'Oversupply but better prices is typically an unusual combination in business. Clearly Chinese stimulus and the production cost curve could have influences but remaining both long and short in iron ore seems to make sense.
Would I buy a few more Vale sub US$13? Yes. Would I want a hedge position like Rio Tinto as well? Yes...'
In the intervening two months or so Vale and Rio Tinto have not performed particularly differently...but a combination of the former outperforming and the latter effectively making no progress mean a positive P&L pay-off especially with the added bonus of a some positive specific timing...
So that is good...but where do we go from here?
A couple of interesting insights from Australia today. First I am still trying to work out why BHP Billiton's head of iron ore production would come out with a statement like:
'BHP Billiton has vowed to supply iron ore as cheaply as arch rival Rio Tinto and will considering reactivating its $20 billion outer-harbour project at Port Hedland as it pushes ahead with an aggressive production plan'
That is potentially dangerous talk given the YTD greater decoupling between iron ore equities and the iron ore price...
And then there is the other supply side factor. As Bloomberg cited earlier today, Goldman Sachs are concerned about net Chinese supply (with my emphasis added):
'Cuts to China’s iron ore production will be less than forecasts, with increased output at some lower cost inland mines offsetting closures at smaller coastal mines, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS)...Output may decline 10 percent over the two years to 2015, trimming production by 40 million tons, Goldman Sachs Australia Pty’s Global Investment Research Executive Director Christian Lelong said in an interview in Sydney on July 4'
I feel comfortable with the unbalanced long/short positioning still. And the point to maybe neutralise it? Well for Vale I noted back in May the attractiveness of the sub US$13 level.
Judging by the chart above that seems about right.



No comments:
Post a Comment