Building on this, here is a fuller write-up after the interim report presentation from management.
I liked the way that Phil Clarke, the CEO, talked about opportunities in his opening remarks:
'Absolute priority is to position Tesco to win in the future'
'The competition is always improving their game...we need to improve our game and this is precisely what we have been doing during the first half'
'Our direction is right...and our strategic progress will quicken...I am encouraged by the progress we are making'
Let's move on from the rhetoric and talk about the realities.
First, the UK business. As noted above, I was impressed by the progress shown. A movement into positive like-for-likes and a small increase in the trading margin indicates good progress.
I think this set of results show that progress in the UK is occurring since the turnaround plan was launched. Customer feedback is improving (which should positively correlate with sales over time)
I like too the price perception improvement - in a lacklustre growth world this does matter, especially when competing with the discounters:
Finally, store refreshments are a classic way to improve sales and it is good to see this working. Note, in particular, the impact especially on 'Extra' stores (the largest). Famously the reformulated Watford store got a lot of press coverage and perhaps shows the way that larger stores can go, with a more diversified offering, including space given over to third party stores. International challenges with large stores will be picked up later too -
The core UK retail business, in still difficult conditions (especially non-food), appears to me to be moving forward. The online business grew by 13% and has a 50% market share. The Blinkbox music/books/broadband offering and Hudl tablet (35,000 sold in 2 trading days) initiatives sound good too...and bound consumers to Tesco more. All of this integrates with the Clubcard loyalty scheme too.
Before looking internationally, let's take a quick look at the financial sector business Tesco Bank. I was a little worried when I saw the headlines that the Bank's profitability had declined on the basis that I knew they were launching a range of new products. This chart helps to clear that up and indicates that the roll-off of the legacy RBS joint venture business had an impact. The underlying business grew by 21%. I am not surprised by this and, given the push into a wider range of core banking products, this should continue -
In my first 'flash' write-up earlier today I highlighted the impact of the international business swoon, which pulled group profitability down:
Europe in particularly looks poor but the company made the point that it was not just worsening conditions in countries such as Ireland and Poland which impacted, but a slide into a recession in Thailand and continued issues with Sunday trading inflexibility in Korea.
This was a good summary slide I thought on Asia. As discussed, Thailand and Korea did overhang the region's performance, but ultimately the combination of solid margins, high return on capital and a strategically interesting region will help. As the CFO said 'rather pleased with the Asia business' and he noted drily that the region's profits were higher than many peers the company competes with in the UK!
And then there is China, which was going nowhere fast under just the Tesco banner. As noted in the chart below, the company confirmed the joint venture with the CRE group. I like the 'ROCE accretive' comment (linked to not having a loss in the country any more versus £100m of losses pa for the last two years) and also noted the CEO's general comments on the business:
'New model'...'they chose us'...'two seats on the board'...'clear route to sustainable profitable growth'
Europe is clearly the disappointing region on the return on capital employed chart shown earlier. I was pleasantly surprised that the region - as shown below - remains free cash flow positive.
The trading results were particularly hit by the poorer Irish business (even though the company does not split out the numbers, Ireland is the highest margin area). The CFO also noted that conditions were improving due to seasonality issues (Europe 60% H2 weighted) as easy comps (Poland into positive like-for-likes etc). Tesco are anticipating an improvement in H2.
I think the company is making the right strategic call in focusing on smaller stores, as shown below in the pie-chart on the right. This equally applies to Asia.
So pulling it all together, I was fairly heartened by what I heard. Any turnaround has challenges and issues but the Tesco UK turnaround, I think, is progressing as well as can be anticipated. Applying a x10 trading profits multiple I would give this business a prospective value of about £24bn. Similarly the bank is actually growing quite well. I make it a £2bn business today.
Asia too deserves a similar multiple - and should exhibit better growth as comparisons become easier. This kicks out a value of around £6.5bn. I think this is consistent with a high >10% ROCE too.
Europe remains difficult...but I like some of the comments around it. On an earnings-only basis the valuation of the division is low. However, using the current mid-single digit return on capital for the division, I am going to value it on x0.5 sales...so approximately a £2.5bn value.
That is £35bn...and the current EV is £34.8bn. So at 345p (as I write) the shares are reasonably value in pure capital terms. The yield at 4.8% is attractive clearly (interim dividend was held and they noted how 'important' is was for shareholders) and the company's commitment to cash flow generation is clearly pleasing. £7bn of debt is not burdensome and c. £25bn of property value on the balance sheet does give options.
So...buy Tesco today for yield, buy it sub the 330p support level for total return. A fuller recovery, assisted by participation in the international operations, would be equivalent to a share price much nearer 400p.














No comments:
Post a Comment