Pages

Thursday, 26 September 2013

World trade insights - the contrast of Maersk and Li & Fung in a world of immediacy

For two companies that are supposed to be plays on world trade, Li & Fung and AP Moeller-Maersk have had rather divergent experiences recently.  The 3 year share price charts are really quite strikingly different with Maersk pushing up to its 2010/11 highs...


...whilst Li & Fung is around the lows for the period


 
I have looked at both companies before.  I last wrote Maersk up after its Q2 results and concluded (see the link here ) that the company was operating in volatile markets but that the combination of cost cutting and a proposed new container shipping joint venture (which would heighten industry concentration levels) would help the shares.  Helped by the strong oil prices, the shares did indeed break the c. DKK45-47k share price resistance level. 

By contrast Li & Fung, the Hong Kong listed global products supplier, worried me intrinsically when I reviewed their half year numbers (link here).  They seemed to be working very hard just to stand still.  Part of the problem they have is centred on their own customers - such as the large retailers - pushing ever harder their just-in-time inventory management systems. 

This reached a peak yesterday when press stories starting circulating that WalMart - responsible for around 15% of Li & Fung's sales - was reducing inventory levels as per a Bloomberg report:

Li & Fung sank 3.1 percent to HK$11.42 even after the supplier of toys and clothes said Wal-Mart is continuing to place orders for 2014 as usual. Wal-Mart said it was cutting orders to suppliers this quarter and next to address rising inventory. the company flagged in last month’s earnings report.

By contrast, AP Moeller-Maersk at their capital markets day sounded relatively upbeat about world trade with CFO Stausholm being quoted that

"We believe we've reached the bottom of the cycle...This is an extreme environment. But there are early signals that world trade is returning,"

Regular readers may remember that FedEx (fully written up here) had this interesting chart in their presentation:


And just like Maersk seemed to be able to work-through any difficulties via cost cutting and opportunistically increasing capacity where it was warranted. 

It seems to me that in a world of immediacy that logistics is prized and middle men suppliers are potentially squeezed.  All are exposed to big trade slowdowns but in terms of differentiated value in today's world...logistics wins out.  Now all the value investor has to wait for is a period of global growth concerns amongst market participants...

No comments:

Post a Comment