At the time the Citizens' stock was a little under US$25. Today it trades for just over US$27. So a 'result'? Well...it depends on how you review today's 3%+ fall...
So why the fall? Ultimately it comes down to one key chart from the presentation deck and the observation of 'broadly reaffirm overall FY 2015...(but the) achievement of 10% ROTCE run-rate target by end 2016 is likely pushed out...will provide 2016 guidance in January 2016':
Oh dear. I had noted already the poor trends of net interest margin...
...that certain growth initiatives were coloured 'amber' and hence a bit behind the curve......and that despite a static loan-to-deposit ratio, the company was no longer accumulating capital (although in absolute terms its capital ratios remain absolutely fine).
So what to think? Well as I concluded a couple of months ago that the hope of achieving a 10% ROTCE opened up the potential for a US$27-30 share price. With this being pushed back the share at c. US$27 feels there or there abouts.
Citizens Financial has been a great spin-off since the IPO but it feels time to tactically say goodbye to the share. Somewhere at/around that US$24 share price I might feel differently.





No comments:
Post a Comment