Pages

Friday, 9 May 2014

Symantec positively surprises...and is still good value

The last time I wrote about Symantec (link here) the cyber security company had just sacked their CEO.  See if you can spot when this happened a couple of months ago on the YTD chart:


Symantec has been a 'feast or famine' stock over the last few years, moving from seemingly good execution to material quarterly earnings misses.  This reflects the reality in a business where a high majority of the sales occur towards the back end of each quarter. 

Thursday's post close numbers though were a 'beat' and the stock has traded up to around US$21 as I write.  So what has suddenly turned around for a company who less than two months ago sacked their CEO is still slightly unclear circumstances?

The interim CEO and the still-getting-his-feet-under-the-desk CFO were fairly clear on the conference call with the former noting in his initial comments that:

'I'm pleased to report that we delivered revenue at the high end of guidance for the fourth quarter and exceeded guidance on operating margin and EPS. Two primary factors drove those results. First, we implemented the right changes to our go-to-market capabilities in fiscal '14, and we've seen improvement in year-over-year billings trends in each of the past 2 quarters, as expected. Second, we made progress reducing costs and, as a result, improved operating margin by 160 basis points, with a path of further expansion ahead'
It almost makes you wonder why they sacked the CEO...a later comment potentially clarified that particular issue:

'There's a lot of opportunity at Symantec, so we don't see that any differently than Steve (the previous CEO) did. But we need to be smarter about the choices we make of where to invest, and this process that Thomas (the new CFO) and I talked about, in terms of systematically looking at each product family, is telling us not only where to invest but where not to invest'.

Inevitably we will have to see over time how the company gets along with these aims.  What I DID like though was the quantitative clarity that the company gave for the next this fiscal year...

'...revenue is expected to be between $6.63 billion to $6.77 billion. Operating margin is expected to be between 27.7% to 28.2%, resulting in EPS in the range of $1.84 to $1.92. We expect cash flow from operations to grow in fiscal year '15 and CapEx to remain flattish to fiscal year '14 levels. We'll continue to return approximately $900 million of cash to shareholders in the form of both dividends and share repurchases'.
...and then the hope of 30% margins next year a year when the interim CEO 'couldn't be more excited about our growing markets, our industry-leading products and our world-class talent'.

Assume no revenue growth and apply the prospective hope of a 30% margin and that delivers operating profitability of a little under US$2bn.  Given Symantec's EV of under US$13bn that puts it on a prospective EV/ebit rating of around x6.5 (and a prospective P/E of just a little over x11).  Additionally the US$900m returned to shareholders (split pretty equally between dividends and share buybacks) is equal to around 7% of market cap. 

Issues remain plentiful including the inevitable uncertainties around the continuing CEO search, over initiatives such as the formation of the creation of a business unit for the Norton branded products that the company offers and finally competitive conditions in an industry where even Symantec acknowledged in the last week that:
'Antivirus "is dead," says Brian Dye, senior VP for information security at Symantec (SYMC), the company that pioneered such software in the late 1980s. Dye reckons that the products catch only 45% of cyberattacks. "We don't think of antivirus as a moneymaker in any way."...Except that antivirus still contributes over 40% of Symantec's revenues'.
A forward EV/ebit rating of x8 would reflect some of the uncertainties/issues above...but also implies a share price of a little over US$25.  That is my target.  Interestingly that is around the last year high:
 

No comments:

Post a Comment