The real reason for the bump was the Office Depot hook-up which offers material synergy potential.  This is the effective elephant in the room with the Q1 numbers reported earlier today.  Statically though we can do a simple sum-of-the-parts calculation. 

The numbers in the company's core US retail stores/associated online operations continues to deteriorate (physical retail down, online up of course). US$300m of extrapolated full year profitability albeit in a declining (net) business.  An x8 operating income multiple implies a value of US$2.4bn.  


The commercial business has been more solid over recent years and deserves a higher multiple (x10) for its operating profitability.  This works out as a value of around US$5.5bn.
And net losses at the international business continues.  I am going to give it a x0.25 sales multiple or around US$800m.
Add the three parts together (US$8.7bn), deduct the company's net debt of around US$800m gives a 'fair value' EV of around US$8bn.  And the Staples EV today? US$11.2bn.  That's a lot of potential Office Depot led synergies. The conference call still talked about a US$1bn worth of synergies over three years due to stores closures and related. With Office Depot currently a US$5.7bn EV business, these synergies need to be worth c. US$10bn (x10 static full synergies) to offset the cost of the deal and the implied uplift to the Staples valuation required to justify today's market cap.  Likely/realistic?  I don't think so.  

I would have a look lower down (US$15?) but today it is not compelling enough for me.  

No comments:

Post a Comment