...then it was the turn of TSB in London to re-list...
...and then Euronext in Paris (to also re-list)
So what should investors think?
Let's start with Markit. My first disclosure is that I am a huge user of the Markit Economics site (link here) as regular readers of this website will know. So do I like the product? Absolutely...very rapidly it seems to me Markit have developed themselves into a formidable supplier of relevant and regular financial information in conjunction with other entities (think HSBC, JPM etc on the various ISM/PMI reports). That sounds like a good almost natural monopoly to me...so long as they keep the contracts (95% of the revenues are 'recurring' subject to retaining contracts of course). And they do a lot more than that...
And how about the numbers? Well the below from the IPO filing document. Clearly the business is growing at a revenue clip of around 10% pa. Costs are growing too and this crimped Q114 profitability a little. Could we get to a c. US$250m operating profits business throwing off US$175m+ cash per annum? I think so. Using some akin peers like McGraw Hill Financial you could apply a x12 ebit multiple to this and get a market cap of around US$3bn implied.
Markit though is a slightly different business to McGraw Hill and shares some similarity to private businesses like Bloomberg which inevitably will give it a premium valuation...currently a little under US$5bn. Around x20 a reasonable near-term ebit is a big price...but now it is all down to delivery and those recurring contracts and more. I will remain on the sidelines until the first quarterly disclosure as a public company. Markit though is a company to be keeping in touch with - and not just for its economic/related data output.
TSB inevitably is a quieter story given the need of Lloyds to partially spin-off some of its UK branch network operations for competition reasons. Those with a long memory will recall that TSB was one of the inaugural privatisations in the UK in the mid-1980s and, just like then, first day investors have been rewarded with the stock up 13% from the 260p IPO price at the time of writing. Well done any investors.
Reflecting good interesting Lloyds confirmed earlier today that the offer size
had been increased from 25 per cent to 35 per cent, or 175m of the 500m TSB
shares in issue at admission.
So does TSB offer any value? I took a quick look at some of the bank's disclosures and noted that 2016 hopes seem to congregate around a 350p tangible book value per share and a 8.5% tangible return on equity (currently 3.1%). If I put those two numbers together I get to around 308p a share (350* 0.88)...but that's 2016 and some discount should be applied. Somewhere between 10-20% seems about right and hence I think the shares were pretty sensibly valued at about a 260p IPO price (c. 15% discount to the 2016 theoretical value). Now, today investors are more sanguine but my view is to stay on the sidelines...especially when I can see better relative value in other UK financial names like RBS and Barclays (for reports on these two see here and here) who are also applying simplification / cost cutting stories. I have set a marker of 277p (10% discount to implied 2016 value) as a level to have another look against these other players in the UK market but am sticking with these alternative names today.
Finally Euronext. Well this one has not had such an interesting first day back on the markets (after parent Intercontinental Exchange was forced to divest the index operator as part of its larger NYSE Euronext acquisition last year). As Reuters reported:
'Shares in financial market operator Euronext started trading at 19.40 euros on Friday, 3 percent below the price set for its initial public offering. Parent Intercontinental Exchange had priced the shares at 20 euros late on Thursday, at the lower end of a previously announced IPO price range of 19-25 euros.
ICE said on Thursday that all 42.25 million shares offered were sold, representing 60.36 percent of the capital, implying a market value of 1.4 billion euros ($1.91 billion) for all of the company.
A group of European institutional investors bought a 33.4 percent stake in the market operator last Friday at a 4 percent discount to the IPO price, or 19.20 euros a share, in a move designed to allay local regulators' concerns that the pan-European bourse could be snapped up by another foreign firm'
Ah...the old 'special discount' and 'core investors'. No wonder ordinary investors and the market in general felt a bit peeved...
So who are Euronext? Well as the prospectus puts it:
'We are a pan-European exchange group, offering a diverse range of products and services and combining transparent and efficient equity, fixed income securities and derivatives markets in Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels, Lisbon and London. Our businesses comprise: listing, cash trading, derivatives
trading, market data & indices, post-trade and market solutions & other'
The better news is that we have been here before. The LSE (London Stock Exchange) trades on c. x13 EV/ebit and so Euronext on a static high single digit multiple looks ok valued even taking into account the pre-sale.
Any exchange business is going to be correlated with the market but I quite like the sound of Euronext especially if I can get the shares at or below the Euro19.2 'core investors' level. A newly liberated management with the scope to realign costs, pay a dividend etc. Liquidity will not be the best - but that can cut both ways. At Euro19.2 I will buy a few (Euro19.8 currently).
So a tale of three IPOs..all very different. The key is, as always, to keep looking and thinking about them.





Markit indexes are the backbone of the quadrillion dollar unlisted credit derivatives industry traded by global banks, and now MRKT trades, so double, triple and higher on goodwill alone.
ReplyDeleteYes, it is that 'natural monopoly' angle which is interesting. 90-95% revenues recurring. Having traded (ultimately successfully) companies like McGraw-Hill and Moody's it is a really nice trait...especially as Mr Market may push around the stock due to shorter-term trends. We've been here both with Twitter...and I think we both know how we reacted to volatility in that stock...
ReplyDelete