Well...it depends on what is already priced in.
Take Caterpillar for example, the headline looked good...

...but as I write the shares are down 2.5% on the day. So why is this?
Well, simply put, the shares have had a strong last year...
...and look at the detailed comments from the company (apologies this is quite long). What strikes me is that the sales line was actually revised down slightly (with those emerging markets including China particularly poor performers) whilst lower-than-expected restructuring costs were the major boost versus previous hopes on the earnings side:
Looking at the operating line the above is reflected by high price realisations but lower volumes. Big picture though year-on-year operating profits are down.
And that's why the stock is down today - the above is not fully consistent with that ultra-firm share price of the last year.
Another share that has performed well over the last year is Dr Pepper Snapple the carbonated drink and related company
What I thought was really striking about their results was the sheer operational leverage. Both Coca-Cola and PepsiCo had less than sparkling volume increases and Dr Pepper - as shown below - shared that outlook. What was different for the latter was the huge operational leverage as shown by the 13% increase in segment operating profit:
I liked the fairly long list of reasons why profit rose so much.
And the impact for Dr Pepper was that hopes for the year were revised up...
...and the shares are back above the US$60 level which interestingly was my target price back in April (link here). One I now have got to think about - although share price firmness on a long is hardly a big problem. My big question will be 'is everything broadly priced in now?'
The final upgrade I am looking at here came from Potash Corp who also have performed well over the last year following the material share price shift down in July last year as some potash 'cartel' members disagreed between themselves. I traded the company positively back then but, in hindsight, should have got re-engaged with it in late January as that offered a good buying opportunity.
Today they upped guidance importantly - given some of the fears noted nearly a year ago - due to both volumes and prices. Interesting too to note the buyback levels they have employed (average price of US$34)
So where is doing better? As per the chart below it is in China and North America.
Thoughts? Clearly sequentially better but as shown by the signalling from the buyback level quite a lot is priced in here.
Interestingly the stock was called up 3% pre-market and, as I write, is now up 'just' 1%.









No comments:
Post a Comment