Pages

Friday, 19 September 2014

Oracle and SAP - big rivalry, big newsflow (part 1)

Oracle and SAP is one of the great technology rivalries today.  Both have had interesting newsflow over the last 24 hours. So are either a great investment here or not?

Well first, have a look at the performance spread between the two (I am using the SAP ADR to iron out any FX issues).  Oracle have outperformed by around 20% over the last year or so:


So let's start with Oracle.  The last time I wrote on them (link here) was back in March when I concluded that:

'US$36 used to be a top for the shares but over recent months it has maybe turned into a support point.  That level would also be below x10 prospective EV/ebit.  That would be the first level I would look at the share even though I retain some caution about the dynamism of their operation'

The stock has moved up a little since then but will be opening the Friday US session at around US$40.  Two pieces of interesting news in the announcements yesterday.  

The first is that the numbers - and especially guidance - was not the greatest.  This is from Seeking Alpha:

'Oracle (NYSE:ORCL) guides on its FQ1 CC for FQ2 Y/Y revenue growth of 0%-4%, and EPS of $0.66-$0.70. That's below a consensus for 4.8% growth and EPS of $0.74.Software/cloud revenue is expected to grow 3%-6% Y/Y vs. 6% in FQ1, and hardware revenue is expected to be flat to down 10%. SaaS/PaaS revenue is expected to grow 39%-44%, and IaaS revenue 40%-44%'

None of this is particularly new to me - as I noted in March I 

had been having some fears about the dynamism of their earnings capability...which makes the second announcement of Larry Ellison stepping down as CEO and being replaced by two internal co-CEOs most interesting.  

In a wonderful piece of linkage again with SAP this is something the German company could tell Oracle all about.  Generally I think that co-CEOs is generally a weak / corporate compromise piece of news.  And hence this doesn't fire me up about Oracle at all.  

At US$3bn of quarterly operating profit and US$2.5bn of free operating cashflow (pre-acquisitions) some semblance of value is there (a 6%+ annualised returns to investors) but the lower earnings momentum is pushing up the prospective EV/ebit multiple - that interesting x10 prospective EV/ebit multiple is now probably below a US$36 share price.  

So I am leaving Oracle alone at the moment.  How about SAP - the underperformer of the two over the last year?  That analysis - following their largest ever purchase - is coming in part 2.   


No comments:

Post a Comment