Pages

Tuesday, 15 July 2014

JPM, Goldman Sachs and relative value in financials

So I talked about Citigroup yesterday (link here) concluding that:

'This still sounds consistent to me with a return to the c. US$54 level I mooted in this report back in April...Still a share to hold even after the positive quarterly returns reaction today...and all the bad headlines'

JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs numbers have crossed in the last hour or so with many similar comments to the Citigroup numbers that fixed interest trading downturns were not as bad as anticipated.  How do they look on a comparable basis?

JPM numbers read well and even though, as shown below, they failed to hit the highs of Q213 the general progression against the Q1 metrics were good and combining the 14% return on tangible equity...



...with the $43+ tangible book value (which I note rose 8% over the last year) gives a target price of just over $60.

Not terrible given the $56+ prevailing share price.  That $60+ resistance point remains a clear target for the shares.  

How about Goldman Sachs?  Well a similar analysis from below (inflating the common RoE to become the tangible RoE) gives a value of just over $180...



...funnily enough this equates broadly with the YTD high:


So trying to compare/contrast these numbers, Citigroup has 10%+ return potential to a fairer value and Goldman Sachs/JPM retain mid/high single digit return scope.  At the margin I prefer Citigroup given the extra catalysts on the stress test and related.

A bigger call though remains.  Financials - as shown by the relative chart between the S&P and Goldman Sachs (black line) - have strongly underperformed over the last year (and especially the past few months).  


 Now we all know that financials (aka 'the banks' in this context) have 'special' qualities that can lead to extraordinary volatility both inherent within the sector as well as government-led fines and related.  Today however I am wondering if the sector - even in a bout of volatility - is building some relative value.  It still feels stock specific to me but there is enough margin of safety to justify a Citigroup holding at the moment.

As for JPM and Goldman Sachs - as discussed a few weeks ago - a European listed proxy of both (Barclays) should take heart from the above.  In the relative game of financials this looks particularly relatively attractive (last write up here including an 'investment bank for free' discussion).


No comments:

Post a Comment