Pages

Friday, 5 December 2014

Smith & Wesson - problem in the firing chamber?

It was August when I last wrote about the iconic gun manufacturer and distributor Smith & Wesson taking the view that the share was back to a cheap level.  Market volatility pushed the share a little lower into the US$9 range and I took this opportunity to add further to my position.


Yesterday's numbers appear to be a disappointment.  This was nothing to do with the reported numbers but all to do with the prospective numbers.  For example, as Seeking Alpha noted: 

'For FY 2015, SWHC lowers EPS guidance to $0.66-$0.70 from prior $0.89-$0.94 vs. $0.89 consensus, and reduces its revenue outlook to $504M-$508M from prior $530M-$540M vs. $531M consensus.

SWHC blames the 22% Y/Y decline in FQ2 revenues on lower consumer demand and competitors' excess inventory at distributor and retailer locations, which followed an earlier surge period when consumers purchased firearms in anticipation of possible restrictive regulations'

Well that is not good...even if the above linked piece noted the company were already talking about this a quarter ago.  

Here to me is a critical paragraph from the conference call when the CEO noted:

'...we are pleased that Smith & Wesson inventory in the distributor channel declined in absolute numbers during the second quarter from 145,000 units at the end of Q1 to 118,000 units at the end of Q2. This is a decrease of more than 18%. While that still represents week of cover that is somewhat above our preferred eight-week threshold, this is excellent progress in a short amount of time, especially as we believe that most competitors inventory in the distributor channel remained higher than ours'

So this is tentatively better even if the company is going to have to participate a little in the upcoming sales period as other gun manufacturers are pushed into more aggressive action by their ultra high inventories (up to 6 months long as per the company!)

Fundamentally however the company is still ticking all appropriate boxes for me.  They announced an acquisition in the last few weeks ('...we signed a purchase agreement to acquire Battenfeld Technologies for $130.5 million. This is an all cash purchase, funded by using our existing cash balances and drawing $100 million on our line of credit...') and I was pleased to see that this will be accretive in the first full year of ownership.  

Otherwise their M&P pistols side continues to innovate and generally sell well and 'the recent adjusted mix results of Black Friday provided further encouragement. It was a record result with consumers driving more than 175,000 background checks in that single day'. Ultimately underlying demand is reasonable.  

So valuation.  Pre the Battenfeld deal - and keeping the inventory adjusted influenced trough 10% operating margins - the company is trading on around x10 EV/ebit with inherently good cash flow.  Even post the Battenfeld deal I would expect the company to move back to a net cash position ceteris paribus in a couple of years or so.  

And the early doors share price reaction to the above?  Little changed. When numbers are cut and a share does not go sharply down then inherently it is cheap/good value.  This is Smith & Wesson today.  Strong further appreciation potential in 2015.  

No comments:

Post a Comment