Back then I wrote up a sum-of-the-parts analysis on the company. Their controversial asset remains their French telecoms division SFR which I valued as follows:
'SFR is harder blighted by all the usual European telecoms sector issues of price compression, competition and the costs of rolling out triple/quad play offerings. For companies like Austria Telekom and KPN I have used as a base valuation x4 ebitda and this increased this on the basis of speculative/operational criteria. For SFR the most important is the mobile network sharing deal with Bouygues as shown below plus future management liberation. On this basis I raise my core valuation to x6 ebitda or c. Euro16.6bn.'
The further developments today are nicely summarised in this story: competing bids for SFR from the aforementioned Bouygues and Altice who are the parent company of the cable concern Numericable. The essential difference between the two bids seems to be that Bouygues probably offers greater synergy scope...but that it would receive greater anti-trust concerns as it reduces the number of main market players from four to three.
What strikes me though is the valuation of around Euro15bn i.e. broadly akin to my own sum-of-the-parts.
Should Vivendi accept one of these offers rather than looking to continue with its own spin-off plans? Well shareholders would probably prefer the absolute clarity...the trouble is that the most beguiling is likely to be the Bouygues one...which has the biggest anti-trust consideration. As the Orange dividend cut and the Deutsche Telekom cash flow cut today show it is better for Vivendi to exit.
It will be interesting to see the market reaction today. I am still looking to augment the Vivendi position in the Euro19s (Euro20s as per close of business on Wednesday) after taking some good profits via a significant top-slice recently.
And then after the telecoms assets are moved on...the media/content businesses look ripe for a splitting up/takeover themselves. The world of Vivendi is never a dull one.


No comments:
Post a Comment