Pages

Monday, 18 August 2014

Trying to price the China fear in Daimler

Earlier in the Asia today posting (link here) I noted that:

'I am continually argued that the key to understanding China is the extent of the ongoing microeconomic reforms.  No surprises then that early Monday reports noted that: 

'Daimler AG's luxury brand division Mercedes-Benz has been found guilty of manipulating prices of after-sales services, China's official Xinhua news agency reported on Sunday, citing authorities in Jiangsu province'.

My instinct would be that such actions represent more of an opportunity to buy depressed western names than a threat per se (akin to the baby food companies in the last year)'

So what price to buy Daimler then?  First, let's recall what happened with the baby food companies.  

It is just over a year since most of the world's leading baby food brands were hit by fines imposed by the Chinese authorities.  As detailed here what is most striking is the low absolute total of the fines imposed with Mead Johnson being worst hit with a US$33m fine.  This for a company currently with over US$2bn of annualised sales in Asia where it describes China as its 'largest market'.  

If you look at the chart of Mead Johnson against the local S&P500 index (to help counter any beta influence) what is clear is that the biggest sentiment fear period came in the month before the fine (July 2013) and the outperformance of the stock relative to the S&P index (admittedly interrupted by the Crimea incident in January/February) started from that point.  


So what about Daimler?  Well the stock has underperformed recently as shown by its performance spread against the DAX coming in:


Now, Daimler do not formally split out geographic profitability but from a sales perspective China is c. 16% of the cars division…


 …and a proportion (50%?) of the 34% of truck sales to Asia. 


Around 10-15% of total group profitability feels about right.  On a simple equivalent profit decline analysis it is interesting that the company's underperformance against the DAX is around 10%.  Clearly with overt operational gearing at automotive companies this is a horribly simplistic view but it does indicate something.  

Switching to the actual Daimler share price the current Euro60 level appears immediately as an important resistance/support level:


You can certainly make a value case for Daimler ('A rise to Euro10bn (15% underlying ebit increase year-on-year) would put the shares on a FY14e EV/ebit ratio of around x7 which is neither very cheap nor expensive')...

...and a current 3.7% yield is certainly a material premium over the German bund.  I think though sub the Euro60 level there is the added opportunity of 'China fear' too.  

No comments:

Post a Comment