Back in August, around the US$11 share price, I concluded that:
'It is going to be a big 'back to school' trading period for Staples whichever way you look at it. Sub US$11 I think you buy more, US$13s lose some. Pick up the dividend in the interim and keep your fingers crossed'
Well they came through and even slipped in an increase in the free cash flow to be generated in 2014 from US$600m to US$800m: not bad at all for a company with a current EV of US$9.5bn. But more of that later.
I liked the sound of the 'building momentum as we reinvent Staples' line in the Chairman/CEO's introductory statement to the results...
Previously I have valued Staples on a sum-of-the-parts basis and I think that is reasonable this time again. So...still the same mix at the US stores of a rising Staples.com (no surprises there) and a falling store network (closures here are now 170 stores rather than the previously guided 140). Now Q3 with its 'back to school' component is a big quarter (Q2 by contrast only generated an operating profit of US$28m). Annualising this six month period (slightly optimistic maybe) and putting this division on a depressed x6 ebit multiple this gives a value of just under US$3bn or around 25% of sales. That's up from August. Further value should be realised as the turnaround continues (and comparable store sales hopefully level off).
The commercial business is better balanced - as shown by the absolutely flat operating income line. Nevertheless there is progress here: a match is indicative of an underlying ok business (and at the micro level the company reported 'drove double digit growth in furniture, print and promotional products as well as technology products' . On an annualised rate with a x10 ebit multiple this gives a slightly improved value of US$6.4bn.

And then we come to international...which I still think they should spin-off. At least it made a tiny profit is all you can say. On the basis that it is now in the black (mostly via higher margins due to Europe and apparently aggressive cost control in Australia) I put it on a multiple of x0.1 sales or a value of c. US$400m (unchanged from before).
So if you add these three areas up you get US$9.8bn or basically just above the current EV.
On the conference call the company noted all the above and also indicated that Q4 would be tough to predict (no numbers for 2015 either) but that they believed in the turnaround. One of the more interesting statistics concerned the 20-30% sales uplift at a store when they closed a nearby Staples and the c. 15% uplift when Office Max (the key peer and also net store reducer) did the same.
There is clearly new runway to aim at here and that high single digit percent free cash flow yield is pretty attractive but the 'easier' money has gone. I therefore did a strong top-slice of my position north of US$14. One up for value investing nevertheless.





No comments:
Post a Comment