I wrote up the Applied Materials / Tokyo Electron 'merger' last week on the day it was announced. You can find the full piece here.
There were many aspects to this deal but I concluded, just under a week ago, that:
'Of course, the number one (Applied Material) and number three (Tokyo Electron) coming together in any industry is probably good news at the margin. But unlike my write-up of similar moves in the advertising industry, the multiples are high here already.
My call is that disappointment may prevail after the initial response (Applied Material up 6% as I write, Tokyo Electron to follow in Japan tomorrow no doubt)'.
Now, there was a response in the shares of both companies immediately after the deal was announced, as shown by the performance of Applied Materials shares over the last ten days (it is easy to spot when the deal was announced):
I had the opportunity to hear some first-hand thoughts from representatives of Tokyo Electron earlier today. A few highlights:
I observed in my initial piece on the deal that trading conditions for nearly all semiconductor equipment makers have been very tricky recently. Tokyo Electron agreed with this as they 'didn't achieve very well...in this tough industry'.
Additionally I also noted that the big overlap was in the 'etch' division with potentially a 70% market share. Tokyo Electron were at pains to note that, in their opinion, market share was lower in different customer bases (NAND, logic, non-flash etc). Essentially they believe that any anti-trust issues would be fairly small.
On synergies (initially mooted at US$250m over the first year and US$500m over the first three years), no further information was given. Shorter-term these gains are clearly going to be from squeezing suppliers and related activities. Clearly though greater scope remains but this would start to include shutting facilities and reducing staff and the company is not going to talk about this yet, apart from they did not that Japanese employees were harder to cut (labour laws etc).
So far face-to-face talks with leading customers of the proposed combined entity have been 'supportive'.
Finally, on the operations, the new venture will 'decide what we will do' with the solar business in February/March 2014 and the dividend policy for the combined entity was not yet fixed.
So what can we take from this discussion to augment my earlier conclusions?
Some good news, especially with regard to potential anti-trust issues and the apparent initial reaction of the leading customers of the proposed combination.
I feel though that the company is going to have to make some difficult decisions about locations and personnel. This will strain any combination...let alone one which spans America and Japan.
The bounce has clearly been well-received by both groups of shareholders. Now matters get a bit more difficult.

No comments:
Post a Comment