Pages

Tuesday, 3 September 2013

Back to school - leading consumer names talk

Yes, it is that time of year again.  Beyond new shoes, sharpened pencils and lost children looking for the right classroom, one of the world's leading investment banks holds a 'back to school' conference for a variety of (generally American) consumer names.  Here are a few highlights so far:

Altria -

Most famous for their Marlboro brand of course, but I thought this was a fascinating chart.  The rise of e-cigarettes (electronic cigarettes) has been a strong theme in recent months.  If there ever is any form of revenue convergence over time with conventional tobacco products...well you can see why the tobacco companies are very interested in the space.


Pan-sector comparison charts are always insightful.  Note tobacco shares (respectively Altria, Reynolds America, Lorillard and Philip Morris International) take the top four slots on a dividend payout ratio basis


Another comparison graphic on dividend yield.  This one really speaks for itself. 


So what do we think about Altria shares here?  Taking into account the monetary value of the stake in SAB Miller the shares are trading just under x8 EV/ebit which, for a company that just confirmed mid-to-high single digit EPS growth plus a continuation of the aforementioned dividend payout, this seems a little rude.



Brown-Forman -

We talked about the beverages/spirits company last week (in an unusual match-up with Joy Global, see the report here).  Whilst we are not buyers of the shares today, there were some interesting insights from the presentation. 

First...even strong branded consumer names have slowed down growth-wise in the last few years (it also does not help that a company gets bigger quickly when it posts historic growth numbers like Brown-Forman have):

Again, a useful insight into premiumisation/premium brands which, as shown in the chart on the left, is still a group that is growing faster than any other in the market


Finally, a reminder that in Brown-Forman's case, a majority of this growth has come from outside the US.  Emerging markets generally do matter for the consumer names.



Finally, I took a look at the presentation for JM Smucker who are famous for, amongst other areas,  peanut butter, shortening and oils, fruit spreads, canned milk, baking mixes and ready-to-spread frostings, flour and baking ingredients, juices and beverages, frozen sandwiches, dessert toppings, syrups, pickles and condiments, and potato side dishes.

I have never undertaken a detailed analysis of this company but the valuation does not look particularly cheap, nor the dividend yield particularly high.  Nevertheless they had one fascinating chart in their presentation document which captured much of the massive re-rating there has been in the branded and often global consumer goods sector over recent years (as investors have paid up for 'stability'):

Note how the market cap growth over the last five years has been materially higher than the sales or earnings growth over the same period.  This implies a material re-rating in ratios such as P/E.  Cash flow from operations is more in line with the share price growth.  Any full analysis should include a cash flow appraisal too.  Cash is king after all. 

2 comments:

  1. I like to buy big dips in cash flow for future value.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, I agree. Cash flow yield is a great filter for helping understanding the worth of businesses. I am sure many of the consumer staple stocks are trading on big multiples because of the far superior pre-dividend/buyback free cash yield versus bonds, as admirably shown in the Altria chart near the top of the posting.

    ReplyDelete