Pages

Thursday, 6 March 2014

Standard Chartered - out of favour but should not be out of mind

Standard Chartered shares have had a rough last year as shown below...
 


...a reality acknowledged by the management team of the London-listed but Asia/emerging markets focused bank in their presentation document:

So, how bad were the numbers?  The headline income side was dull rather than disastrous but the real pain can be seen on the loan impairment side which rose just over US$400m


Geographic split is always interesting and insightful for a company like Standard Chartered.  The influence of Korea (strikes, difficult trading) and the (wonderful named) 'other APR' (Asia-Pacific region) is clear.  Ex these it would have been a single digit growth year. 
 
Of course there is another aspect to the debate over Standard Chartered shares recently and that is the balance sheet.  The company has not managed to definitively quell comments that the balance sheet is a concern (and hence by extension that a rights issue was required).  They did not present a 'headroom' chart (below) which seemed reasonable at first glance.  As always though with a financial institution, unexpected impairments/losses can change the situation quickly. 
 


On that front the outlook statement is suitably muted...
 
...and as the company themselves admitted (as shown in their previous presentation) that the next couple of years were going to be different from their historic recent norms:
 

 
I titled a previous report I wrote on Standard Chartered back in December (link here) 'Standard Chartered - short-term troubles wrapped in a great longer-term theme' and this remains the case.  Back then (with the share around 1300p a share) I noted a chart they used at their investor day to show the medium-term potential of the markets they are active in:

 
This time they included an interesting internationalisation of the RMB (the Chinese currency) graphic which clearly remains a medium-term opportunity for the group:
 


 
It is clear strategic opportunities remain for this company.  Back in December I noted that:

'So is there value then?  A 4.7% yield for starters...that's quite pleasant.  Second - and using the half year 2013 detailed information - the company currently trades at approximately x1.2 book with a 13%+ return on equity.  Even adjusting this latter statistic for the update above, the current share price is good value at anything above a 12% return on equity.  I think that is very do-able and probably actually will be beaten. 

I think Standard Chartered, post today's fall, seems good value on a reasonable time basis and I could easily see a return to £15+ with a 4.5%+ yield to boot' 
 

 
My instinct is to retain the same sentiments - with awareness of some inevitable links to 'China / emerging market issues' remains the correct view...especially as the shares now trade on nearer x1.1 book. 

And here's another interesting observation...the 3 year chart versus (relatively) close peer HSBC.
 
 
 
That discount seems a bit rude...and when the residual part of the global earnings season calms down a little more I will go back and look at the 5%+ yielding HSBC too.  

No comments:

Post a Comment