Pages

Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Apache - an opportunity missed? Probably. Value still apparent? Yes.

Apache - the US-listed energy company - does know how to tease.  During the conference call after the publication of the Q4/FY numbers a few weeks ago the CEO noted that:

'we are going to provide our 2014 capital and production guidance at our Investor Day on February 26th as well as provide a longer term view of what we believe our high graded portfolio is capable of achieving. I think you are going to be pleased with what you see'

Well...the share price reaction today of down 3%+ (and back to that book value level of c. US$80) begs to differ:


So what has disappointed the market?  Well, simply put, the presentation pack at 175 pages was high on information per se...but there was little in there to excite beyond factors well-known and discussed at length in previous quarterly reports (and written up here and here for example).

175 pages...in four charts.  First...selling assets is good but it does half knock pro-forma production.  I think the degree of the difference here may have surprised a few people:

 Second...there is growth, especially in Americas liquids (and the overall global growth cannot be sniffed at too).  I like that number...
 


...and the general 2014 observations too.  However, there seems only a few new numbers here including some unscheduled North Sea outages and mixed Australia news.  So great production growth headlines but some shabbiness in the detail. 

 
 
Finally, Egypt - which unsurprisingly was reviewed in depth.  Ahhh...the pro-forma hit again although this time due to the risk-reducing (and well-received) Sinopec deal.  It was probably the right thing to sell half a politically charged asset...but look at that cashflow.  They did sell on a low cash flow multiple.  

And that's it.  Of course some observations about continuing the share buy back, hoping to continue in progressing the dividend and engaging in "serious discussions" with potential buyers for some of its 50% in the Kitimat liquefied natural gas project in British Columbia.  But the more radical hopes of a clear intention to strike a number of further deals to highlight value and boost the share price well above book value...well there was very little. 

So an opportunity missed?  Probably.  Value still as discussed in previous reports?  Yes.  Scope for 'surprise' new deals/value-adding strategies?  Of course. 

I bought some more stock near the low of the day sub US$80.  As I said a few weeks ago at the time of the Q4/FY announcement:

'Apache shares should return to the US$90+ share price zone on pure value alone' 

The investor day though was not the immediate catalyst I was hoping for.  The opportunity remains though but, as with all value ones, it will take some time. 

No comments:

Post a Comment