Pages

Monday, 11 November 2013

UK losers #1 - RSA: back near a Pound after three issues

In another life, getting on for eighteen months ago, I rolled up to the HQ of Royal and Sun Alliance (RSA) to gain an update from the investor relations team. 

It proved to be an opportune time.  The share was kicking around the £1 (100p) level and, over an hour or so, I heard about the dull but firming motor/home insurance market in the UK but also a very interesting international growth story with strong Scandinavian, Canadian and emerging market assets.  You can see their importance here:


Buying some shares proved to be one of my better 2012 calls.  So it is with great interest that I see that RSA is again within touching distance of 100p. 



It has proved to be a very tough last week or so for the RSA management team with not only a disappointing corporate update (bad weather centric) but then - late last Friday - breaking news of some potentially problematic activity at their Irish unit. 

There is lots of uncertainty from the above.  The management team are running around investors this week and clearly there is going to be a lot of necessary hand-holding and explanation.

But - simply put - is there an opportunity again after today's big share price fall?

I think there is - for two reasons.  The business may seem to be getting worse - and clearly the Irish allegations suggest divisional oversight issues - but the underlying fundamentals are still on track. 

Now clearly the below H1 2013 return on equity statistics will now clearly be wrong (e.g. 12% Ireland/Italy RoE) but look at the data more closely.  If there ever was a case for somebody to look to break-up RSA then this is the moment.  There have been rumours about Aviva or Allianz sniffing around.  Well, the company suddenly got cheaper.

As a combined group - with the stated hope of a move to a 12% return on equity over the next couple of years - the group was worth (with a NAV of around 102p) up to 125p.  Plus there is the 5%+ yield (should be sustainable after the earlier 2013 reduction, the first of the three issues which has driven the share down). 

This underlying value still exists but investors - at near a Pound - are unsurprisingly not discounting it at all.  Not with the 10%+ hole in profit hopes due to the Irish allegations and a further 5-6% cut due to the Q3 weak trading.  In reality full adjustment for the above would take the shares to around 110p.  Nearer a Pound is just supreme negative sentiment. 

This progressive underlying improvement is also seen in the positive rate environment - even in the difficult UK market, where they are clearly traded off on volume to keep prices up (the correct policy in my opinion). 


So put all that together and...

Below 110p pessimistic market views are being applied.  In my opinion - and it is just an opinion, please do your own research - investors are well-rewarded at this level.

The fairer value remains nearer 125p plus there is the 5% dividend.

If Aviva/Allianz ever wanted to look at the company...then this is the time.

RSA suddenly got interesting again. 

1 comment:


  1. The very heart of your writing shilst sounding agreeable at first, did not settle very well with me personally after some time. Someplace within the paragraphs you were able to make me a believer but just for a while. I nevertheless have a problem with your leaps in assumptions and one would do well to fill in those breaks. In the event you actually can accomplish that, I will definitely end up being fascinated.
    Its such as you learn my thoughts! You seem to grasp so much approximately this, such as you wrote the ebook in it or something. I think that you simply can do with some% to force the massage house a bit, however other than that this is magnificent blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.
    Progressive Property Hands Free Investing

    ReplyDelete