Pages

Friday, 19 December 2014

Did I get my 2014 macro calls right or wrong? The scorecard...

As 2014 enters its last couple of weeks it is the right time to review some calls I made around a year ago before I unveil my own lists of '15 for 2015' macro and stock calls.

On this link here is a posting issued on 27 December 2013 titled '14 for '14 (part 1): 14 macro trends for 2014'. Given here on Financial Orbit all you get is straight up honesty about how investment calls have worked out (mainly because it reflects what I am seeing/feeling in my own positions) how did these predictions pan out?  Here's the scorecard...

Macro trend 1: contrarians will rock

Hmm...so commodities, energy, emerging markets and bonds were the underowned assets as per the chart I put up on the original posting.  I think this one was a MISS.  The momentum players have enjoyed 2014 far more than I thought.

Macro trend 2:  High sentiment doesn't stay high...and the return of volatility

Up until a few months ago this was not looking the greatest call...but recent events have made it look prescient because it reflected a need for a flexible/sceptical nature which has really kicked in during H214.  Given an updated form of that 5 year VIX chart I posted originally does now look a bit different I am going to rate this call a HIT.


Macro trend 3: equities - time for active stockpicking again

Derived from some of the above, my own active stock selection strategies have worked out well...but I know this is not a market norm.  So I am torn...given I also talked about the DJIA not posting a 5% gain (again) and so far this is 2-3% below the reality I think I am going to have to call this one a MISS.

Macro trend 4: global QE is still alive...it is just you need to be paying attention to Japan and Europe, not obsessing about what Janet Yellen is going to be up to

Yes, yes, yes.  This one nailed the 2014 reality.  Rampant QE application in Japan and (continuing) debate in Europe.  Most certainly a HIT.

Macro trend 5: don't expect real consumer incomes in 'the West' to roar away...and hence don't expect GDP to be sustainably significantly above trend

Outside of the US and maybe the UK economic growth in 'the West' has been disappointing and real consumer income growth (or more precisely median income growth) has been downright poor everywhere.  I am rating this one a HIT after weighing up the evidence.

Macro trend 6: emerging markets have value, but no-one cares, which is why you should
Wow...this is a tough one given India and China have been rampant on a FY14 basis whilst Brazil and Russia...have not.  I also have benefited from stocks that had/have undervalued emerging market exposure in them.  Hmmm...I am going to rate this one NEUTRAL.  

Macro trend 7: companies spend more on capex...but investors will retain the right to change their mind whether it is good or not

I am going to rate this one a HIT as my broad thesis that any capex uplifts would not be loved up by investors was correct whilst buybacks and dividends have driven share prices more.

Macro trend 8: China continues to accumulate gold...and this (and low sentiment) pushes the gold price up

China has certainly continued to accumulate gold...but the headline gold price in US dollars is a little down in 2014...but in euros, yen, roubles, pounds it is up.  So on balance I am going to rate this a HIT.


Macro trend 9: property is not going be so strong in 2014

I believe this one is a HIT as the trend is fading across most geographies even if there have not been perhaps as many absolute price falls as I would have thought.

Macro trend 10: Berlin are going to have to accept a lower Euro...which means generally a stronger US Dollar

No debate on this one...as with the QE prediction above this one worked out very well.  HIT.  

Macro trend 11: your best source of returns in bonds during 2014 will be from yields

There has not been a MISS for a few themes but this one did not work out so well.  Yield compression has been material in most bond markets around the world.

Macro trend 12: the continued growth of the online world

One word suffices to explain why this prediction was a HIT: Alibaba.




Macro trend 13: agriculture grades are due a run

They are currently running...but to be fully fair I was too early with this call.  The better news is that I doubled up into the volatility around the middle part of the year and that's working out quite nicely now.  So as a prediction unfortunately a MISS.


Macro trend 14: stay flexible...

As I noted on macro trend 2 above this has gained currency as a theme as the year has progressed and certainly as a mindset has helped me make money in 2014.  So I am going to rate it a HIT.


So...the scorecard:

9 HITS, 4 MISSES and 1 NEUTRAL.  Ok I know this included a couple of close calls but I am kind of happy with this batting average.  On the misses I made money as a stock picker and the way my personal funds are set up I tend to be more of an equity than a bond investor in any case.  Agricultural exposures are also kicking in nicely for me during the last few months.

The review of the 2014 calls will continue before Christmas...as will the introduction of some macro themes to be thinking about for 2015...

1 comment: