Pages

Friday, 1 November 2013

Sony: is Mr Loeb still onto something?

Sony shares are volatile today following the earnings publication yesterday. They have still more than doubled in the last year but now are down more than 20% from the interim high of a few months ago:


Some of the excitement over recent months has been centred on the activist investor Dan Loeb of Third Point taking a stake and corresponding, in a public fashion concerning a potential spin-out of the entertainment business, with the Sony board. 

So, what was the underlying problem with Sony shares?  As per Bloomberg.com:

Sony’s net income will probably total 30 billion yen ($305 million) in the year ending in March 2014, the Tokyo-based company said in a statement yesterday, cutting its August projection for 50 billion yen in profit. The company also posted a second-quarter loss.

Even with Japan’s weaker yen, five of Sony’s nine divisions posted operating losses in the second quarter.

I have noted already in this earnings season that the weaker Yen has been an artificial benefit to many Japanese companies...but apparently not Sony.

Take their five electronics businesses.  In the Sony Q2 2012 these businesses collectively made a loss of -Y4.6bn.  In Q2 2013 the loss was -Y4.2bn...and this was despite a Y19.5bn forex benefit. 

Looking at the details, demand conditions continued to be poor for a range of products from TVs to cameras. 

The Pictures business also moved into loss after some poor movie releases, but Music and the Finance division at least managed to move forward.  2013-14 forecasts for these three divisions were held. 

Sony lends itself to a sum-of-the-parts analysis.  On the electronics side, if I extrapolate H1 profit here (Q1 was profitable assisting the H1 period to be profitable too) and place the division on a (low) x8 EV/ebit valuation you get a value of Y165bn. 

Clearly there is a risk that Q2-style loss-making trading is a guide to the rest of the financial year.  Nevertheless, this value equates to approximately 3% of sales.  That's low. 


Music and pictures were overall mixed performers as noted above.   I still think Music warrants a x10 EV/ebit valuation and this Y410bn.  Pictures is loss-making at the moment, but at x0.1 sales, has a value of Y67bn.  Undoubtedly too low given the next hit film or TV show could be just around the corner...but prudent.

Finally onto the financial services division.  The company never breaks out fully the influence of the markets on this division. Clearly there is some risk here but I got a value of Y1363bn for this division (x8 ebit). 

Adding all this together gives Y2005bn or a share price of Y1926, 15% above the current share price.  This is clearly lower than before...but with the shares where they are, an opportunity has presented itself on a risk-adjusted basis.  I still think Mr Loeb is onto something.  And there is still the opportunity of better trading.

The investor day on 21st November should be an interesting event: a management with more explaining to do and unhappy investors. 

No comments:

Post a Comment