Experience has told me that it is hard to generalise. The old mantra of 'profit warnings come in three's' is wise to heed but I could equally point to plenty of companies that have warned once, expectations have been re-set and they have gone on their merry profitable ways again.
That brings me to Dick's Sporting Goods. There is much to like about the (to quote their corporate website) 'authentic full-line sports and fitness specialty omni-channel retailer offering a broad assortment of high quality, competitively-priced brand name sporting goods equipment, apparel and footwear in a specialty store environment' with a history of expansion and smart looking stores. They even retain extension expansion plans both in physical stores and (unsurprisingly) online too.
This success is perhaps not as much a surprise as we should think given over 20,000 firms operate in the US retail sporting goods industry, but less than 200 have more than five stores.
But then this update came out a couple of days ago (with my emphasis added):
'Net sales for the first quarter of 2014 increased 7.9% to $1.4 billion. Consolidated same store sales increased 1.5%, compared to the Company's guidance of an approximate 3 to 4% increase... Same store sales in the first quarter of 2014 for DICK'S Sporting Goods increased 2.3%, while Golf Galaxy decreased 10.4%. "Our difficulties this quarter were isolated to two categories: golf and hunting," said Edward W. Stack, Chairman and CEO. "After a very challenging first quarter in golf last year, we expected some further headwinds and only modest improvement, but instead we saw a continued significant decline. In the case of hunting, we planned the business down based on last year's catalysts, but it was even weaker than expected." '
Golf and hunting? Where did that come from?
Well as a complement to the core sporting goods stores the company owns and operates Golf Galaxy, LLC, a golf specialty retailer with over 80 stores in 30 states but the hunting side is newer. The rationale for the latter is contained in the chart below...
...and you have to say the stores do you look fairly attractive from a consumer's perspective:
But their impact was quite material on guidance - unsurprising as the company states that collectively these two areas are in the latest quarter (the biggest for golf in a normal seasonal cycle) '30% of sales'.
'the Company currently anticipates reporting consolidated non-GAAP earnings per diluted share of approximately $2.70 to 2.85, excluding a gain on the sale of an asset. This compares to the previous expectation, provided on March 11, 2014, of $3.03 to 3.08 per diluted share...Consolidated same store sales are currently expected to increase approximately 1 to 3%, compared to a 1.9% increase in fiscal 2013. This compares to the previous expectation, provided on March 11, 2014, of an approximate 3 to 4% increase'
That's a c. 10% decrease in EPS...but the shares fell getting on for double that to levels not seen for over two years.
So are the shares now offering value? Well the good news is that the company essentially has no net debt AND is buying back shares. A US$1bn share buyback would be equivalent to c. 20% of the current market cap...
Additionally the comments about the core sporting eCommerce business continued to show exceptional growth and we saw significant strength in several categories in the first quarter, including womens and youth athletic apparel, footwear and team sports.
But what about the fears for the golf and hunting areas? A few comments from the conference call are illuminating. Re golf specifically one issue is:
'the core golfer doesn't seem to understand or has not yet fully embraced the new technology our vendors have brought to market. The technology in game improvement possibilities, especially in drivers are fantastic, but since it is not yet completely understood or embraced, the core golfer has not replaced his equipment...'
And then on the prospects over the rest of 2014 and into 2015:
'The hunt business (decline) we think is temporary. We think it gets relatively flat at the end of the year, so I would say that 2014 is a good base year for that hunt business going forward. But as I said in my remarks, we don't know where the bottom is in golf. We may be at the bottom...we are not sure where the cyclical bottom is to be for the golf business'
'I wanted to get your thoughts on -- what this shortfall in
the golf and the hunt as to how you view your 2017 target and your
achievability of the $10 million in sales and then 10.5% EBIT margins targets
that you laid out?'
The response from management was pleasing...especially as the final comment seems to imply that there was not much in for the Golf business:'I think we still feel that we can do that. We can meet those targets. As I said the hunt business is going to be -- we think it will stabilize. The golf business is going to be a bit more of a challenge but we have got opportunities in other areas. I've said such as the women's business, the youth business, that can make up -- we think a meaningful part of the sales and at a higher gross margin. So what we might be missing in sales -- the women's business and some of these other categories are at a higher margin rate than the golf business. And if you remember when we talked about our sales, the 2017 plan, we had very little growth from the Golf Galaxy standpoint there.'
That sounds like a trading strategy to me.





Thx for the sharp and enthusiastic analysis of DKS value on sale.
ReplyDeleteNo problem, enjoyed looking at it. Now let's see how they get on!
ReplyDeleteTurf Supplies
ReplyDeleteHancey Turf is a premier Turf Supplier and also provides a various turfing solution to make your home lawns and sports ground better. Website: www.hanceysturf.com.au
Contact information:
Phone number: 1800 761 334, 0439 306 616
E-mail: sales@hanceysturf.com.au
Interesting blog. This is one of my favorite blog also I want you to update more post like this. Thanks for sharing this article.
ReplyDeleteSports Goods Dealers in Chennai