“We cannot trust the
GDP figures and they don’t capture the reality on the ground. How can there be any credibility in economic
policy making if the core, basic statistics needed to tell internal and
external interested parties what is going on get revised and changed? We need to talk about this at the next
IMF/G20 meeting…”
This is not a real quote but it is not entirely implausible
that one of the major emerging market powers could say this about the United
States. Wednesday’s statistical update
will show US GDP having its most significant reclassification for over a
decade. The methodological
technicalities are apparently centred on the need to capture a knowledge
economy more precisely. I am sure this has all been worked out with great
precision and academic correctness, but as investors and interested economic
observers, should it change our behaviour at all?
I am reminded of Keynes’ definition of investor animal
spirits as ‘a spontaneous urge to action rather than inaction, and not as the
outcome of a weighted average of quantitative benefits multiplied by
quantitative probabilities’. Whether GDP
is reclassified as y basis points or z percent points better or worse than
before correctly we should shrug our shoulders.
What we should be worrying about are the realities on the ground today
and how they are impacting the decisions made for tomorrow. Pushing GDP statistics up on a
reclassification will not change anything.
If the Emperor is wearing no clothes, then he is wearing no
clothes. As investors or macroeconomic
observers we have to spot this. You can
rewrite history but any behavioural influences on current or future financial
markets are fairly negligible. In
reality Beijing knows this as much as Washington. There is no point in giving the statisticians
or politicians a hard time when real-time business insights or personal
observations matter so much more.