A supermarket chain and a bank. That's two quite different industries, arguably at different ends of the classical beta spectrum. Still there is something which joins the French-listed (predominately food) retailer Carrefour and the bank Allied Irish Bank beyond the fact that both are reporting today. And that's both have been perceived over the last year as turnaround plays.
That's an easy concept to grasp for AIB. Irish banks have had a troubled last few years for well-documented reasons. AIB's share price has been on a bit of a renaissance though over the last six months or so and has, as shown below, basically tripled.
Of course a Euro0.15 share price tells its own story: the company is working very hard for all players along its capital chain. The summary results are very insightful: a nice rise in operating profit, net interest margins, control of costs...and via a still big total provision, continued Euro1.5bn+ losses (albeit it improved year-on-year by a mere Euro2bn!)
I noted too (as with so many banks) the loan:deposit ratio compressing, this time to the clearly important 100% level. Given all the inevitable loan restrictions imposed in Ireland over recent years that this ratio has only just got down to 100% tells you how big the pre financial crisis boom was...
Still, to give credit to the management team, provision cover at 55% of total impaired loans is better than many. Still nearly 35% of its loan advances book being classified as impaired again tells its own story.
So what is the future? Raise the net interest margin, reduce costs, reduce impairment charges and mildly build the loan:deposit ratio. All sensible stuff.
Banking sector turnaround situations have generally performed well over recent months (see this posting I wrote last month on Credit Agricole for example). My view? If you want a 'sticky' banking sector turnaround play in Europe take a look at RBS (my most recent posting here)...whose own Irish unit is the worst performing part of its business.
As for Carrefour, well shareholders have been nicely rewarded over the last year for faith in their turnaround.
At the crux has been getting France to perform better and the key chart from the presentation document today was this one. The France versus (other) Europe contrast is striking...as is the superior emerging market centred performance.
The above just shows sales. From a margin perspective progress over the year (compared to 2012) was apparent in all regions although trading was generally a little bit more difficult in H2 than H1. Still looking at the valuation a prospective x10 EV/ebit FY14e ratio with a 5%+ free cash flow yield, 2.2% dividend and net debt only just over x1 ebitda is perfectly fine.
I can't help feeling though that the biggest lesson from Carrefour is the scope that Tesco has if it is perceived to have turned the corner with its domestic business...look at the switch chart over the last year:
And people say stockpicking is dead...I think not. Tesco remains out-of-favour and interesting here (recent posting here). Carrefour is perfectly fine, but I feel I can do better.







No comments:
Post a Comment