Pages

Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Tesco - after the investor day: 6 company charts and a shocking general consumer trends one

Back in January, after the Christmas trading update, I wrote on the UK-listed retailer Tesco that:

'Around a month ago - post another trading statement where Tesco reiterated their numbers - I noted that the shares offered capital growth value below a 330p share price.  That remains the case...Early trading saw the shares down around 3% to below 320p.  I have added a few more shares to my holding and will do so again sub 310p and sub 300p'

So what did Tesco say at their investor day yesterday and why - after a fairly dullish trading session on Tuesday for the share - is it down over 3% today (as I write)?


First, there were few new numbers with mid-single digit earnings growth, the dividend rising in line with earnings and low teens return on capital percentage pretty mainstream.  The key was explaining the company's strategy.  I have written before (link here for the interim results write-up last October) about their refresh/service/price perception strategy in their UK stores and unsurprisingly this continues.  What was new - and undoubtedly what has 'spooked' the analyst community is just how big some of the shifts in retail are.

Tesco themselves usefully did a breakdown of their own Christmas sales. Not too many surprises that online related and convenience did well and large stores did not...

...but perhaps the analytical community did not know that Tesco remains a proportional (of its own 10k square foot estate) heavyweight in large stores
 

Here is the debatable point though.  Tesco also remains the convenience, loyalty, home shopping and website leader.  How we all shop is changing - as this useful chart from the presentation shows - and Tesco are in the vanguard of that

 

To me, the Tesco story remains all about the turnaround.  Unsurprisingly this is Extra stores based (i.e. the largest stores).  This is all that matters for the company.

The prize is also very clear - and this is where the company's aforementioned technology lead amongst the large supermarket groups does matter. 

The market remains sceptical as shown by the share price over the last year and an x11 consensus P/E for the year ending February 2014.  I note the yield at just over 5% is attractive clearly and the company's commitment to cash flow generation is clearly pleasing.  £7bn of debt is not burdensome and c. £25bn of property value on the balance sheet does give options (as other supermarket groups are finding out e.g. rumours about private equity interest in Morrisons). 

So it seems to me that the market got a bit spooked by some of the trend charts shown by the company yesterday.  Perhaps they wanted newer answers rather than waiting for the current turnaround to conclude. 

To me, though, if analysts are going to be spooked by anything, it should be the income trend charts shown by Tesco yesterday.  If this is the reality over the next few years then the whole (UK but by design much of the developed world) economy has an issue.  Lower beta 'essentials' companies like Tesco will be amongst the least of a portfolio manager's problems.

 
 
 

As for me, I noted above that I would add to my Tesco position at 310p and 300p and that remains my intention.  Embrace the volatility.

No comments:

Post a Comment