Pages

Tuesday, 25 February 2014

Sina - a sane or insane valuation? A value investor speaks...

Sina is in the headlines again.  Forget the Q4/FY numbers that came out yesterday that nominally beat, all the talk is of Weibo, the microblogging site they have a majority stake in. 


The Financial Times' Lex column nailed the debate by noting that:

 
So is Weibo a WhatsApp?  Well, Weibo may be the number two in China to Tencent's WeChat but progress remains very solid in Q4:
 
'Weibo ad revenue +163% Y/Y to $56M, Weibo non-ad revenue (data licensing, gaming, membership fees) +114% to $15.4M'
 
That is good year-on-year progress, but look at the absolute numbers.  US$70m Q4 revenues on a user base of 60m at the end of Q3 and reasonably close to 70m at the end of Q4 (I could not find a disclosure from the company on the number of Q4 users). 
 
So US$1 a user...interesting akin to the non-advertising but subscription payment per user charged in year two by WhatsApp.  So maybe the valuation is not too crazy...
 
On an akin theme, I thought this was an interesting article on Asian internet company valuations with the useful observation that:
 
'In North America, we’ve been told that Western users are worth more than international users.  That’s why Sina Weibo will only get a $3 – 5 billion valuation when it IPOs in a few months compared to the current $32 billion valuation for Twitter.  That’s even though Sina Weibo has a similar number of monthly active users as Twitter.  It turns out that an international user is only worth less than a Western user if you only sell ads...It all comes down to monetization of those users.  The Asian messaging companies are vastly ahead of the North American messaging companies in terms of how they monetize.  Therefore, the investors who know them best over there value them higher'

Ah...the Weibo IPO.  Alibaba (part-owned by Yahoo) bought an 18% stake for US$568m last year (US$3.2bn implied value) and has the option to up this stake to 30% pre-IPO.  Interesting call if they do this or not - I assume if they do then the value they see is higher than US$3.2bn...
 
 Of course the investment banks of the world are falling over themselves to suggest higher valuations.  Back to today's Financial Times.  This article was on the front page...US$4...5...6...8bn valuation. 
Sina (US$54m of income before tax in FY13) is not much without Weibo.  Just look how they talked about prospects for 2014: 
"The strong performance of Weibo's advertising and value-added services in the fourth quarter allowed us to end 2013 with strong top line and bottom line growth." said Charles Chao, Chairman and CEO of SINA.  "As we enter 2014, we will continue to focus on growing Weibo's user base and user engagement through product innovation, as well as seizing opportunities to enable us for long term growth."
So at the current US$4.4bn EV what should an investor think?  Well, given all the above, all eyes are on Alibaba.  That US$4bn EV level strikes me as interesting though - and usefully that is just below the US$65 level that has been the share's early February low point. 
 
 
Sina is undoubtedly highly volatile and suffers from speculative tendencies - as shown from the share price above.  Is there a price though that risk-reward should interest investors?  Yes. 
It might be volatile but that does not mean you should ignore it.
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment