Whatever way you look at it, the numbers from the UK food retailer Morrisons were pretty poor. I have written about the company a few times over recent months (with the most recent link here) and have built up a position with an average price in the mid 230s. So what to do with the share at new (multi-year) lows today?:
Listening to the company's conference call there is material change. As the CEO put it, there is a 'paradigm shift in the market to which we must respond...we must get much closer on price'. Unsurprisingly this has come from online and discounters:
Morrisons have launched their online initiative at the turn of the year - undoubtedly late but at least they have started. It is the discounters the company are more worried about, as shown below:
The impacts of this lost market share / enhanced competitive environment can be seen in the operating numbers disclosed earlier today...
...as well as the guidance given for their 2014-15 period where underlying earnings are expected to fall further...
...and a worsening of the balance sheet metrics. I note, in particular, that net assets fell by just over 10% with the rise in the net debt level as capex peaked and write-offs occurred. The business covenants are x3.5 net debt:ebitda and x3 interest cover - the business remains well inside these despite the issues above.
So what is the plan? Operationally the detail is laid out best in this slide:
None of this is a huge surprise - and follows elements of the turnaround strategy at Tesco albeit as with online shopping, initiatives such as a Morrisons card and expanding in convenience have already been launched/developed elsewhere.
So how to fund all of this given the balance sheet evolution noted above? First, the company noted the raising of £1bn via the sale of non-core assets / some property. Even though they will maintain an 'overwhelming freehold estate' this - combined with the capex reduction shown below as fewer larger supermarkets are built - help fund the above.
Not all of it will be spent on the new initiatives. Sensibly the company is looking to reduce net debt as noted below. Given the commitment to raise the dividend further in the next financial year (by at least 5%) the net debt reduction assumes a free cash flow yield of around 13% (albeit with over half of this from the property disposals).
As the management noted, this will 'take time to implement'. The plan has elements of logic, bravery and necessity to it. It will take time to implement and does suggest that profits do not bounce back to the 2013-14 levels for a while. Using the underlying 2014-15 profit guidance the company is currently trading on x14 EV/ebit with a prospective 6.3% dividend yield plus the sub-book value support.
As the Tesco turnaround has shown over the last couple of years, these initiatives can take a while - at a time when there is a lot of change (and initiatives) happening at other peers. Bears will anticipate continued tough trading and ultimately the removal of the current dividend support. Bulls will see income / book value supports and (as per my link above) private equity potential interest.
My view has been to buy some more shares today on the weakness. Nothing is guaranteed and there are clear risks but necessity businesses like food retailers don't go away easily. Scepticism to the space is extremely high - perhaps rightly so. Still, at the margin, always better to be greedy whilst others are fearful...









No comments:
Post a Comment