Pages

Thursday, 7 November 2013

EEEK - a European consumer update from Coca-Cola Hellenic

In early September, just prior to its FTSE100 entry, I took a look at Coca-Cola Hellenic Bottling, a distributor of a variety of beverages products - including Coca-Cola - across a large part of central, southern and eastern Europe.  The company originally had been listed in Greece but had pursued a London-listing in the hope of a higher valuation / greater attraction to international investors.  Due to its size, after serving a suitable listing period, it joined the FTSE100 a couple of months ago. 

So, how did the inaugural FTSE100 results look?  I guess the stand-out comments by the company were these (with my emphasis added):

'We face continuing challenging comparables in our emerging markets and we expect varying levels of performance in the last quarter. Although we were pleased to see the rate of decline in the established and developing segments moderate in the third quarter, we are cautious, as the consumer sentiment remains under pressure. We do not anticipate the current trading conditions to change in the last quarter of the year'.

Pretty cautious stuff for a company involving in relatively low ticket price consumer goods.  The short conclusion could be: it remains tough out there.  At least they did not change guidance. 

Looking in more detail, you can see the reason for the company's caution.  Page one of their quarterly results document and the below chart is reproduced.  There are a lot of negatives in the '% change' columns.  Still, a least the currency neutral net revenue line per unit case was small positive - not much consolation however. 


 
I found some good insights though from comparing how the company's different geographic regions got on. 
 
In Established (markets such as Greece, Switzerland) the spectre of 'negative price/mix' raised itself along with lower volumes etc.  
 

Developing (broadly non-Russia bloc Eastern Europe) was better with price-mix offsetting negative FX impact


Whilst Emerging (Russia, Ukraine, Romania, Nigeria etc) positive price-mix was not enough to offset other headwinds


Looking at the business overall, with the better-performing Developing the smallest division (see below) it is no surprise that the profit line is still struggling.

 
Looking into other aspects of the numbers, free cash flow during Q3 was good at just under Euro250m (Euro345m for the first 9 months of the year).  The company is still sticking to their 2012-15 three year free cash flow generation of Euro1.3bn, which is inline with the cash flow generation seen so far this year.  That's around a 6% free cash flow yield of which c. 2% is paid out. That gives the company options with net debt around x2 ebitda currently.

With an EV of around Euro9bn the company is still trading on around x20 EV/ebit.  I noted in my previous piece that a return to historic peak profitability would pull this ratio down to around x12 EV/ebit which would be a more reasonable number.  The problem is - as the company themselves said - having the right environment to do this. 

On that basis a discount is appropriate today, even adjusting for longer-term growth potential (the soft drink beverage consumption in many of these countries is very low - see my earlier linked report for charts on this).

The c. 1500p level seen in July pre the FTSE100 index squeeze still seems more appropriate. 

No comments:

Post a Comment