Pages

Thursday, 10 July 2014

Family Dollar: consumer insights, activism and results

I have been writing about the US discount stores recently with this post on Dollar General my last set of observations. It is a fascinating area given its insights into its consumers who are often below average income consumers.  This is real economy stuff.

So what are the latest observations from their great peer Family Dollar who I noted at the link above may be pushed together by the activist investor Carl Icahn?

Well Family Dollar numbers were pretty much as expected with a -1.8% comparable same store sales fall and a 20% fall in quarterly earnings year-on-year profits...unsurprising given it remains a 'difficult operating environment'.  Not much has changed really since I last wrote the company up here:


Whilst the outlook remains fairly muted with low growth in sales and a continuing decline in gross margins...

...inducing a 'return to value' (good old fashioned cost cutting)...


...workforce reductions/store closures (good old fashioned cost cutting #2).


Will it work?  Well clearly Mr Ichan  has lost patience despite - as I noted here -  'returning over US$500m to shareholders via dividends and buyback which is equivalent to around 7.5% of market cap today.  The company retains good balance sheet flexibility with net debt:ebitda only x0.8'


At the above Family Dollar research link previously talked about a US$55 buying level (near x10 EV/ebit) and I stick with that given still mixed key metrics.  Clearly speculation abounds but as I noted with Dollar General a few days ago that their US$55 buy level was much closer (US$57s vs US$64s for Family Dollar) and that is where the value lays in the US dollar store space between these two.  

Now let's see if the activists get active or not with my instinct that it does not kick off quite as quickly as some hope and that the US$55 buy level for both companies is a possibility given the still difficult consumer backdrop for them.  

Interesting times and interesting economic insights too.  

No comments:

Post a Comment