Pages

Thursday, 1 May 2014

Vale - relative value and relative iron ore risk

The Brazilian commodities / iron ore company Vale  is always an interesting company to look at.  As my previous Vale report (link here) noted:

'Clearly Vale is more wedded to the China/global growth and iron story than Brazilian growth rates per se.  At x6 FY13A EV/ebit it is classically priced for a commodity stock with large exposure linked to (largely) economically exogenous factors.  Certainly they can help themselves through cost control and the like but this is the broad reality. 

US$13 is clearly a sentiment low point using the Vale ADR quote.  That is worth noting down'. 

And where are we now?  Yes, back at that US$13 (ish) level:


Back in the previous US$13 flirtation in February/March I did pick up some shares consistent with my earlier research call...but I retain a bigger short in Rio Tinto which has materially outperformed over the last year, helped by its shareholder friendly capex cuts.


So why remain short (or even long/short) in iron ore?  Well aside from sequential production downdrafts (see below but also note the year-on-year increase in iron ore production by the company of nearly 10%)...

 
...the Macrobusiness blog notes (link here) a very interesting contrast in the Vale communication following yesterday's numbers:

'Vale also warned of an oversupply in the iron ore market, as more production goes online, particularly in Australia. “For the first time in these last 10 years, we’re experiencing a different situation, in which supply has surpassed demand,” Vale’s head of ferrous metals and strategy, Jose Carlos Martins. “At the same time, demand has risen slower than expected...We expect that the price in the second half would be better than the first half,” he said. “Nothing is for sure but the price will not fall below $US110 on a sustainable basis.”'

Oversupply but better prices is typically an unusual combination in business.  Clearly Chinese stimulus and the production cost curve could have influences but remaining both long and short in iron ore seems to make sense. 

Would I buy a few more Vale sub US$13?  Yes.  Would I want a hedge position like Rio Tinto as well?  Yes...especially as look where iron ore prices are currently: just sub US$110!


No comments:

Post a Comment