Pages

Thursday, 16 October 2014

Philip Morris International - FX hurts but story still on track

In my write-up of their Q2 numbers three months ago I described Philip Morris International as 'reassuring reading' (link here) and mused that the share 'feels like a core position to me which I would augment further near...US$80.  I am still targeting a share price return to US$90+'.  

So how did they get on in Q3?

Well the headline will undoubtedly be this:


Sounds bad news despite the underlying mid single digit growth?  Well...not really because if you look at the first two lines of the Q3 statement you immediately see the big issue:


Ah...the resurgent US dollar.  No surprises that for a company that earns all its profits outside its market of listing, a strong US dollar creates some translation issues...and by a clear amount:


That's a big hit for a company earning around US$5 per share although, as noted by the 2013 equivalent statistic, not unprecedented.  

Scraping away the FX issues however is there a fundamental problem?  The answer is no.  Take a look at this instructive table:

The operations line is still moving forward overall.  Yes negative FX impacts take the headlines but this was not totally unexpected - after all everyone can follow the currency markets.

So whilst the operations number overall is good what about the EU and Asia specifically?

Well Europe was all about investment in brands and a tricky underlying backdrop.  Despite this pricing - always a positive trait in the tobacco industry - was solid.  As for Asia the issues discussed previously about Australia (link here) overhung the results as well as illicit trading in The Philippines.  Both are fairly well known in my estimation.

Another interesting indication is the continuing buyback momentum.  The three year buyback program is only two-thirds through as noted below.  And the average buyback price recently has been around US$84.  An interesting indication for the share...
So trading on high x12s EV/ebit FY14e with a near 4.8% yield (nicely covered by a 6.3% free cash flow yield) I still see value.  Any FX relief pushes the valuation down to the low x11s and - on an underlying basis - the company continues to grow on a mid single digit basis.  I still see a fairer value at least at US$90. 


From a position of a current owner I want to buy more at US$80 to trade to US$90.  For non-holders today is a good day to buy in my view.  

No comments:

Post a Comment