'Brazil's economy expanded 2.3 per cent in 2013 including 0.7 per cent in the last three months of the year, allaying fears that the country had slid into recession during the second half but highlighting a slowdown in industrial output'
My main conclusion from the earlier piece was to have a look at some of the bigger Brazilian companies as they report. First up then is the mining behemoth Vale.
I noted yesterday that a large tax bill imposed by the Brazilian authorities made all the headlines but if you look at underlying earnings, the only reasonable conclusion to come to would be that whilst 2013 was better than 2012...it was the second worse year for the company in the last four.
And the issue for this is, to put it simply, China and iron ore. This excerpt from the numbers fascinated me. Asia is over 50% of the destination revenues of the company with China almost four-fifths of that. 72% of the company's revenues are iron ore based...
...and basically 95%+ of the profitability
So iron ore prices matter. As shown below, spot iron ore price have struggled in the last month or so as fears of a rising China-held surplus have built (I wrote recently about the potential use of iron ore as a form of collateral due to inefficiencies in the banking system here)
Vale though are very clear in their views. On the conference call they stated:
'the price cannot go below $110 on a sustainable basis is because of the high-cost of local producers'
For what it is worth, Vale currently pays a sub 0.5% dividend yield.
Clearly Vale is more wedded to the China/global growth and iron story than Brazilian growth rates per se. At x6 FY13A EV/ebit it is classically priced for a commodity stock with large exposure linked to (largely) economically exogenous factors. Certainly they can help themselves through cost control and the like but this is the broad reality.
US$13 is clearly a sentiment low point using the Vale ADR quote. That is worth noting down.
What I also note though is the relative underperformance due to the Brazilian listing, emerging market malaise and Vale's own internal issues relative to peers (less cost cutting etc). Take Rio Tinto as an example. Look at the switch chart...
When malaise in Brazil, China, the iron ore market or ALL three hits the headlines, remember this chart. My instinct is that the Vale ADR will be closer to US$13 at that point. In the meantime I am going to stay short of Rio Tinto (with long mining exposure elsewhere such as some of the gold plays).








That is a classic L/S spread trade, but I can see why your fundamental analysis steers you clear of it.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment. I have got one side of it on...just waiting for the EM volatility to give me the chance to buy Vale! Get the timing right...nicely remunerative. Got to keep watching/thinking!
ReplyDelete